

JournalofAccountingandEconomics57(2014)89–109
ContentslistsavailableatScienceDirect
JournalofAccountingandEconomics
journalhomepage:doc.guandang.net
Theimpactofissuer-payoncorporatebondratingproperties:EvidencefromMoody'sandS&P'sinitialadoptions$
SamuelB.BonsallIV
FisherCollegeofBusiness,TheOhioStateUniversity,2100NeilAvenue,Columbus,OH43210,UnitedStates
articleinfo
Articlehistory:
Received15August2012Receivedinrevisedform12December2013
Accepted7January2014
Availableonline27January2014JELclassification:D82D83G24G28
Keywords:
BondratingagenciesIssuer-paymodelConflictsofinterestRatingqualityAccuracyTimeliness
abstract
ThisstudyexamineswhetherandhowthepropertiesofcorporatebondratingschangefollowingMoody'sandS&P'sadoptionsoftheissuer-paybusinessmodelintheearly1970s.Regulatorsanddebtmarketobservershavecriticizedtheissuer-paymodelforcreatinganindependenceproblem.However,theissuer-paymodelallowsforeconomicbondingbetweenratingagenciesandissuersthroughexplicitcontractualarrangements,whichshouldimprovetheflowofnonpublicinformation.Usingadifference-in-differenceresearchdesign,Ifindthatmoreoptimisticratingsbyissuer-payratingagenciespredictgreaterfutureprofitability,differencesbetweentheratingsofissuer-payandinvestor-payratingagenciesareassociatedwithnarrowersecondarybondmarketbid-askspreads,andthatissuer-payratingagenciesbecomerelativelymoreaccurateandtimelypredictorsofdefaultcomparedtoinvestor-payagenciesaftertheadoptionofissuer-pay.TheseresultsreinterprettherecentfindingsofoptimisticratingsbyJiangetal.(2012)asconsistentwithmoreinformativebondratings.
&2014ElsevierB.V.Allrightsreserved.
1.Introduction
Bondratingagenciesplayacriticalroleinintermediatingbondmarketsbyprovidinginformationtoprospectiveinvestorsaboutthedefaultriskofbondissues.Apopularconcernregardingtheratings'processisthatthebondissuergenerallypaystheratingagency,whichpotentiallycompromisestheinformationcontentoftheratingbycreatinganindependenceproblem.1Infact,legislators'concernsaresignificantenoughthattheDodd–FrankActof2010hasrequiredtheSecuritiesandExchangeCommission(SEC)tostudyratingagencyrevenuemodels.Althoughtherelationbetweenthe
ThispaperisbasedonmydissertationcompletedatthePennsylvaniaStateUniversity.Ioweadebtofgratitudetomydissertationcommitteeforitsguidanceandsupportonthisproject:PaulFischer(co-chair),KarlMuller(co-chair),OrieBarron,DanGivoly,andJayHuang.IwouldalsoliketothankWalidAlissa,KarthikBalakrishnan,AnneBeatty,ZahnBozanic,CraigChapman,AnnaCostello,RichFrankel,MichelleHanlon,P.J.Hoffman,KevinKoharki,S.P.Kothari,PepaKraft(referee),BrianMiller,MiguelMinutti-Meza,DarrenRoulstone,CathySchrand,CathyShakespeare,NemitShroff,DanTaylor,JoeWeber,HollyYang,andJerryZimmerman(editor)fortheirhelpfulcomments.ThismanuscripthasbenefittedgreatlyfromtheinputofworkshopparticipantsatthePennsylvaniaStateUniversity,theUniversityofUtah,WashingtonUniversityinSt.Louis,theUniversityofMiami,theUniversityofMichigan,theUniversityofPennsylvania,DartmouthCollege,theUniversityofMinnesota,theMassachusettsInstituteofTechnology,StanfordUniversity,DukeUniversity,NorthwesternUniversity,theUniversityofNotreDame,theUniversityofIllinois,GeorgetownUniversity,theUniversityofGeorgia,RiceUniversity,theOhioStateUniversity,theUniversityofCaliforniaatLosAngeles,andtheUniversityofHouston.IamgratefultotheSmealCollegeofBusinessandtheFisherCollegeofBusinessfortheirfinancial

support.
1
SeeCoffee(2008),Egan(2008),Gellert(2009),SecuritiesandExchangeCommission(2003),andPartnoy(1999,2001,2006)forvariousallegationsofunderperformancebytheratingagenciesasaresultofreceivingfeesfromdebtsecurityissuers.0165-4101/$-seefrontmatter&2014ElsevierB.V.Allrightsreserved.doc.guandang.net
☆
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/mar The impact of the corporate balanced scorecard on corporate control—A research note Kalle Kraus, Johnny Lind...
coupon bonds except A) Corporate bonds B) U.S...the impact of this change was a ___ interest ...C) They both involve a claim on the issuer's...
the cash flows on the bond will not change (i...the credit quality of an issuer of a corporate ...impact future cash flows Zero-coupon bonds: ...
yields, prices, popular types of corporate bonds....the impact of required return and time to ...Table 6.1 Debt-Specific Issuer- and Issue-...
types, and international issues of corporate bonds...the impact of required return and time to ...The theory holds that for a given issuer, long...
of return investors earn if they buy the bond ...Changes in interest rates have larger impact on ...16 Types of Bonds: By Issuer Corporate Bonds ...
Recovery Rates on Defaulted Corporate Bonds_经管营销_专业资料。Recovery Rates... The impact of issuer-p... 暂无评价 21页 1下载券 Pricing Corporate Bond...
portfolio of securities such as stocks and bonds....issuer, and the cost of acquiring that ...Corporate restructuring hedge fund 公司重组型对冲...
have little impact on the value of the ...The yield on corporate bonds is higher than that... usually so that the issuer can issue new bonds...
impact on stakeholders regulation expertise expenses ...Corporate bonds – similar to government bonds but...the issuer and may change during the course of ...
热门文档