My interests focus on the comparison between the abductive argumentation supporting a conjecture and the related proof. In particular,.the purpose of my research is to show the importance of a structural analysis between them (from an abductive argumentati
WHAT KIND OF PROOF CAN BE CONSTRUCTED FOLLOWING AN
ABDUCTIVE ARGUMENTATION?
Bettina Pedemonte
Itituto delle Tecnologie Didattiche – CNR Genova
Abstract
My interests focus on the comparison between the abductive argumentation supporting a conjecture and the related proof. In particular, .the purpose of my research is to show the importance of a structural analysis between them (from an abductive argumentation to a deductive proof, from an abductive argumentation to an abductive “proof”). I propose the Toulmin’s model as a tool which can be used to detect and to analyse some structural continuities and some structural gaps between an argumentation and the following proof. This analysis allows identifying in the passage from an abductive argumentation to a deductive proof, one of the possible trouble met by students in the construction of a proof.
Introduction
The purpose of this paper is to analyse some aspects of the relationships between argumentation and proof in geometry. In particular, my interests focus on the argumentation supporting a conjecture and the consequent proof.
Starting from the Italian research concerning the cognitive unity between the two processes (Boero, Garuti, Mariotti, 1996), I developed a theoretical framework in order to analyse and to compare argumentation and proof from a structural point of view (Pedemonte 2002). Indeed, I think that the comparison between an argumentation and the consequent proof may be carried out considering their contents (some words, some expressions, the theoretical framework if it exists in the argumentation, and so on), and/or their structure (abductive, inductive, deductive and so on). In this paper, I present a part of this theoretical framework: a structural analysis between argumentation and proof considering an abductive argumentation1. In the student’s protocols, it is easy to find abductive argumentations supporting a conjecture. But according to curricula of the secondary school, when students learn to proof, they usually have to construct deductive proofs. As the analysis will show, this passage it is not always immediate for them.
In this paper, Toulmin’s model is used as a methodological tool useful to compare argumentation and proof from a structural point of view. In particular I want to show the gap which can be observed between an abductive argumentation and a deductive proof. The aim of this analysis is to present this gap as a cognitive gap. It is to say that in the structural gap between argumentation and proof, it is possible to identify some difficulties met by students in the construction of a proof. 1 Abduction refers to an inference which starting from an observed fact and a given rule, led to a conclusion (Peirce, 1960, Polya, 1962). An abductive step can be represented in the following way:
B
A B
B
B is an observed fact, A B is a rule. Then A is more probable.
2 Credulous Acceptance Following [7], we de?ne an argumentation framework ...prove the credulous acceptance of an argument, a proof tree is constructed....
2 Credulous Acceptance Following [7], we de?ne an argumentation framework ...prove the credulous acceptance of an argument, a proof tree is constructed....
热门文档