718THE AMERICAn ECOnOMIC REVIEWJunE 2008other words, a* 5 1. Note, also, that 100 percent is the upper bound (i.e., no leverage) for the allocation to risky assets in discrete time if background wealth is risky (in the sense that there is a strictly positive probability that background wealth can fall to an arbitrarily small value over the next period).
These results suggest that we can incorporate the effects of housing wealth and labor income into our model by approximating a* < 1, i.e., by assuming that a CRRA investor without habit would invest about 100 percent of his liquid wealth in stocks. By making this approximation, we effectively assume that the habit does most of the lifting required to get risky asset shares below 100 percent in our portfolio choice model. This is eminently consistent with the spirit of habit-formation equilibrium models where the habit does most of the lifting to get a sizeable equity risk premium.
The benefit of this approximation is that the optimal portfolio share no longer depends on background wealth, and that it varies over time only because of variation in X /1Wt 2 Ct2, not because of variation in a*:
(7) at < 1 2 X.Wt2CtRf
Equation (7) provides the basis for the main tests in the paper. The analyses where we assume a* < 1 should be interpreted as a test of the joint hypothesis that habits lead to time-variation in risky asset shares and that the variation induced by habits dominates the effects of variation in background risks.
But we also examine alternative specifications where we relax the a* < 1 assumption. Allowing for a range of values that are still relatively close to one, say 0.9 # a* # 1, would make little difference as long as variation in X /1Wt 2 Ct2 dominates variation in a*. If a* is instead substan-tially smaller than one, we have to take into account that a changing composition of wealth can change the degree to which stock market risk is diversified away in background wealth. We relax the a* < 1 approximation in two heuristic ways.
First, when we look at the liquid risky asset share, we control for the relative magnitude of background wealth. We use the labor income/liquid wealth ratio interacted with age, the business wealth/liquid wealth ratio, and the housing wealth/liquid wealth ratio, which should help capture variation in a*. In the end, we find that these controls have little effect. This is consistent with cross-sectional analysis in the literature. Heaton and Lucas (2000) and Yao and Zhang (2005) find little evidence that these asset composition ratios are correlated with liquid risky asset shares (among households that participate in the stock market), perhaps with the exception of the rela-tive share of business wealth, which seems to have some small negative impact. These empirical findings also support our approximation assumption a* < 1.
Second, we look at the financial wealth (liquid plus housing plus business wealth) risky asset share. On the right-hand side of equation (6), one must then redefine Wt as financial wealth. The only background wealth component left out is human wealth, which is difficult to measure. We include the labor income/financial wealth ratio interacted with age as a proxy for background human wealth.
B. Implications for Time-Variation in
Risky Asset Holdings
We are interested in the implications of habit formation for time-variation in the willingness to hold risky assets. To obtain our estimating equation, we first linearize equation (7),
s Varying Risk Aversion on the Dynamics of Asset Price Fluctuations Baosheng...At each time step t, every agent decides how to allocate his wealth ...
s Varying Risk Aversion on the Dynamics of Asset Price Fluctuations Baosheng...At each time step t, every agent decides how to allocate his wealth ...
热门文档