管理学论文
Latham&Saari,1979b),thesupervisor’slegitimateau-thoritytoassigngoalscreatesdemandcharacteristics.
Analternativetoassigninggoalsistoallowsubordi-natestoparticipateinsettingthem.Thetheoryisthatthiswouldmakegoalsmoreimportanttothepersonbecauseonewould,atleastinpart,ownthegoals.AseriesofstudiesbyLathamandhiscolleaguesrevealedthat,whengoaldif cultyisheldconstant,performancesofthosewithparticipativelysetversusassignedgoalsdonotdiffersig-ni cantly(e.g.,Dossett,Latham,&Mitchell,1979;Latham&Marshall,1982;Latham&Saari,1979a,1979b;Latham&Steele,1983).Erezandhercolleagues(Erez,1986;Erez,Earley,&Hulin,1985;Erez&Kanfer,1983),however,reachedtheoppositeconclusion.
Workingcollaboratively,withLockeasmediator,LathamandErezexploredreasonsfortheircontradictory ndings.Theyfoundthatfromamotivationalperspective,anassignedgoalisaseffectiveasonethatissetparticipa-tivelyprovidedthatthepurposeorrationaleforthegoalisgiven.However,ifthegoalisassignedtersely(e.g.,“Dothis...”)withoutexplanation,itleadstoperformancethatissigni cantlylowerthanforaparticipativelysetgoal(Latham,Erez,&Locke,1988).Meta-analysesoftheef-fectsofparticipationindecisionmakingonperformance,forthosestudiesthatmeasuredperformanceobjectively,yieldedaneffectsizeofonly.11(Wagner&Gooding,1987a,1987b).
Subsequently,Locke,Alavi,andWagner(1997)foundthattheprimarybene tofparticipationindecisionmakingiscognitiveratherthanmotivationalinthatitstimulatesinformationexchange.Forexample,Lathametal.(1994)foundthatwithgoaldif cultylevelcontrolled,participationingoalsettinghadnobene cialeffectonperformance.However,peoplewhoparticipatedwithoth-ersinformulatingtaskstrategiesperformedsigni cantlybetterandhadhigherself-ef cacythanthosewhodidnotparticipateinformulatingstrategies.
Monetaryincentivesareonepracticaloutcomethatcanbeusedtoenhancegoalcommitment.However,thereareimportantcontingencyfactors.The rstistheamountoftheincentive;moremoneygainsmorecommitment.Second,goalsandincentivetypeinteract.Whenthegoalisverydif cult,payingpeopleonlyiftheyreachthegoal(i.e.,atask-and-bonussystem)canhurtperformance.Oncepeopleseethattheyarenotgettingthereward,theirper-sonalgoalandtheirself-ef cacydropand,consequently,sodoestheirperformance.Thisdropdoesnotoccurifthegoalismoderatelydif cultorifpeoplearegivenadif cultgoalandarepaidforperformance(e.g.,piecerate)ratherthangoalattainment(Latham&Kinne,1974;Latham&Yukl,1975;T.Lee,Locke,&Phan,1997).
Latham(2001)developedanempathyboxtohelpmanagersidentifynon nancialoutcomesthatemployeesexpectedasaresultofcommittingtoorrejectingaspeci cdif cultgoal.Inastudywherethegoalwastoreducetheft,whenself-ef cacyregardinghonestbehaviorwashigh,actionstakentochangeoutcomeexpectanciesledtoasigni cantdecreaseinstolenmaterial(Latham,2001).Self-efficacy.Asnoted,self-ef cacyenhancesgoalcommitment.Leaderscanraisetheself-ef cacyoftheirsubordinates(a)byensuringadequatetrainingtoincreasemasterythatprovidessuccessexperiences,(b)byrolemodelingor ndingmodelswithwhomthepersoncanidentify,and(c)throughpersuasivecommunicationthatexpressescon dencethatthepersoncanattainthegoal(Bandura,1997;White&Locke,2000).Thelattermayinvolvegivingsubordinatesinformationaboutstrategiesthatfacilitategoalattainment.Transformationalleadersraisetheef cacyofemployeesthroughinspiringmessagestoandcognitivestimulationofsubordinates(Bass,1985).Feedback
Forgoalstobeeffective,peopleneedsummaryfeedbackthatrevealsprogressinrelationtotheirgoals.Iftheydonotknowhowtheyaredoing,itisdif cultorimpossibleforthemtoadjustthelevelordirectionoftheireffortortoadjusttheirperformancestrategiestomatchwhatthegoalrequires.Ifthegoalistocutdown30treesinaday,peoplehavenowaytotelliftheyareontargetunlesstheyknowhowmanytreeshavebeencut.Whenpeople ndtheyarebelowtarget,theynormallyincreasetheireffort(Matsui,Okada,&Inoshita,1983)ortryanewstrategy.Summaryfeedbackisamoderatorofgoaleffectsinthatthecombi-nationofgoalsplusfeedbackismoreeffectivethangoalsalone(Bandura&Cervone,1983;Becker,1978;Erez,1977;Strang,Lawrence,&Fowler,1978).
Controltheory(Carver&Scheier,1981)alsoempha-sizestheimportanceofgoalsettingandfeedbackformo-tivation.Theassumptionsthatunderliecontroltheory,however,arequestionable(Locke,1991a,1994;Locke&Latham,1990).Inessence,thetheoryisbasedonama-chinemodelderivedfromcyberneticengineering(Powers,1978).Thesourceofmotivationisassertedtobeanegativefeedbackloop(suchasthatcharacterizingathermostat)thateliminatesgoal–performancediscrepancies.Thenatu-ralstateoftheorganismis,byimplication,oneofmotion-lessnessorrest.
ControltheoryisineffectamechanisticversionofHull’sdrivereductiontheory,whichwasabandonedde-cadesago.However,machinesdonotpossessinternalmotivationalstatesanddonothavegoalsoftheirown.Their“goals”arethoseofthemachine’sbuilders.Further-more,discrepancyreductionisaconsequenceratherthanacauseofgoal-directedbehavior.AsBandura(1989)stated,goalsettingis rstandforemostadiscrepancy-creatingprocess.Motivationrequiresfeed-forwardcontrolinaddi-tiontofeedback.Afterpeopleattainthegoaltheyhavebeenpursuing,theygenerallysetahighergoalforthem-selves.Thisadoptionofhighergoalscreatesratherthanreducesmotivationdiscrepanciestobemastered.“Selfmotivationthusinvolvesadualcyclicprocessofdisequili-bratorydiscrepancyproductionfollowedbyequilibratoryreduction”(Bandura,1989,p.38).TaskComplexity
Athirdmoderatorofgoaleffectsistaskcomplexity.Asthecomplexityofthetaskincreasesandhigherlevelskillsand
P. Latham (2002), “Building a Practically Useful Theory of Goal Setting and Task Motivation: A 35-Year Odyssey,” American Psychologist, 57, 705-717...
goal setting theory is linked to job design, motivation and performance 5....– Job enrichment – is the practice of building motivating factors into ...
goal setting theory is linked to job design, motivation and performance 5....– Job enrichment – is the practice of building motivating factors into ...
热门文档