LETTERS
a
Percentage100b
Percentage806040
20©2006 Nature Publishing Group doc.guandang.net kinshipRelative kinshipFigure2DistributionofpairwiserelativekinshipestimatesintheCEPHsampleandmaizesample.Thepeaksaround0indicatenorelationship.(a)FortheCEPHsample,thesmallpeaksaround0.25representrelationshipsamongoffspringwithinafamily,parent-offspringorgrandparent-parent,andthesmallpeakaround0.125representrelationshipsofgrandparent-offspring.(b)Forthemaizesample,thecontinuouslydescendingestimatesofrelativekinshipagreewiththecomplexfamilialrelationshipsandpopulationstructureamongthesemaizeinbredlines.Forsimplicity,weshowonlypercentagesoftherelativekinshipestimatesofthemaizesamplefrom0to0.45.Association(SA)andGenomicControl(GC)arecommonmethodsusedinhumanandplantstudiestocontrolforthefalsepositives(typeIerrors)causedbythispopulationstructure9–13.WithGC,randommarkersareusedtoestimateandadjustthein ationofteststatisticsgeneratedbypopulationstructure,assumingsuchastructurehasasimilareffectonallloci.SAanalysisusesrandommarkerstoestimatepopulationstructureandthenincorporatesthisintofurtherstatisticalanalysis.ForsamplesinareaIII,however,accountingonlyforpopulationstructuremayleadtoeitherinadequatecontrolforfalsepositivesoralossinpowerowingtofamilialrelatedness(Fig.1).Itremainstobeseenwhichmethodswillprovemostusefulwhenevaluatingsampleswithveryhighlevelsofpopulationstructurealongwithdiverselevelsoffamilialrelatedness(areaV;Fig.1).Inthispaper,wepresentanewmethodforassociationmappingthatisapplicabletosamplesfromareasIIandIII(Fig.1).Forthefamily-basedsample,weappliedourmethodtomicroarraydatafromthebaselineexpressionlevelsofgenesinimmortalizedBcellsfrom14familiesofCentred’EtudeduPolymorphismeHumain(CEPH)Utahpedigree14.Inthisstudy,sixgeneexpressionphenotypeswereregard-edasphenotypictraitsinmappingexpressionquantitativetraitloci
(eQTL).Forthesamplecontainingcomplexfamilialrelationshipsand


populationstructure,weexaminedthreequantitativetraitsmeasured
on277diversemaizeinbredlines,representingthediversitypresentin
publicbreedingprogramsaroundtheworld15.Asmaizeisahighly
outbredspecies,thepopulationdifferentiation(Fst)amongthemajor
subgroupsinoursamplerangedfrom0.047(SSR)to0.073(SNP),
similartothatofarecenthumanstudy11(Fst¼0.013forChinese-
JapaneseandFst¼0.145forbetweencontinents).Whenweincluded
aminorbottleneckedsubgroup,theoverallFstroseto0.106(SSR)
and0.118(SNP).
