My interests focus on the comparison between the abductive argumentation supporting a conjecture and the related proof. In particular,.the purpose of my research is to show the importance of a structural analysis between them (from an abductive argumentati
By means of this model, in opposite position respect to Duval, the argumentation structure has a ternary structure. Then the comparison between an argumentation and the proof subsequently produced is possible also from a structural point of view. If we consider a proof as a particular argumentation, the warrant is an axiom, or a definition, or a theorem, in a specific theory.
In the following section, I illustrate the use of this model as an example when the resolution process of an open-ended problem will be analysed.
Experimental design
The following examples are taken from a set of data collected in four 12 -grade thclasses in Italy, and in one 12 -grade class in France. The students worked in pairs on a computer running the Cabri-Geometry software. The experiment lasted an hour and a half. The problem proposed was the following:
Problem. ABC is a triangle. Three exteriors squares are constructed on the triangle’s sides. The free points of the squares are connected defining three other triangles. Compare the areas of these triangles with the area of triangle ABC (see figure p. 5). I will transcribe a part of two solution protocols related to the proposed problem. Theses parts are based on the transcriptions of the audio recordings and the written productions of the students.
I will present two protocol examples:
Example 1: Example of structural gap between argumentation and proof (abductive argumentation into deductive proof
Example 2: Example of structural continuity between argumentation and proof (abductive argumentation into abductive “proof”).
In order to analyse the argumentation, I have selected the assertions produced by students and reconstructed the structure of the argumentative step: claim C, data D and warrant W. The indices identify each argumentative step. The student’s text is in the left column, and my comments and analyses are reported in the right column. The texts have been translated from Italian into English.
Example 1
The analysis starts at claim C7; at this point students are comparing the area of the triangle ABC and the area of the triangle ICD. Till now the students spoke about the construction of the heights of the two triangles. They decided to construct the heights in order to compare the areas of the triangles ABC and ICD. triangles ABC et ICD Cabri-géomètre.
31. L: I’m prolonging the straight line, yes, the
straight line on the segment… what have I
done?
generally is. If his parents are foreigners or if he has become a naturalised American, then the rule doesn’t apply; Qualifier : True : its only presumably so; Backing : It’s embodied in the following legislation :… th
2 Credulous Acceptance Following [7], we de?ne an argumentation framework ...prove the credulous acceptance of an argument, a proof tree is constructed....
2 Credulous Acceptance Following [7], we de?ne an argumentation framework ...prove the credulous acceptance of an argument, a proof tree is constructed....
热门文档