VOL. 98 nO. 3BRunnERMEIER AnD nAgEL: WEALTH AnD TIME-VARyIng RISk AVERSIOn717Thus, our problem maps into the problem of a CRRA investor with wealth Wt*, consumption Ct*, and risky asset portfolio share at*. If expected returns and volatility are constant, at* 5 a*, i.e., it is constant, as we know from Paul Samuelson (1969). Then, the risky asset share of our habit utility investor, as a fraction of post-consumption wealth at time t, is
(6) at 5 a* A1 2 XB.Wt2CtRf
We now see that at is increasing in Wt , holding X constant. The agent invests the present value of the future habit, X / Rf , in riskless assets, and surplus wealth over and above that amount like a CRRA investor. Hence, if Wt is close to X / Rf , the agent’s effective relative risk aversion is high, because most of the wealth is used to self-insure the stream of future habit. If Wt is a lot larger than X / Rf , the agent invests approximately like a CRRA investor.
So far, the agent’s wealth is composed entirely of liquid wealth, by which we mean the sum of stocks and riskless bonds. In a more realistic model, however, the household would also have so-called background wealth, i.e., labor income, housing wealth, and perhaps wealth in a private business. Labor income and business ownership are sources of risky income. Home equity rep-resents a risky asset if the household expects to sell at some point, say at retirement (or trade to a house of a different size, or in a different location).2 The presence of background wealth com-plicates the relationship between liquid wealth levels, habit, and the proportion of liquid wealth allocated to stocks, because a*, and hence also at , depend on how much background wealth the agent has, and on the riskiness of background wealth. This makes the portfolio choice problem quite untractable.
Fortunately, the existing literature shows that as long as the returns on background wealth have a relatively low correlation with stock returns (for which there is some empirical support), the main effect of risky background wealth is a diversification effect. That is, the presence of background wealth allows the household to diversify away some of the risks of stocks, reducing the aversion to holding stocks.3 This diversification effect can simplify the problem.
The very purpose of habit-formation models is to try to explain facts about asset returns and consumption with moderate values for the felicity curvature parameter g. For example, Campbell and Cochrane (1999) set g 5 2 and the habit is responsible for the lion’s share of effective relative risk aversion and its variation over time; the curvature of the felicity function would induce very little relative risk aversion in the absence of the habit. For such moderate values of g, realisti-cally calibrated models of household portfolio choice with CRRA preferences and background wealth, such as Haliassos and Carol C. Bertaut (1995), Heaton and Lucas (1997), Joao F. Cocco (2005), Cocco, Gomes, and Pascal Maenhout (2005), and Rui Yao and Harold H. Zhang (2005), all find that households should basically invest 100 percent of their liquid wealth in stocks. In
Costs of adjusting the holdings of illiquid background wealth can also lead to an additional effect of house owner-ship that relates to one of the possible interpretations of X. Recognizing that housing is often financed by collateralized borrowing (mortgage), and that many households own a house for most of their life, one can view housing as a long-lived durable good to which the household has committed financial resources of future periods, and whose consump-tion is very costly to adjust. In this case, the mortgage payments have the same consequences as a habit. The agent uses riskless assets to self-insure and be able to meet future mortgage payments to avoid large adjustment costs of trading down to a smaller house. This effect is analyzed in Chetty and Szeidl (2005) and X can be viewed as incorporating the effects of habits and of such committed future payments.3 It’s important to distinguish here between models that examine the effect of adding mean-zero background risks (e.g., Christian Gollier and John W. Pratt 1996) from the portfolio choice literature that’s our focus here, where back-ground wealth is added, which has positive mean returns.2
s Varying Risk Aversion on the Dynamics of Asset Price Fluctuations Baosheng...At each time step t, every agent decides how to allocate his wealth ...
s Varying Risk Aversion on the Dynamics of Asset Price Fluctuations Baosheng...At each time step t, every agent decides how to allocate his wealth ...
热门文档