文档下载 文档下载导航
设为首页 | 加入收藏
搜索 请输入内容:  
 导航当前位置: 文档下载 > 所有分类 > 人文社科 > 教育学/心理学 > weigle2004
侵权投诉

weigle2004

读写结合

S.C.Weigle/AssessingWriting9(2004)27–5529

students.Allnativespeakersmusttakethesametest,whileindividualcampuses

havetheoptionofdesigningtheirownassessmentsforNNSs,aslongasthis

assessmentincludesanessay.AtGeorgiaStateUniversity,theassessmentpro-

cedureforNNSsformanyyearswasanadaptationoftheRegularRegentsTest,

describedinthefollowing.FacultyinvolvedinthescoringofthetestforNNSsand

inpreparingstudentsforthetestfoundthetestproblematic,however,andwhena

decisionwasmadein2000tomovetheassessmentofNNSsawayfromthecampus

testingcentertotheDepartmentofAppliedLinguisticsandESL,anopportunity

wascreatedtoimprovethetestingproceduresforNNSs.Thispaperdescribesthe

newtestandstepsthathavebeentakentovalidateit.InthepaperIarguethata

testofwritingthatincorporatesreadingcanprovidemorevalidinformationabout

students’abilitytowriteatthecollegelevelthanaprompt-basedessaytest.

2.Background

Asnotedabove,seriousdoubtshavebeenraisedovertheyearsoftheap-

propriatenessofrequiringstudentstopassanessaytestasasinglecriterionfor

high-stakesdecisions.Theargumentsagainsttimedimpromptuessaytestscenter

aroundissuesofreliability,authenticity,andvalidity.Intermsofreliability,the

twomainsourcesoferrorvarianceinscoringessaysareratersandtasks,asnoted

above.Errorvarianceduetoraterscanbereducedthroughtheuseofmultipleraters

andappropriatetraining,buterrorvarianceduetothesamplingofwritingtaskscan

beamoreseriousproblem,particularlyifexamineeswriteonasingletaskchosen

bytheexaminer(Breland,1996).Havingstudentswriteonmultipletaskscanhelp

mitigatethisproblem,butthissolutioncanbecostlyintermsofadministration

timeandresourcesforscoring.Asforauthenticity,severalscholarshavepointed

outthatwritinganessayonapreviouslyunseentopicisaninauthentictaskas

farasacademicwritingisconcerned,asstudentsrarelyifeverfacethistaskin

anyoftheircontentcourses.Finally,intermsofvalidity,the“snapshot”approach

towriting(Hamp-Lyons&Kroll,1996)isverylimitedinitsabilitytoassessthe

fullrangeofawriter’sability,asitdoesnotprovideopportunitiesforstudentsto

expressthemselvesinmorethanasinglegenreforasinglepurpose.Furthermore,

questionshavebeenraisedaboutthereductivenatureofholisticscoring(Charney,

1984;Huot,1990)becauseitreducesthecomplexmultifacetednatureofreading

toasinglenumber.

ForNNSs,timedimpromptuessaysmaybeevenmoreproblematic,particularly

whentheiressaysarescoredalongwithNSessays.Researchsuggeststhatraters

whohavenothadtrainingorexperiencewiththewritingofsecond-languageusers

maygiveundueattentiontosentence-levelerrors(Sweedler-Brown,1985)andthat

facultyfromdifferentdisciplinesmayusedifferentcriteriaforjudgingNNSwriting

(Brown,1991;Mendelsohn&Cumming,1987;Santos,1988).Furthermore,using

asinglescaletorateessaysisparticularlyproblematicforNNSs,whomaydevelop

differentaspectsofwritingskillatdifferentrates(Hamp-Lyons,1991).

上一页第3页

你可能喜欢

热门文档

相关文档

站点地图 | 文档上传 | 侵权投诉 | 手机版
本站所有资源均来自互联网,本站只负责收集和整理,均不承担任何法律责任,如有侵权等其它行为请联系我们.
文档下载 Copyright 2013 doc.guandang.net All Rights Reserved.  -  email