Several correlations among observables derived from modelling the high-energy properties of GRBs have been reported in the literature. We show that well-known examples of these have common features indicative of an origin in selection effects. In particula
DraftversionFebruary22,2008
APreprinttypesetusingLTEXstyleemulateapjv.10/09/06
TESTSFORSELECTIONEFFECTSINGRBHIGH-ENERGYCORRELATIONS
NathanielR.Butler1,2,DanielKocevski2,andJoshuaS.Bloom2,3.
DraftversionFebruary22,2008
arXiv:0802.3396v1 [astro-ph] 22 Feb 2008
ABSTRACT
Severalcorrelationsamongobservablesderivedfrommodellingthehigh-energypropertiesofGRBshavebeenreportedintheliterature.Weshowthatwell-knownexamplesofthesehavecommonfeaturesindicativeofanorigininselectione ects.Inparticular,wefocushereonthepossibleoriginoftheEpk-EisocorrelationinSwiftdataduetodetectorthresholdtruncation.TheexistenceoffaintSwifteventscallsintoquestioninferencesbasedonpre-Swiftsurveyswhichmustbesubjecttocomplicatedincompletenesse ects.Wereviewmethodsfortreatingdatatruncatione ectsincorrelationanalysesandapplythesemethodstoSwiftandpre-Swiftdata.Also,weshowthattheEpk-Eγ(“Ghirlanda”)correlationise ectivelyindependentoftheGRBredshifts,whichsuggestsitcontainslittleintrinsicphysics.Werecommendverifyingthatacorrelationhassigni cantlyreducedscatterintherestframerelativetotheobserverframeandalsoestablishingthatGRBredshiftscontributemeaningfully.Subjectheadings:gammarays:bursts—methods:statistical—cosmology:observations
1.INTRODUCTION:COMMONPITFALLSIN
CORRELATIONANALYSES
Recently,Butleret(2007,hereafterreportev-idencefromSwiftsatelliteobserva-tionsofGamma-rayBursts(GRBs)thatseveralpow-erlawrelations(or“correlations”astheyarecommonlyreferredtointheliterature)exhibitawidescatterandshiftinnormalizationtowardtheSwiftdetectionthresh-old,suggestiveofanoriginintimatelyconnectedtothedetectionlimitsofpre-Swiftsatellites.Becauserela-tionsintrinsictothephysicalprocessesunderlyingGRBsshouldnotbeinstrument-dependent,abroaderinvestiga-tionintothedatafrompre-Swiftsatellitesisimportanttoextend(orquench)implicationsoftheSwiftstudy.ThisisacrucialstepbeforetherelationscanbetrustedtopotentiallyconstrainthephysicsofGRBsorcosmol-ogy.
Togaugetheimportanceofsystematice ectsinthisareofresearch,weisolatefromtheliteraturetwopathsthatlikelyhaveleadtoapparentlyhighlysigni cantcor-relations:(1)selectione ectstruncatethedatainvari-ouswaysandthe“missing”dataarenottreated;or(2)partialcorrelationwithahiddenvariableorvariablesisignored.Wecallimpropertreatmentofthesee ectstype(1)andtype(2)errors,respectively.Commonexamplesoftype(2)errorsinvolveusingacorrelation(e.g.,Lag-Luminosity)toinferredshiftzforanothercorrelationwiththesamevariables(e.g.,Epk-Luminosity),with-outcontrollingforpartialcorrelationwiththevariableincommon(e.g.,peak ux).
Thetwotypesoferrorscanworktogether,forexample,inthestudieswhichemployonecor-relationtoinferzforanothercorrelation(e.g.,Lloyd-Ronning&Ramirez-Ruiz2002;Yonetokuetal.theEpk-Luminositycorrelationislikelygovernedbytruncatione ects(see,Lloyd,Petrosian,&MallozziandaLag-Luminositycorrelationcouldarisedue
TownesFellow,SpaceSciencesLaboratory,UniversityofCali-fornia,Berkeley,CA,94720-7450,USA
2AstronomyDepartment,UniversityofCalifornia,445Camp-bellHall,Berkeley,CA94720-3411,USA3SloanResearchFellow
1
topartialcorrelationwithpeak ux.Alternatively,Epkmaycorrelatewithlag.Thetrueoriginofonecorrela-tioncanbechallengingtoisolate.Ontheotherhand,casesfortheseexamplecorrelationsfromthepre-andearly-aftergloweracanprobablyberejectedoutrightasnon-intrinsicbynotinganinvariancewithrespecttoran-domizationsintheredshifts.Wediscussindetailbe-lowwhatwespeci callymeanby“redshiftvariation”andalsowhywebelievethisvariationiscriticalforun-derstandingwhetherGRBcorrelationsre ectintrinsicphysicsorartifactsofthedetectionprocess.Inthepre-andearly-Swiftera,studiesmarryingtwocorrelationshavebecomeincreasinglyrare,andthegrowingnumberofGRBswithspectroscopicredshiftsallowsfordirecttestsalongtheselines.
TheGRBratedensityandluminosityfunctioncon-tributetoshapingthecorrelations;however,weconsidertheseglobalratherthanintrinsicGRBproperties.TheGRBratedensityandluminosityfunctiondictatetheob-sourcedensitydN/dF∝F a(e.g.,Preeceetal.Althoughthisisindependentofthedetectionpro-cess,atruncationinthisdistributionatthefaintendduetoselectione ectswillcreateaclusteringintheobserverframe.Forexample,thedN/dFtellsusthatlog(F)willhaveadispersionequalto0.43/a<~0.3dex,inde-pendentofthetruncationwhichsetsthenormalizationforanycorrelation.WithFasaphotonnumber u-ence,thiscanformthenecessaryinitialtightnessofasigni cant“functional”correlation(e.g.,forexample,betweenEpk,obsandphotonenergy uenceSbol∝Epk,obsF.Covariancebetweenthemea-iftreated(e.g.,1996;B07).Theapparentdynamicrangeofthecorrelationcanultimatelybeampli edbyanadditionalfunctionalcorrelationstepwherebothsidesoftheequationaremultipliedbysimi-larpowersof1+ztoreachthesourceframe(e.g.,B07).Simpletestscanbeappliedtocheckwhetherthesee ectsaresu cienttoproduceagivencorrelation.
WebegininSection2belowbyshowinghowtheEpk-EisoorAmatietal.(2002)correlationappearsintheob-serverframefortwosatellites,HETE-2andSwift.We
Track Jumps in Hardness-Intensity Correlations of GRB Pulse Decays_文学_高等教育_教育专区。Abstract. The hardness-intensity correlation (HIC), during the ...
Perley Can We Trust GRB High Energy Correlations?...S. Bloom On the Selection Effects of the Epeak...Shocks: Physics Predictions, Observational Tests . ...
Correlations of Prompt a... 暂无评价 13页 ...selection effects: In any GRB trigger algorithm ...(1) does appear to lead the high energy ...
Correlations of Prompt a... 暂无评价 13页 ...selection effects: In any GRB trigger algorithm ...(1) does appear to lead the high energy ...
热门文档