Several correlations among observables derived from modelling the high-energy properties of GRBs have been reported in the literature. We show that well-known examples of these have common features indicative of an origin in selection effects. In particula
GRBCorrelations
3
portantforSwiftduetoarcsecondX-raylocalizations.Westressthatacorrelationisnotintrinsicsimplybe-causetriggerthresholdingcanberuledoutasin uenc-ingthesurveys(see,e.g.,Amatietal.2002).Stud-iesareunderwaytobetterunderstandthetruncationsandtopotentiallyinferwhetheranyintrinsice ectsarediscernibleintheradically-truncatedpre-Swiftsurveys(e.g.,Ghirlandaetal.2008).
3.THEANATOMYOFACORRELATION
Pre-Swift,afterglow-erasatellitesdonothavesensitiv-itiesthatvarybyordersofmagnitude(see,e.g.,Band03);we ndthatdiagnosingthereliabilityofacorrela-tionplottedonalog-logscaleforthesedataalonecan-note ectivelybedonebylookingatvariationsinthenormalizationsalone.Wecaninsteadexaminehowtheregressionslopeandscattervarywithassumptionsonthenatureofthecorrelation.Inthissectionweoutlineacartoon-ish,butinsightful,mathematicalmodel.
IfweassumethatallGRB tparametershavethesameerror,theerrorscanbeignored.ConsiderobserverframequantitiesX=log(Sbol)andY=log(Efor′example.Thesetranslatetosourceframequantitiespk,obs),X=X+bZ=log(Eiso)andY′=Y+aZ=log(Eexample.Here,Z=log(1+z)anda=1,b≈pk),for3(accurateto20%for0.5<z<5,representingthebulkofknownGRBredshifts).
Ifweassumeanoriginintheobserverframe,crosstermsinvolvingtheobservablesandzcanbeignored,andtheexpectedsource-frameregressionm= slopeis:
m Z2
srcobs+ab X2
.(1)
Here, . denotesanaverageaftersubtractingawaythemeaninXorZ,andm1givestheobsistheslopeintheobserverframe.Equationslopeoftheapparentsourceframerelationgiventheobserveddata,whereasdeter-minationofthetruesourceframerelationrequiresde-tailedknowledgeoftheGRBratedensityandluminos-ityfunctiontoimputethemissingdata.Althoughre-centprogresshasbeenmadeonmeasuringthese(e.g.,Kistleretal.2007),wedonotattemptheretorecon-structmGRBobs[mstudiessrc,true].Moreover,forcomparisonwithmostwhichsimplyassumemsrcEquation,true=m(e.g.,Firmanietal.2005),weonlyrequire1.srcRelativelyindependentofwhichsurveyweuse, Z2 / X2 ≈0.1,andmsrc≈mobs.Thisisthetypi-calexpectedbehaviorforGRBcorrelationswhereXorYaretypicallymuchmorebroadlydistributedthanZ.However,arti cialcorrelationsinthecasem(e.g.,considerWillingaleetal.2007),obsmayalsooccurdependingonthealgebraicarrangementofobservablesgoingintoXandY.
ThescatterinYaboutthebest- tregressionlineis
σ2src= (Y msrcX)2 +(a msrcb)2 Z2 .
(2)
CovariancetermsbetweenXandZorbetweenYandZ—whichgenerallyacttodecreasethescatterinthesourceframeascomparedtotheobserverframe—aredroppedbecauseweassumethecorrelationisnon-intrinsic.Tobeexplicit,rearrangementlikeEpk∝E0.5
ofanequation
,andthisisoshowsthattheobservablesshouldvarywithzimpliescrosstermsinEquation2.The
crosstermsgotozeroifthecorrelationisdueto(z-independent)observationale ects.
The rstterminEquation2isboundfromthebottombyσ2obs;equalityisobtainedformsrc=mobs.Thesec-ondterminEquation2impliesanincreaseinσ2
overσ2
src
obsunless,coincidentally,a=msrcb.Interestingly,this“coincidence”issatis ednearlyorexactlyformanyoftheknownGRBcorrelations.
