文档下载 文档下载导航
设为首页 | 加入收藏
搜索 请输入内容:  
 导航当前位置: 文档下载 > 所有分类 > WHAT KIND OF PROOF CAN BE CONSTRUCTED FOLLOWING AN ABDUCTIVE ARGUMENTATION
侵权投诉

WHAT KIND OF PROOF CAN BE CONSTRUCTED FOLLOWING AN ABDUCTIVE ARGUMENTATION

My interests focus on the comparison between the abductive argumentation supporting a conjecture and the related proof. In particular,.the purpose of my research is to show the importance of a structural analysis between them (from an abductive argumentati

The opposite positions of these researches moved me to search an answer to the following question: Is there cognitive unity or cognitive distance between argumentation and proof?

The experimentation that I carried out (Pedemonte, 2002), push me to distinguish the content and the structure in the argumentation and in the consequent proof. When student produces an abductive argumentation, a structural gap is necessary to construct a deductive proof. This gap can be a difficult for him. My hypothesis is that the “natural” continuity that appears in the contents of argumentation and proof, (in according with the hypothesis of cognitive unity) can be observed in their structure too. Indeed, sometime student produce an abductive “proof” after an abductive argumentation (see example 2, p. 6).

In order to give an answer to my question and to validate or invalidate this hypothesis I needed a tool to compare the argumentation structure and proof structure: the Toulmin’s model.

Toulmin’s model: a methodological tool

Toulmin proposes a model describing the structure of the argumentation (1958). I use this model as a tool to compare the structures relating to the two processes: argumentation and proof.

In any argumentation the first step is expressed by a standpoint (an assertion, an opinion). In Toulmin’s terminology the standpoint is called the claim. The second step consists of the production of data supporting it. It is important to provide the justification or warrant for using the data concerned as support for the data-claim relationships. The warrant can be expressed as a principle, a rule and the like. The warrant acts as a bridge between the data and the claim. This is the base structure of argumentation, but auxiliary elements may be necessary to describe an argumentation. Toulmin describes three of them: the qualifier, the rebuttal and the backing. The force of the warrant would be weakened if there were exceptions to the rule, in that case conditions of exceptions or rebuttal should be inserted. The claim must then be weakened by means of a qualifier. A backing is required if the authority of the warrant is not accepted straight away.

Then, Toulmin’s model of argumentation contains six related elements as showed in the following figure.

Q : qualifier

WHAT KIND OF PROOF CAN BE CONSTRUCTED FOLLOWING AN ABDUCTIVE ARGUMENTATION

: claim

unless R : rebuttal

on account of

Fig. 1. Toulmin’s model of argumentation3.

3 Let us illustrate this model with the same example used by Toulmin (1958) : Claim : Harry is a British subject; Data : Harry was born in Bermuda; Warrant : A man born in Bermuda will generally be a British subject; Rebuttal : No, but it

上一页第3页

你可能喜欢

热门文档

相关文档

站点地图 | 文档上传 | 侵权投诉 | 手机版
本站所有资源均来自互联网,本站只负责收集和整理,均不承担任何法律责任,如有侵权等其它行为请联系我们.
文档下载 Copyright 2013 doc.guandang.net All Rights Reserved.  -  email