文档下载 文档下载导航
设为首页 | 加入收藏
搜索 请输入内容:  
 导航当前位置: 文档下载 > 所有分类 > 人文社科 > 教育学/心理学 > weigle2004
侵权投诉

weigle2004

读写结合

30S.C.Weigle/AssessingWriting9(2004)27–55

Anumberofstudieshavedocumentedthedif cultiesthatmanyESLstudents

haveinpassingmandatedwritingpro ciencyexaminations.Ruetten(1994)re-

portedthat62%ofNNSsfailedawritingtestgivenattheendofthesecond-semester

freshmancompositioncourseattheUniversityofNewOrleans,comparedto30%

ofNSs.Johns(1991)presentedacasestudyofanotherwisesuccessfulNNSstu-

dentwhowasunabletopassthewritingpro ciencyexaminationatSanDiego

StateUniversity.Thisstudent,abiochemistrymajor,hadpassedallhisgeneral

educationcoursesandhadahighgradepointaveragebuthiseffortstoobtainhis

degreewerehinderedbyhisinabilitytopassthemandatedwritingexamination.

AtGeorgiaStateUniversity,ByrdandNelson(1995)reportedapassrateof

49%ontheAlternateRegentsEssayTestamong rst-timetesttakersin1991.

Fouryearslater,8%ofthestudentswhohadtakentheteststillhadnotpassedthe

test.ByrdandNelsonfoundthatafewofthesestudentsmatchedthepro leof

Johns’(1991)casestudy:studentsinthescienceswithabove-averagegradeswho

nonethelesshavedif cultypassingthetest.Forthemajorityofrepeatfailures,

however,thefailuretopassthetestwas“partofanoverallpatternofacademic

struggleandfailure”(p.280);thesestudentsgenerallyhadlowgrades,including

severalwithdrawalsfromcoursesorfailinggrades.

Analternativetoprompt-basedimpromptuwritingtestisatestthatintegrates

readingwithwritingbyhavingexamineesreadandrespondtooneormoresource

texts.Whilesource-basedwritingtestscannotovercomemanyoftheproblems

inherentinwritingtests,theydohavesomeadvantagesoverprompt-basedtests.

First,agreatdealofresearchonacademicwritinghighlightsthefactthatacademic

writingisrarelydoneinisolation,butisvirtuallyalwaysdoneinresponseto

sourcetexts(Cumming,Kantor,Powers,Santos,&Taylor,2000;Haleetal.,1996;

Hamp-Lyons&Kroll,1996;Horowitz,1991;Leki&Carson,1997;Weigle,2002).

Thatis,studentsincontentcourses(withtheexceptionofcomposition)arerarely

ifeveraskedtowriteessaysbasedsolelyontheirbackgroundknowledge;before

theywriteonagiventopictheyareexpectedtoread,discuss,andthinkcritically

aboutthattopic.

Anotherargumentforusingasourcetextasabasisforwritingisthatitpro-

videsacommoninformationsourceforalltesttakers,puttingthemonamoreequal

footingintermsoftheamountofbackgroundknowledgeneededtorespondtoa

writingtask.Furthermore,asourcetextcanservetoactivatethewriter’sknowl-

edgeorschemataaroundatopic,helpingthemgenerateideasfortheirwriting.

Someresearchsuggeststhatseveralshortreadingsonarelatedtopicmaybeeven

moreeffectivethanasinglelongerreadingbyprovidingseveraldifferentwaysof

approachingthetopic(Smithetal.,1985).

Hamp-LyonsandKroll(1996)arguefortheviewthatacademicwritingshould

beviewedinthecontextofacademicliteracy:inordertobepartofthe“academic

conversation”(p.226),studentsmustrespondtotextsthathavebeenwrittenand

inviteresponsestotheirowntexts.Thisviewofacademicliteracysuggeststhat

testsshouldincludesomeintegrationofreadingwithwriting,forexample,by

providingasourcetextforwriterstorespondto.AsimilarpointismadebyLeki

上一页第4页

你可能喜欢

热门文档

相关文档

站点地图 | 文档上传 | 侵权投诉 | 手机版
本站所有资源均来自互联网,本站只负责收集和整理,均不承担任何法律责任,如有侵权等其它行为请联系我们.
文档下载 Copyright 2013 doc.guandang.net All Rights Reserved.  -  email