CellBiolToxicol(2007)23:367–37219citationsfortheputativeintestinalcellInt407,45citationsfortheputativeamnioncellWISH,59citationsforChangliver,470citationsfortheputativehumannasalcarcinomacellHep-2,and556citationsfortheputativeoralcarcinomaKB.APubMedsearchbyBuehringetal.(2004)uncovered220publicationsthatinvolvedcross-contaminatedcultures.AsurveydistributedandanalyzedbyBuehringetal(2004)inordertoobtainaprofileofactivecellcultureworkersrevealedthatofthe483respondents,32%usedHeLacells,9%wereunwittinglyusingHeLacontaminants,33%oftheinvestigatorstestedforauthenticity,35%obtainedtheircelllinesfromotherlaboratoriesratherthanfromamajorrepository.TheirpaperalsoincludestheoutcomeofaPubMeddatabaseanalysiswhichuncovered220researchpapersbasedontheuseofcross-contaminatedcelllines.Buehringetal.(2004)alsorevealedadisturbingtrend.WhilethenumberofpublicationsinthePubMeddatabasein-creasedsteadilyfrom1969through2004,thenumberofpapersinvolvingHeLacontaminantsincreasedfarmorerapidly.Ananalysisofoneoftheirfiguresshowsuseofcontaminatedculturesincreasingabout10-foldandthenumberofcellculturepapersinthedatabaseincreasingslightlymorethan2–2.5-foldduringthesametimeperiod.Anidenticalsearchcovering2005andsomeof2006revealedthatthepatternofmisusecontinues(Buehring,personalcommunication,2006).
Thedataderivedby“mining”ofdatabasesshouldbeviewedasveryconservativeestimates.Databasestendtoberatherporousandmanyreportsgounnoticed.Themajorrepositories,becauseoftheirdiligenceinmonitoringcross-contaminationarenowabletofulfilltheirmissionofstoringanddistributingauthenticatedcelllines.However,thisdoesnotdiminishtheneedforperiodicauthenticationofculturesreceiveddirectlyfromotherinvestigators,fromcommercialsources,andfrommajorreposito-ries.LiscovitchandRavid(2006)reportedthatDNAfingerprintinganalysisrevealedthatNCI/ADR-REScelllineisactuallyanovariantumorcellline,OVCAR-8,ratherthanabreastcancercellline.NCI/ADR-RESisincludedintheNCIpanelof60celllinesdistributedforevaluationofpotentialanticancerdrugs.LiscovitchandRavidestimatethatabout300papershavebeenpublishedwiththeincorrectidentification.Mistakescanhappeneveninthefinestlaboratories.Onlyauniversalpracticeof
369
celllineauthenticationcanprovideuswiththesecurityourresearchandcommitmentwarrant!
Acallforremedialaction
Thecross-contaminationandmisidentificationdisclo-suresofthelastfourdecadestaintedthereputationsofmanyrespectedlaboratories.Thisledtodenial,paranoia,andmockery.Theclimatesoengenderedwasnotconducivetothegenerationofpoliciesandpracticesthatwouldbeembracedprofession-wide.Contributingtothelackofactionwasthemistakenbeliefbysomethatdisclosurewouldautomaticallybefollowedbyindividualheightenedawarenessandremedialaction.Periodicreports,conferences,andsymposiacameandwentandhadinsufficientimpact(asisevidencedbythehighfrequencyofmisidenti-fication).Noencompassing,remedialplanwithreasonableexpectationsandwithmeasuredinduce-mentwasdevelopedtochallengetheprofession.Thecompellingneedforchangedpracticewasnotmatchedbycompellingsolutions.
Clearly,thecurrentsituationisintolerableandrequiresabroad,coordinatedeffortinvolvingthosewhodoresearch,fundresearch,publishfindingsofresearchandeducateresearchers.Thestrategyde-scribedbelowderivesitsmeritfromthecompellingneed,itsrelianceoncompliancemethodsusedinselectedsituationsbygovernmentagenciesandscientificjournals,andtheroleofprofessionalsocietiesasguardiansinadvancingthesearchfortruthandmaintenanceofhighstandards.
Generationofaplananditsimplementationshouldhaveasitshallmarkthespiritofcollegialityandmutualconcern.However,itmustalsobeunyieldingregardingtheneedfordecisiveactionthatleadstotheeliminationofthisscandaloussituation.
Aconferenceshouldbeconvenedtoanalyzethemajorfeaturesoftheproposedstrategy,aswellasalternativeones.
1.Itisproposedthatgovernmentandprivate
fundingagenciesbeprevailedupontorequirecelllineauthenticationasaconditionfortheawardofgrantandcontractfunds.
2.Itisalsoproposedthatkeyscientificjournalsbe
prevailedupontorequirecelllineauthenticationasaconditionforpublication.
Establishment of the Eukaryotic Cell Lines for Inducible Control of SARS-CoV Nucleocapsid Gene E_专业资料。VIOOC lIA,te002()6—6 RLGIASNCOcbr1,55:138o...
Database of Cross-Contaminated or Misidentified Cell Lines-v7_2 - 副本_电子/电路_工程科技_专业资料。Database of Cross-Contaminated or Misidentified Cell ...
List of contaminated cell lines From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia This is a list of cell cultures which have been cross-contaminated and overgrown by ...
8相 对活性 a :与对照组及抑制剂组比较, 00;bP<.1 :与同组 4h比较, 00;cP<.1 :与同组 8h 比较, 00P<.5 )*+, 0 /01201345 导N B细胞...
Effect of three suture lines on the proliferation and cell cycle of lung adenocarcinoma cell A54_专业资料。Eftofte utelnesont olertonanfec hresur i hepriai...
26, NO. 4, OCTOBER 2011 First-Zone Distance Relaying Algorithm of Parallel Transmission Lines for Cross-Country Nonearthed Faults Z. Y. Xu, Senior ...
Development of a tilting system for electric multiple unit to speed up on conventional lines 付费方式付费方式隐藏>> Journal of Journal of Mechanical ...
Development of a tilting system for electric multiple unit to speed up on conventional lines 付费方式付费方式隐藏>> Journal of Journal of Mechanical ...
热门文档