Several correlations among observables derived from modelling the high-energy properties of GRBs have been reported in the literature. We show that well-known examples of these have common features indicative of an origin in selection effects. In particula
2Butleretal.
showthatthereisatightcorrelationinthesourceandobserverframesonlyifweexcludeSwifteventsbelowthetypical


HETE-2threshold.Independentofthis,weshowinSection3thattheslopeandnormalizationofthecor-relationarethoseexpectedpurelyfromselectione ectsandthatlittlemodi cationtotheslopeisexpectedaswetransformtothesourceframe.Weapplyatoymodeltopre-SwiftdatafrommultiplemissionconstitutingtheGhirlandaetal.(2004)correlationandcautionagainstusingthisandotherrelationsforcosmologystudies.
2.SWIFTANDTHEEPK-EISOCORRELATION
Onestraight-forwardwaytodiagnoseatype(1)erroristocomparedatafromsatelliteswithverydi erentde-tectionsensitivities.Ifthecorrespondingsurveysbothextendtotherespectivelimiting uxlimits,thenpow-erlaw tsforeachsub-sampleshouldhaveappropriatelydi erentnormalizations.
Intheobserverframe(Figure1A),thereisahighlysigni cantcorrelationforbothHETE-2andSwift.How-ever,thesigni cancevanishesifweaccountforthede-tectionthresholds(see,Petrosian1993)whenconsideringeithersample.Todeterminethethresholdforeachburst,wesimplyscaletheobserved uencebytheinverseoftheobservedsignal-to-noiseratioS/N.
TodiscernhowobserverframepointsaboveandbelowtheHETE-2thresholdtransformtosourceframepoints,itisnotnecessarytoaccuratelyknowtheGRBredshifts.ThereddashedcurveinFigure1B—correspondingtothetrajectoryoneeventfollowsasitsredshiftisvaried—illustrateshowredshiftonlyweaklya ectswherepointsfallontheplot(seealso,Section3).Pointsintheex-tremeBottom-RightofFigure1AorTop-LeftofFigure1Bcannotbemadeconsistentatanyredshift(seealso,Nakar&Piran2005;Band&Preece2005).
RandomlysamplingredshiftsfromthoseobservedbySwift,we ndthat80%ofSwifteventsabovetheHETE-2thresholdareconsistentwiththepre-Swiftrelation(solidanddottedlines).Only20%ofSwifteventbe-lowtheHETE-2thresholdareconsistent.Similarly,B07 ndthatthatabouthalf(40%)oftheSwiftGRBs(in-cludingerrorsonEisoandEpk)forwhichspectroscopicredshiftsareknownareinconsistentwiththepre-Swiftrelation;thebest tcurveisafactor≈2higherthanthepre-Swiftcurve(solidanddottedlinesinFigure1B).Bellmetal.(2008)haveindependentlyveri edthesta-tisticalanalysisinB07forseveralbursts.
Becausewe ndthatburstswith uencesabovepre-Swiftthresholdsareconsistentwiththepre-SwiftEEwhereaspointsbelowpre-Swiftthresholdspk-areisorelation,overwhelminglyinconsistent,theSwiftandpre-Swiftrest-framecorrelationsarelikelytobotharisefromthedetectorthresholdtruncationwhichgeneratestheob-serverframecorrelation.FuturesatellitesmoresensitivethanSwiftareexpectedtofurthershiftandbroadentheEpk-Eisorelationintoaninequality.
Becausewecanfullyattributetheslope,scatter,andnormalizationofthecorrelationtoselectione ectsandfunctionalcorrelations,anyintrinsicexplanationforthecorrelationintheSwiftdataisunecessary.Ourresultsalsostronglycallintoquestionanyintrinsicexplanationforthecorrelationinpre-Swiftdataorinsurveysonlyin-cludingthebrightestSwiftevents(e.g.,Sakamotoetal.2008),becausetheexistenceoffaintSwifteventsmostly
1010]
2-mc gre10[ lobS101010
1001000
Epk,obs [keV]
]
Vek[ kpEEiso [erg]
Fig.1.—Fromdatatruncationtospuriouscorrelationsintheobserverandsourceframes.TypicalerrorbarsareplottedforpointsintheTop-Rightcorner.(A)Thereisastrong(>8σsigni cant)correlationintheobserverframebetweenEpk,obsandSbolforSwift(B07)andHETE-2(Sakamotoetal.2005).Thejagged,graylineshowstheob-serveddetectionS/NrelativetoS/N=10forSwiftGRBs,andthesolidblacklineisa ttothosevalues.Similarly,us-ingthemaximalS/NfromFREGATEorWXMfromtheHETE-2catalog(Vanderspeketal.2007),wedeterminea10σthresholdcurveforHETE-2bursts.Ifweconsideras-sociatedsets(see,e.g.,Petrosian1993)ofdatapointsabovetheHETE-2threshold(e.g.,dashedlineregions),thecorrela-tionintheSwiftdataisinsigni cant(0.7σ).HETE-2eventswithmeasuredz’saremarkedwithanX.(B)Randomlysam-plingz’sfromSwiftbursts,wecanplaceSwiftpointsfrom(A)ontotheEpk-Eisoplot.Only20%ofSwifteventbelowtheHETE-2thresholdareconsistentwiththerelationfoundbyAmatietal.(2002).
missingfrompre-Swiftsurveysshowsthatwedonotun-derstandwhattruncatesthedatainthosesurveys.
InFigure1wemarktheHETE-2eventswithmea-suredredshifts;theseareonaverageafactortwobrighterrelativetothresholdthantheeventswithoutmeasuredredsh ts.ThequalityoftheHETE-2GRBlocalizationdependsonthebrightnessoftheGRBasdoeslikelyalsothebrightnessoftheopticaltransient;bothe ectscon-tributetowhethertheafterglowandhostgalaxycanbedetected.Additionalcomplicatedselectione ectsrelatedtodeterminingtheGRBredshiftarediscussedinBloom(2003).Theseareexpectedtobelessim-
Track Jumps in Hardness-Intensity Correlations of GRB Pulse Decays_文学_高等教育_教育专区。Abstract. The hardness-intensity correlation (HIC), during the ...
Perley Can We Trust GRB High Energy Correlations?...S. Bloom On the Selection Effects of the Epeak...Shocks: Physics Predictions, Observational Tests . ...
Correlations of Prompt a... 暂无评价 13页 ...selection effects: In any GRB trigger algorithm ...(1) does appear to lead the high energy ...
Correlations of Prompt a... 暂无评价 13页 ...selection effects: In any GRB trigger algorithm ...(1) does appear to lead the high energy ...
热门文档