文档下载 文档下载导航
设为首页 | 加入收藏
搜索 请输入内容:  
 导航当前位置: 文档下载 > 所有分类 > 外语学习 > 英语考试 > Eradication of cross-contaminated cell lines A call for action - 副本
侵权投诉

Eradication of cross-contaminated cell lines A call for action - 副本

CellBiolToxicol(2007)23:367–37219citationsfortheputativeintestinalcellInt407,45citationsfortheputativeamnioncellWISH,59citationsforChangliver,470citationsfortheputativehumannasalcarcinomacellHep-2,and556citationsfortheputativeoralcarcinomaKB.APubMedsearchbyBuehringetal.(2004)uncovered220publicationsthatinvolvedcross-contaminatedcultures.AsurveydistributedandanalyzedbyBuehringetal(2004)inordertoobtainaprofileofactivecellcultureworkersrevealedthatofthe483respondents,32%usedHeLacells,9%wereunwittinglyusingHeLacontaminants,33%oftheinvestigatorstestedforauthenticity,35%obtainedtheircelllinesfromotherlaboratoriesratherthanfromamajorrepository.TheirpaperalsoincludestheoutcomeofaPubMeddatabaseanalysiswhichuncovered220researchpapersbasedontheuseofcross-contaminatedcelllines.Buehringetal.(2004)alsorevealedadisturbingtrend.WhilethenumberofpublicationsinthePubMeddatabasein-creasedsteadilyfrom1969through2004,thenumberofpapersinvolvingHeLacontaminantsincreasedfarmorerapidly.Ananalysisofoneoftheirfiguresshowsuseofcontaminatedculturesincreasingabout10-foldandthenumberofcellculturepapersinthedatabaseincreasingslightlymorethan2–2.5-foldduringthesametimeperiod.Anidenticalsearchcovering2005andsomeof2006revealedthatthepatternofmisusecontinues(Buehring,personalcommunication,2006).

Thedataderivedby“mining”ofdatabasesshouldbeviewedasveryconservativeestimates.Databasestendtoberatherporousandmanyreportsgounnoticed.Themajorrepositories,becauseoftheirdiligenceinmonitoringcross-contaminationarenowabletofulfilltheirmissionofstoringanddistributingauthenticatedcelllines.However,thisdoesnotdiminishtheneedforperiodicauthenticationofculturesreceiveddirectlyfromotherinvestigators,fromcommercialsources,andfrommajorreposito-ries.LiscovitchandRavid(2006)reportedthatDNAfingerprintinganalysisrevealedthatNCI/ADR-REScelllineisactuallyanovariantumorcellline,OVCAR-8,ratherthanabreastcancercellline.NCI/ADR-RESisincludedintheNCIpanelof60celllinesdistributedforevaluationofpotentialanticancerdrugs.LiscovitchandRavidestimatethatabout300papershavebeenpublishedwiththeincorrectidentification.Mistakescanhappeneveninthefinestlaboratories.Onlyauniversalpracticeof

369

celllineauthenticationcanprovideuswiththesecurityourresearchandcommitmentwarrant!

Acallforremedialaction

Thecross-contaminationandmisidentificationdisclo-suresofthelastfourdecadestaintedthereputationsofmanyrespectedlaboratories.Thisledtodenial,paranoia,andmockery.Theclimatesoengenderedwasnotconducivetothegenerationofpoliciesandpracticesthatwouldbeembracedprofession-wide.Contributingtothelackofactionwasthemistakenbeliefbysomethatdisclosurewouldautomaticallybefollowedbyindividualheightenedawarenessandremedialaction.Periodicreports,conferences,andsymposiacameandwentandhadinsufficientimpact(asisevidencedbythehighfrequencyofmisidenti-fication).Noencompassing,remedialplanwithreasonableexpectationsandwithmeasuredinduce-mentwasdevelopedtochallengetheprofession.Thecompellingneedforchangedpracticewasnotmatchedbycompellingsolutions.

Clearly,thecurrentsituationisintolerableandrequiresabroad,coordinatedeffortinvolvingthosewhodoresearch,fundresearch,publishfindingsofresearchandeducateresearchers.Thestrategyde-scribedbelowderivesitsmeritfromthecompellingneed,itsrelianceoncompliancemethodsusedinselectedsituationsbygovernmentagenciesandscientificjournals,andtheroleofprofessionalsocietiesasguardiansinadvancingthesearchfortruthandmaintenanceofhighstandards.

Generationofaplananditsimplementationshouldhaveasitshallmarkthespiritofcollegialityandmutualconcern.However,itmustalsobeunyieldingregardingtheneedfordecisiveactionthatleadstotheeliminationofthisscandaloussituation.

Aconferenceshouldbeconvenedtoanalyzethemajorfeaturesoftheproposedstrategy,aswellasalternativeones.

1.Itisproposedthatgovernmentandprivate

fundingagenciesbeprevailedupontorequirecelllineauthenticationasaconditionfortheawardofgrantandcontractfunds.

2.Itisalsoproposedthatkeyscientificjournalsbe

prevailedupontorequirecelllineauthenticationasaconditionforpublication.

上一页第3页

你可能喜欢

热门文档

相关文档

站点地图 | 文档上传 | 侵权投诉 | 手机版
本站所有资源均来自互联网,本站只负责收集和整理,均不承担任何法律责任,如有侵权等其它行为请联系我们.
文档下载 Copyright 2013 doc.guandang.net All Rights Reserved.  -  email