Ourassociationmappingapproachintegratesgenomictoolsto
uncoverpopulationstructureandfamilialrelationshipswiththetraditionalmixed-modelframeworkthathaslongbeenusedbyanimalgeneticists16–18.Oneobviousobstacleinapplyingamixed-modelmethodbeyondafewdomesticatedanimalspeciesisthatpedigreerecordsareoftenunknownorinaccurate.Genomictoolsnowallowustodetectbothpopulationstructure(Q)andrelativekinship(K)withinasample.Marker-basedrelativekinshipestimateshaveprovenusefulforquantitativeinheritancestudiesindifferentpopulations19,20.ThisKestimateapproximatesidentitybydescentbyadjustingtheprobabilityofidentitybystatebetweentwoindividualswiththeaverageprobabilityofidentitybystatebetweenrandomindividuals.FortheCEPHsample,wereplacedthepedigree-basedcoancestrymatrix(G)inatraditionalmixedmodelwiththeKmatrixtode nethedegreeofgeneticcovarianceamongindividuals.Nopopulationstructurewasdetected,andQwasnotincludedinthemixed-modelanalyses.Forthemaizesample,we tbothQandKintothemixedmodeltoaccountformultiplelevelsofrelatedness.Werandomlytestedtheexpressionlevelofsixgeneswithgoodheritabilityestimates:HSD17B12,TUBB2A,CTSH,RPS26,UBE2L3andSSR1.TheKmatrixagreedwiththefamilystructureofthedata.Although94%ofthepair-wisekinshipestimateswerecloseto0,thesmallpeaksaround0.25and0.125representedtherelationshipswithinfamilies(Fig.2a).ThemixedmodelwitheithertheKorGmatrix tsthedataequallywell.TheKmodelshowedasigni cantimprovementinmodel toverthesimplemodelinwhichfamilystructureisignored(Table1).Overall,theKmodel,GCandQTDTshowedgoodcontroloftypeIerrorrate(Fig.3a–candSupplementaryFig.1online).TheKmodelgaveslightlyliberalresultsandGCgaveslightlyconservativeresultsforTUBB2A,whereastheresultsfromQTDTwereliberalforTUBB2AbutslightlyconservativeforHSD17B12.Thestatisticalpowersimulationwasconductedbyaddingageneticeffecttoeachmarkerandthentestingwhetheritcouldbedetectedbydifferentmodels.TheadjustedTable1Goodnessof tofthreedifferentmodelsinexplainingphenotypicvariationofhumangeneexpressions
HDS17B12
–2log
likelihood
Simplemodel
Coancestry
Kmodel
aModelTUBB2A–2loglikelihood210.3a174.9173.9CTSH–2loglikelihood208.1a137.7140.7RPS26–2loglikelihood184.9a56.558.7UBE2L3–2loglikelihood72.3a43.645.0SSR1–2loglikelihood14.0a–3.2–3.2BIC126.685.883.6BIC220.8190.7189.7BIC218.6153.5156.5BIC195.472.374.5BIC82.859.460.8BIC24.612.612.6116.1a70.067.8comparisonbasedonw2testindicateswhethertheKmodelsigni cantlyimprovesthemodel tatPo0.001;BIC,BayesianInformationCriterion(smallerisbetter);allCEPHUtahfamilymemberswereusedintheanalysesofthreemodels;thesimplemodelwasincludedonlyforthepurposeofillustratingtheeffectofignoringfamilyrelationships,asitisnotastandardpractice.NATUREGENETICS
A unified mixed-model me... 暂无评价 7页 2财富值 The Unified Test Method...Two classes are in USE association (B uses A) if instances of B can ...
cient mixed-model association (EMMA), which corrects for population structure and genetic relatedness in model organism association mapping. Our method takes ...
10 A?unified ifi d?mixed i d‐model d l?method th d?for f ? association?mapping pp g y???=???Xβ +???Sα +???Qv +???Zu + e Backgr...
A Grammar Analysis Model for the Unified Multimedia Query Language_专业资料 暂无评价
Towards a unified physic... 暂无评价 10页 免费 A unified mixed-model me...(Gerstner and Kistler, 2002), categorization and association, while avoiding ...
Association mapping for ... 暂无评价 14页 免费 Association mapping for .....‘Exploiting Genome-wide Association in Oilseed Brassicas: a model for ...
A unified mixed-model ... 暂无评价 7页 1下载券 Towards a generic mode... 暂无评价 16页 免费 A New Method for Chara... 暂无评价 4页 2.00 ...
ed mixed-model method for association mapping that account for multiple level of relatedness. Nat Genet 38:203–208 Zanetti S, Winzeler M, Keller M, ...
Customer Requirements Mapping Method Based on Association Rule Mining for Mass...A Method of Rotating M... 1人阅读 8页 2.00 Subsystem model-based ...
Association mapping of yield and its components in rice 2007_电子/电路_工程...ed mixed-model method for association mapping that accounts for multiple ...
热门文档