My interests focus on the comparison between the abductive argumentation supporting a conjecture and the related proof. In particular,.the purpose of my research is to show the importance of a structural analysis between them (from an abductive argumentati
The experimental design was carried out in some 12 -grade classes, when students begin to learn proof. I proposed a geometrical problem requiring the production of conjectures and the related proof. The students’ productions were analysed according to Toulmin’s model in order to highlight and to understand the cognitive relation between argumentation and proof.
Theoretical framework
The relationships between the production of a conjecture and the construction of proof has been an object of study from a cognitive perspective. Actually, research studies showed the possibility that some kinds of continuity exist between the two processes. In particular, continuity can take the following shape:
“During the production of the conjecture, the student progressively works out his/her statement through an intensive argumentative activity functionally intermingled with the justification of the plausibility of his/her choices. During the subsequent statement-proving stage, the student links up with this process in a coherent way, organizing some of previously produced arguments according to a logical chain” (Boero, Garuti, Mariotti, 1996).
This phenomenon is referred to by the authors as cognitive unity.
During the solving process, which leads to a theorem, we may suppose that an argumentation activity is developed in order to produce a conjecture. When the statement expressing the conjecture is made valid in a mathematical theory, we can say that a proof is produced. This proof is a particular argumentation based on a mathematical theory. The cognitive unity, described above, concerns the content between this argumentation and the consequent proof. During the production of several theorems, there are many similar content elements in the argumentation and proof, therefore we can say that it is frequent to find a continuity in the content of the two processes (Pedemonte, 2002).
On the other side, according to Duval (1991), deductive thinking does not work like argumentation: there is a “gap” between the two processes even if they use very similar linguistic forms and proposition’s connectives. The structure of a proof may be described by a ternary diagram: data, claim, and inference rules (axioms, theorems, or definitions). Within proofs, the steps are connected by a “recycling process” (Duval, 1992–1993): the conclusion of a step serves as input condition to the next step. On the contrary, in argumentation, inferences are based on the contents of the statement. In other words the connection between two propositions is an intrinsic connection (Duval, 1992–1993): the statement is considered and re-interpreted from different points of view. For these reasons (according to Duval) the distance between proof and argumentation is not only logic but is also cognitive: in a proof, the epistemic value2 depends on the theoretical status whereas in argumentation it depends on the content. Then it is easy to observe the cognitive distance between the two processes. 2th The epistemic value is the degree of certitude or conviction associated with a proposition (Duval,1991).
2 Credulous Acceptance Following [7], we de?ne an argumentation framework ...prove the credulous acceptance of an argument, a proof tree is constructed....
2 Credulous Acceptance Following [7], we de?ne an argumentation framework ...prove the credulous acceptance of an argument, a proof tree is constructed....
热门文档