Asanexample,considertheGhirlandacorrelation:Epk∝E0γ.7et,whereEγ∝Eisoθ2
al.(2004)
ergyreleasecorrectedforbeamingintoajetjetistheen-ofangleθcaseofauniformdensitymediumsurrounding
jet.ForthetheGRB(Sarietal.1999),θ2
3/4T3/4thetimeinthejet∝E 1/4observeriso(1+z) framewherejet,whereTjetisthejettinge ectsareexpectedtobecomeapparent.Sub-stitutingintoequations1and2,itfollowsthatX=3/4log(SbolTjet),Y=log(Epk,obs),a=1andb≈3/2.Hence,a≈msrcb,asalsodemonstratedgraphicallyinFigure2A.TheGhirlandaetal.(2004)correlationis,therefore,e ectivelyindependentofthemeasuredphoto-metricredshifts.ForthedatainFigure2A,σσinsigni cantobs=0.17dexandσsrc=0.16dex(i.e.,0.9decreasefromanF-test).
Asaninterestingside-notewhichfurthersuggestsapaucityofintrinsicphysics,thissamebalancingischaracteristicofsimilarrelationsfoundassumingin-steadawind-strati edmedium(Navaetal.2006)orevenallowingθ(Liang&ZhangjettovaryarbitrarilywithT2005).ThelatterrelationhasjetandEthesmall-isoestσsrc,whichleadsustosuspectthattheonlyreasonthataverylargenumberofcorrelationsdonotaboundintheliteratureisthatwetypicallyrestricttothosethancanbeinterpretedphysically,or,shortofthis,werequiretheobservablestoevolvewithredshiftinaphysicallyplausiblefashion(e.g.,Tjet,src=Ttheseconstraints,itispossiblejet/(1+z)).With-outtoinventhighly-signi cantbutabsurdrelations(e.g.,redshiftedSwifttriggernumberversusredshiftedburstduration;Figure2B)whichmakeamockeryofallcorrelationstudies.
4.MINIMALREQUIREMENTSFORNEWCORRELATIONS
WeshowaboveforGRBsobservedwithmultiplesatel-litesthatfourexamplecorrelationsreportedintheGRBliteraturecanbeexplainedintermsofselectione ects.Contrarily,thereisnoconvincing,non-a-posteriorex-planationforthecorrelationsinthesourceframe.ThisstronglysuggeststhatthesehavenothingtodowiththeintrinsicphysicsofGRBs.Ourresultscanbetestedfur-therusingpre-Swiftdataonceweextendthosecatalogsdowntothedetectionthreshold uxlevelsorestablishthedominanttruncationmechanisms.
Independentoftheargumentthatthecorrelationsareduetotruncatione ects,acommonz-independenceiseitherveryoddordamning.Aswediscuss,thisisonecharacteristicofatight,apparentsource-framecorrela-tionwhicharisespurelyduetoselectione ects.Itcannotbeaconsequenceofintrinsicphysics,becausetheGRBcannotpossiblyknowhowthedistancetotheobservershouldvarywithz.Wecautionthatthebalancingof1+ztermsimpliesthecorrelationscannotbeusedtoin-ferz.Moreover,usingtheobservablesandspectroscopicredshiftstoconstructaHubblediagramandtestconcor-dancecosmology(e.g.,Schaefer2007)iscircular,because
Track Jumps in Hardness-Intensity Correlations of GRB Pulse Decays_文学_高等教育_教育专区。Abstract. The hardness-intensity correlation (HIC), during the ...
Perley Can We Trust GRB High Energy Correlations?...S. Bloom On the Selection Effects of the Epeak...Shocks: Physics Predictions, Observational Tests . ...
Correlations of Prompt a... 暂无评价 13页 ...selection effects: In any GRB trigger algorithm ...(1) does appear to lead the high energy ...
Correlations of Prompt a... 暂无评价 13页 ...selection effects: In any GRB trigger algorithm ...(1) does appear to lead the high energy ...
热门文档