管理学论文

strategieshaveyettobecomeautomatized,goaleffectsaredependentontheabilitytodiscoverappropriatetaskstrat-egies.Becausepeoplevarygreatlyintheirabilitytodothis,theeffectsizeforgoalsettingissmalleroncomplexthanonsimpletasks.Meta-analyses(Wood,Mento,&Locke,1987)haverevealedgoaldif cultyeffectsizes(d)of.48forthemostcomplextasksversus.67fortheleastcomplextasks.Forspeci cdif cultgoalsversusagoaltodoone’sbest,theeffectsizewas.41forthemostcomplextasksversus.77fortheleastcomplextasks.
Becausepeopleuseagreatervarietyofstrategiesontasksthatarecomplexthanontasksthatareeasy,measuresoftaskstrategyoftencorrelatemorehighlywithperfor-mancethandomeasuresofgoaldif culty(Chesney&Locke,1991).Inaddition,thereareoftengoal–strategyinteractions,withgoaleffectsstrongestwheneffectivestrategiesareused(Durham,Knight,&Locke,1997).
R.KanferandAckerman(1989)foundthatinanairtraf ccontrollersimulation(ahighlycomplextask),hav-ingaperformance-outcomegoalactuallyinterferedwithacquiringtheknowledgenecessarytoperformthetask.Peopleperformedbetterwhentheywereaskedtodotheirbest.However,WintersandLatham(1996)showedthatthefaultwaswiththetypeofgoalthathadbeensetratherthanwiththetheory.Theyfoundthatwhenaspeci cdif cultlearninggoalratherthanaperformancegoalwasset,consistentwithgoal-settingtheory,highgoalsledtosig-ni cantlyhigherperformanceonacomplextaskthandidthegeneralgoalofurgingpeopledotheirbest.
Anotherfactorthatmayfacilitateperformanceonnew,complextasksistheuseofproximalgoals.LathamandSeijts(1999),usingabusinessgame,foundthatdo-your-bestgoalsweremoreeffectivethandistalgoals,butwhenproximaloutcomegoalsweresetinadditiontothedistaloutcomegoal,self-ef cacyandpro tsweresigni -cantlyhigherthaninthedo-your-bestconditionorintheconditionwhereonlyadistaloutcomegoalhadbeenset.Indynamicsituations,itisimportanttoactivelysearchforfeedbackandreactquicklytoittoattainthegoal(Frese&Zapf,1994).AsDorner(1991)noted,performanceerrorsonadynamictaskareoftenduetode cientdecompositionofadistalgoalintoproximalgoals.ProximalgoalscanincreasewhatFreseandZapf(1994)callederrormanage-ment.Proximalfeedbackregardingerrorscanyieldinfor-mationforpeopleaboutwhethertheirpictureofrealityisalignedwithwhatisrequiredtoattaintheirgoal.
shipsamongassignedgoaldif culty,self-setgoaldif -culty,self-ef cacy,andperformanceareshowninFigure1.Observethatassigningachallenginggoalaloneraisesself-ef cacybecausethisisanimplicitexpressionofcon- dencebyaleaderthattheemployeecanattainthegoal.Thecorrelationbetweenself-setgoalsandself-ef cacyishigherwhennogoalsareassigned.
Themediatingeffectofself-setgoalsandself-ef cacyonmonetaryincentiveeffectswasnotedearlier(T.Leeetal.,1997).However,notallincentivestudieshavefoundamediatingeffect.Wood,Atkins,andBright(1999)showedthatincentiveeffectsweremediatedbyinstrumentalityoroutcomeexpectanciesratherthanbygoalsandef cacy.Also,whensummaryfeedbackisprovidedwithoutanygoals,thefeedbackeffectsaremediatedbythegoalsthataresetinresponsetothefeedback(Locke&Bryan,1968).BanduraandCervone(1986)foundthatbothgoalsandself-ef cacymediatedfeedbackeffects.Self-ef cacyisespeciallycriticalwhennegativesummaryfeedbackisgivenbecausetheperson’slevelofself-ef cacyfollowingsuchfeedbackdetermineswhethersubsequentgoalsareraisedorlowered.
Asnotedearlier,thebene tsofparticipationindeci-sionmakingareprimarilycognitiveratherthanmotiva-tional.However,LathamandYukl(1976)andLatham,Mitchell,andDossett(1978)foundthatemployeeswhowereallowedtoparticipateinsettinggoalssethighergoalsandhadhigherperformancethanthosewhowereassignedgoalsbythesupervisor.Thehigherthegoals,thehighertheperformance.Finally,KirkpatrickandLocke(1996)foundthatgoalsandself-ef cacymediatedtheeffectofvisionaryleadershiponemployeeperformance.
Satisfaction
Goalsare,atthesametime,anobjectoroutcometoaimforandastandardforjudgingsatisfaction.TosaythatoneistryingtoattainagoalofXmeansthatonewillnotbesatis edunlessoneattainsX.Thus,goalsserveasthein ectionpointorreferencestandardforsatisfactionversusdissatisfaction(Mento,Locke,&Klein,1992).Foranygiventrial,exceedingthegoalprovidesincreasingsatisfac-tionasthepositivediscrepancygrows,andnotreachingthegoalcreatesincreasingdissatisfactionasthenegativedis-
PersonalGoalsasMediatorsofExternalIncentives
WhatLocke(1991b)calledthemotivationhub,meaningwheretheactionis,consistsofpersonalgoals,includinggoalcommitment,andself-ef cacy.Thesevariablesareoften,thoughnotinvariably,themostimmediate,con-sciousmotivationaldeterminantsofaction.Assuch,theycanmediatetheeffectsofexternalincentives.
Forexample,assignedgoaleffectsaremediatedbypersonalorself-setgoalsthatpeoplechooseinresponsetotheassignment,aswellasbyself-ef cacy.Therelation-Figure1
RelationshipsAmongAssignedGoals,Self-SetGoals,Self-Efficacy,andPerformance
Note.AdaptedfromATheoryofGoalSettingandTaskPerformance(p.72),byE.A.LockeandG.P.Latham,1990,EnglewoodCliffs,NJ:PrenticeHall.Copyright1990byPrenticeHall.Reprintedwithpermission.
P. Latham (2002), “Building a Practically Useful Theory of Goal Setting and Task Motivation: A 35-Year Odyssey,” American Psychologist, 57, 705-717...
goal setting theory is linked to job design, motivation and performance 5....– Job enrichment – is the practice of building motivating factors into ...
goal setting theory is linked to job design, motivation and performance 5....– Job enrichment – is the practice of building motivating factors into ...
热门文档