368Wenowattributetheextensivecontaminationtothefollowing:HeLa,becauseofitscelebratedstatus,waswidelydistributedandpassedonfromlaboratorytolaboratory,wherepractitionersdidnotalwaysexer-cisestringentcareand/orwereoblivioustocross-contaminationasaproblem.Also,HeLaprovedtobeaveryrobustcellinculturecapableofovergrowingmanyothercellsinmixedculture(Masters2002).ThereactionofthescientistsattheDecennialReviewConferencerangedfromdisbelieftoaccepting(seepages182–195ofNCIMonograph26,1967forverbatimdiscussion).
TheissuewassharplyfocusedandbroughttoabroadaudiencebyWalterNelson-Reesandhisassociateswhoshowedinaseriesofpapers(1974,1977,1981)thatextensivecross-contaminationandmisidentificationcharacterizedtheculturessenttohimforinclusionintherepositoryhewasmaintainingundercontractfortheNCI.InhisspeechontheoccasionofreceivingaLifetimeAchievementAwardfromtheSocietyforinVitroBiologyin2004,Nelson-Reesrecalledthatfrom1970through1974heauthored25researchaccounts“ofgreaterorlesserimportance,noneofwhichcausedastir.”The7June1974issueofScience,however,publishedapaperbasedonobservationsof20separatecellcultures,9ofwhichhadHeLabandedmarkersaswellasTypeAG6PD.Twoofthesecelllineswerepurportedtobebreastcarcinomacells(HBT-3,HBT39B).Athird,HEK(presumablyderivedfromhumanembryonickidney),wasidenticaltoHBT-3andHBT39B,whichwereHeLacells.Unfortunately,thesecellswerewidelyusedforbreastcancerresearch.Nelson-Reesrecalledthatthisfirstmajorlisting,particularlythewholesaleuseofthewrongcellsinextensiveprogramsofbreastcancerresearch“causedquiteatremor.”BarbaraCulliton(1974),acolumnistforSciencewroteinthesameissue,“IfNelson-Reesisright,alotofpeoplemayhavebeenspendingalotoftimeandmoneyonmisguidedresearch.”
Nelson-ReespointedoutthatwhileHeLacellcon-taminationiswidespread,otherhumanandanimalcellsarecontaminatingoneanother“...techniquesformain-tainingcellpuritymustbeappliedtoreduceitandtheproblemsitpresentstobiologiststhroughouttheworld.”Thelitanycontinuedthroughoutthe1970s,withadditionalrevelationsofinter-andintra-speciescross-contaminationandmorevehementaccusationsbeingexchanged,includingconcealmentofknowledgeandCellBiolToxicol(2007)23:367–372
manipulationthroughediting.ThisiswellillustratedinresponsetoapaperpublishedinNature(Harrisetal.1981).Ateamofsevenscientists,includingNelson-Rees,analyzedfour“unknown”culturespurportedtobeofHodgkindiseaseorigin.Allfour,includingthreeidenticalcultures,werenotHodgkinnorweretheyHeLa.Threewereofunidentifiedhumanoriginandthefourthwasnon-human,withakaryotypeidenticaltothatoftheNorthernColombianbrownfootowlmonkey,acelllinecarriedbythecontributorofthefourcellcultures(Harrisetal.1981).Suchalarge-scalemix-upinvokedtheverbalwrathofWashingtonreporterDavidDickson,whosediatribeincluded,“corruptionofscientificliterature...misleadingcol-leagues...forgery...falsifyingdata...lying...falseclaims...fraudagainstthefederalgovernment...acriminaloffense”(Dickson1981).
Amorequantitativeandbroaderpicturefollows.Nelson-Reesencountered279contaminatedcellculturessubmittedfrom45differentlaboratories.RecentsubmissionstotheGermanDSMZcellbankincludecohortsofhumanhematopoieticcelllines,14%ofwhicharecross-contaminated(Drexleretal.1999).Inanothersurvey,theyfoundthat45of326submissionswerecontaminated.Forty-twowereintraspecificcontaminants.Theseweresubmittedby27of93scientists(29%)whomadesubmissions(Drexleretal.2003).VanHelden(1988)reportedthatthehumanesophagealsquamouscarcinomacelllinesHCu10,18,22,27,and39weregeneticallyidentical,whileOguraetal.(1997)reportedthatlinesJTC-3,OF,andOEisolatedin1959,1969,and1971,respec-tively,wereHeLacells.Morerecently,Melcher(2005)reportedthattheputativenormalcolonepithelialcelllineNCOL-1wasprobablyderivedfromthecoloncarcinomaLoVo.Furthermore,spectralkaryotypingandDNAfingerprintingrevealedthatasublineofNCOL1andLoVowereidenticalwhileanotherputativesublineofNCOL1hadadditionalmarkers.SeeKnissetal.(2002)andMcLeodetal.(1999)forotherexamples.
Itishardtoestimatehowmuchmisguidedresearchisattributabletocross-contamination.But,again,wedohavedatathatprovideaconservativebutshockingestimate.Masters(2005)reportedattheAnnualMeetingoftheSocietyforinVitroBiologyonaMedlinesearchfortheyears2000–2004regardingthecontinueduseofcontaminatedcelllinesknowntobeHeLa.Theoutcomewasasfollows:Therewere
Establishment of the Eukaryotic Cell Lines for Inducible Control of SARS-CoV Nucleocapsid Gene E_专业资料。VIOOC lIA,te002()6—6 RLGIASNCOcbr1,55:138o...
Database of Cross-Contaminated or Misidentified Cell Lines-v7_2 - 副本_电子/电路_工程科技_专业资料。Database of Cross-Contaminated or Misidentified Cell ...
List of contaminated cell lines From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia This is a list of cell cultures which have been cross-contaminated and overgrown by ...
8相 对活性 a :与对照组及抑制剂组比较, 00;bP<.1 :与同组 4h比较, 00;cP<.1 :与同组 8h 比较, 00P<.5 )*+, 0 /01201345 导N B细胞...
Effect of three suture lines on the proliferation and cell cycle of lung adenocarcinoma cell A54_专业资料。Eftofte utelnesont olertonanfec hresur i hepriai...
26, NO. 4, OCTOBER 2011 First-Zone Distance Relaying Algorithm of Parallel Transmission Lines for Cross-Country Nonearthed Faults Z. Y. Xu, Senior ...
Development of a tilting system for electric multiple unit to speed up on conventional lines 付费方式付费方式隐藏>> Journal of Journal of Mechanical ...
Development of a tilting system for electric multiple unit to speed up on conventional lines 付费方式付费方式隐藏>> Journal of Journal of Mechanical ...
热门文档