Several correlations among observables derived from modelling the high-energy properties of GRBs have been reported in the literature. We show that well-known examples of these have common features indicative of an origin in selection effects. In particula
4Butleretal.
thecorrelationsmaywellexhibitlow-scatterasaconse-quenceofassumingconcordancecosmology.
Werecommendtestingpotentialnewcorrelations(orknowncorrelationsnotexplicitlymentionedhere)by(a)showingσobs>σsrcandby(b)showingthatthequal-ity(scatterorsigni cance)ofthecorrelationsdegradeswhenthez’sarerandomizedandthecorrelationsrecal-culatedwiththerandomz’sandby(c)showingthattheobservablesvarywithzaspredicted.Thesetestsaretoestablishbasiccon denceinanintrinsicnatureforthecorrelationsandarenotmerelytoestablishthatacor-relationcanbeusedtoestimateredshift(e.g.,Li2006;Schaefer&Collazzi2007).
Fortheseteststobeaccurate,however,itisalsoneces-sarytoidentifyselectione ectsactingonthedata.Fluxor uencevaluesshouldbepresentdowntotheestab-lishedsurveycompletenesslevel.Well-establishedmeth-odscanthenbeappliedtocompensatefordatatrun-cation(e.g.,Petrosian1993)andtocontrolforpartialcorrelations(e.g.,Akritas&Siebert1996).
InlookingfornewrelationsrelevanttothephysicalprocessesunderlyingGRBs,andtoavoidaninherentdi cultyindecidinganoriginforthecorrelationsinthesourceorobserverframes(Section3),itmaybeimportanttochooseobservablesless-broadlydistributedthanthecharacteristicrangein1+zortoabandonob-servableswithstrongandcomplicatedtruncations(i.e., uxesor uences)altogether.Functionalcorrelationsin1+zcouldbeminimizedbychoosingobservables(e.g.,powerlawindices)whichdonotvaryexplicitlywithz.Also,potentiallycircumventingallconcernsraisedabove,weshouldestablishcalibrationforGRBsatz 1.ItisalsocrucialtounderstandwhetherGRBpropertiesevolvewithredshift.
Epeak [keV]
10

1010Eγ [erg]
10T90 × (1+z) [s]
10

10Swift Trigger Number × (1+z)
Fig.2.—(A)Ghirlandaetal.(2004) ndatightcorrela-tionbetweenthebeaming-correctedGRBenergyreleaseEγandEpk.WealsoplotrecentpointsfromSchaefer(2007).Suggestinganon-intrinsicoriginsimilartothecorrelationsinFigure1,itisnotnecessarytoknowthezofaneventtoacceptablyplaceitonthebest- tcurve(dottedline).Thetightnessofthecorrelationisuna ectedwhethertrueorrandomredshiftsareassumedfortranslatingtheobserverframetosourceframequantities.(B)Ahighly-signi cant(>5σ),mockcorrelationbetweenSwifttriggernumberandburstdurationillustrateshowinvariancewithrespecttoz-randomizationcanunmaskafunctionalcorrelationduetomultiplicationinXandYby1+zfactors.
N.R.BgratefullyacknowledgessupportfromaTownesFellowshipattheU.C.BerkeleySpaceSciencesLab-oratory,aswellaspartialsupportfromJ.S.B.andA.Filippenko.J.S.B.ispartiallysupportedbytheHellmanFacultyFund.
REFERENCES
Akritas,M.G.,&Siebert,J.1996,A&A,278,919Amati,L.,etal.2002,A&A,390,81
Band,D.L.,&Preece,R.D.2005,ApJ,627,319Bellm,E.C.,etal.2008,arXiv:0801.2417Bloom,J.S.2003,AJ,125,2865Butler,N.,etal.2007,ApJ,671,656
Cabrera,J.I.,etal.2007,MNRAS,382,342Firmani,C.,etal.2004,ApJ,611,1033Gehrels,N.,etal.2004,ApJ,611,1005
Ghirlanda,G.,Ghisellini,G.,&LazzatiD.2004,ApJ,616,331
Ghirlanda,etal.2008,AIPConfProc.GRB2007,InPressKistler,M.D.,etal.2007,arXiv:0709.0381Li,L.X.2006,MNRAS,374,L20
Liang,E.,&Zhang,B.2005,ApJ,633,611Lee,T.T.,&Petrosian,V.1996,ApJ,470,479
Lloyd,N.M.,Petrosian,V.,&Mallozzi,R.S.2000,ApJ,534,227
Lloyd-Ronning,N.M.,&Ramirez-Ruiz,E.2002,ApJ,576,101
Massaro,F.,Cutini,S.,Conciatore,M.L.,&Tramacere,A.2007,arXiv:0710.2226
Nakar,E.,&Piran,T.2005,MNRAS,360,73Nava,L.,etal.2006,A&A,450,471Petrosian,V.1993,ApJ,402,L33
Preece,R.D.,etal.2000,ApJ,126,19Schaefer,B.E.2007,ApJ,660,16
Schaefer,B.E.,&Collazzi,A.C.2007,ApJ,656,L53Sakamoto,T.,etal.2005,ApJ,629,311Sakamoto,T.,etal.2008,arXiv:0801.4319
Sari,R.,Piran,T.,&Halpern,J.P.1999,ApJ,524,L43Vanderspek,R.,etal.2007,AIPConfProc.GRB2007,InPress
Willingale,R.,etal.2007,arXiv:0710.3727Yonetoku,D.,etal.2004,ApJ,609,935
Track Jumps in Hardness-Intensity Correlations of GRB Pulse Decays_文学_高等教育_教育专区。Abstract. The hardness-intensity correlation (HIC), during the ...
Perley Can We Trust GRB High Energy Correlations?...S. Bloom On the Selection Effects of the Epeak...Shocks: Physics Predictions, Observational Tests . ...
Correlations of Prompt a... 暂无评价 13页 ...selection effects: In any GRB trigger algorithm ...(1) does appear to lead the high energy ...
Correlations of Prompt a... 暂无评价 13页 ...selection effects: In any GRB trigger algorithm ...(1) does appear to lead the high energy ...
热门文档