VOL. 98 nO. 3BRunnERMEIER AnD nAgEL: WEALTH AnD TIME-VARyIng RISk AVERSIOn719
(8)
at 5 1 2 5 1 2 exp 1x 2 wt2XWt2CtRf
where x K log 1X / Rf 2, wt K log 1Wt 2 Ct24, and the last approximate equality follows from a first-order Taylor approximation, where r and k are constants, and r . 0 . Intuitively, when Wt is close to X, changes in Wt have a big effect on X / Wt at the margin, but the effect is small when Wt is big. This feature is preserved by linearizing around the mean log habit-wealth ratio, such that at is linear in log liquid wealth. Then, the bigger Wt , the smaller the marginal impact of an increase in Wt .
Taking first differences of equation (8), we get
(9) Dat 5 rDwt .< k 2 r 1x 2 wt2,
This result depends on our assumption that X is approximately constant. As discussed above, it can be justified, for example, by looking at idiosyncratic wealth shocks and X as an external habit that is not affected by idiosyncratic wealth shocks, or with X as an internal habit that is slowly moving, and so reacts only very sluggishly to changes in wealth. Equation (9) forms the basis for our empirical tests.
Anticipated versus unexpected Wealth Changes.—When taking our model to the data, an important question is whether the relationship between changes in liquid wealth and portfolio shares would be modified if changes in liquid wealth were partly anticipated. It turns out that this distinction does not matter for the validity of our tests.
Consider the following example. At t 5 1 , the agent expects to receive a big one-time payment, for example an inheritance from a rich uncle, in period t 5 2. Let’s assume that the probability of getting the inheritance is high, and the risk of obtaining or not obtaining it (for example, because the uncle prefers to donate the money to charity) and the value of the uncle’s assets are uncor-related with stock market returns. The key point is that a small probability of not getting the inheritance is sufficient to make the anticipated inheritance unsuitable as a means to insure future habit. Hence, at t 5 1, the agent still needs to invest 1X / Rf 2 in riskless assets to insure future habit, despite the anticipated inheritance. Only when the inheritance is actually received at t 5 2, but not before, liquid wealth increases relative to 1X / Rf 2, and the risky asset share increases.In this example, the dollar amount of stock holdings moves one-for-one with realized changes in the dollar amount of liquid wealth, despite the fact that the agent anticipated the change in liquid wealth. One can show that a similar logic applies when the agent invests less than 100 percent of surplus wealth in stocks, with nonconstant, but slow-moving habits, and when one incorporates the consumption-savings decision. In Appendix A.2 of Brunnermeier and Nagel (2006), we numerically solve a three-period model that illustrates these effects.5
Note that in our empirical data, we measure post-consumption wealth each period, so the definition of wt corre-sponds to the definition of wealth in the data.5 It may be useful at this point to draw an analogy to the consumption literature. Power utility implies a precaution-ary savings motive. In that case, consumers faced with an expectation of a big inflow in the near future, but which can be low or zero with strictly positive probability, would hesitate to run down savings to raise today’s consump-tion, because that would expose them to a small, but significant, risk that consumption might be extremely low in the 4
s Varying Risk Aversion on the Dynamics of Asset Price Fluctuations Baosheng...At each time step t, every agent decides how to allocate his wealth ...
s Varying Risk Aversion on the Dynamics of Asset Price Fluctuations Baosheng...At each time step t, every agent decides how to allocate his wealth ...
热门文档