文档下载 文档下载导航
设为首页 | 加入收藏
搜索 请输入内容:  
 导航当前位置: 文档下载 > 所有分类 > IT/计算机 > 计算机硬件及网络 > The impact of issuer-pay on corporate bonds
侵权投诉

The impact of issuer-pay on corporate bonds

90S.B.BonsallIV/JournalofAccountingandEconomics57(2014)89–109

ratingagencyandthefirmwhosebondisbeingratedcreatesapotentialindependenceproblem,ratingagencies'desirestomaintaintheirreputationsinthemarketplacecouldmitigatethatproblem.2Furthermore,thebusinessrelationitselfmayallowtheratingagencytoobtainadditionalinformationaboutissuers'prospectsbecauseofreduceddisclosurecostsfacedbyissuers,whichwouldpotentiallyincreasetheinformationcontentoftherating.3Thus,itisunclearhowtheratingagency'srevenuemodelinfluencestheinformationcontentofabondrating.Inordertoassesshowissuer-payinfluencestheinformationcontentofratings,Iexaminewhethertheadoptionoftheissuer-payrevenuemodel(issuer-pay)bymajorratingagenciesleadstosystematicchangesintheinformationconveyedbytheirratings.4

Usingadifference-in-difference(DID)researchdesign,Ifindthatdifferencesbetweenthecorporatebondratingsoftestandcontrolratingagenciesaremorestronglyassociatedwithissuers'futureprofitabilityandsecondarybondmarketbid-askspreadsandthattestratingagenciesbecomerelativelymoreaccurateandtimelypredictorsofdefaultcomparedtocontrolagenciesaftertheadoptionofissuer-pay.Theseprimaryresultsaresomewhatweakerfortheratingsofissuersthatgeneratepresumablythemostfeerevenueforissuer-payratingagencies,consistentwithcateringincentivesreducingoverallissuer-payratingimprovements,andstrongerforratingsofissuerswithpoorerinformationenvironments.Thepoorinformationenvironmentresultssuggestthatinthecross-sectionofissuerswiththeleastrobustpublicinformation,increasedaccesstononpublicinformationimprovestheissuer-payratingagencies'ratingsthemost.Inarecentstudy,Jiangetal.(2012)findevidencethatMoody'sInvestorsService(Moody's)providedmoreoptimisticratingsthanStandard&Poor's(S&P)priortoS&P'sadoptionofissuer-payin1974butnotfollowS&P'sadoption.Overall,thisstudy'sresultsreinterprettherecentfindingsofoptimisticratingsbyJiangetal.(2012)asconsistentwithmoreinformativebondratings.WhilethefindingsofJiangetal.(2012)aresomewhatindicativeofbiasinbondratingsfollowingtheadoptionofissuer-pay,myresultssuggestthatseeminglymoreoptimisticratingsareassociatedwithstrongerfuturefinancialperformance,contrarytoexpectationsundertheassumptionofbias.

FollowingJiangetal.(2012),Itakeadvantageofaquasi-experiment—theinitialadoptionofissuer-paybyMoody'sandS&Pinthe1970s—totestwhethertheinformationcontentofbondratingsworsenedorimprovedunderissuer-payrelativetoinvestor-payinaDIDresearchdesign.Thissettingallowsmetoholdconstantotherpotentialdriversofbondratingquality,suchastheprovisionofconsultingservices,andfocusonlyonhowchargingissuersforbondratingsaffectsratings'informativeness.Furthermore,Icancompareeachratingagencytotheotherasacontrolgroup.AsinitiallydescribedbyJiangetal.(2012),onOctober1,1970Moody'sbecamethefirstmajorratingagencytochargecorporateissuersaftermanydecadesofearningrevenuefromthesaleofitsresearchtoinvestorsthroughitsMoody'sIndustrialManuals.S&Pdelayedchangingtoissuer-payuntilJuly1,1974,afteralsooriginallyusinganinvestor-paymodel.

Theadoptionofissuer-paycould,ascriticssuggest,createincentivesforthemajorratingagenciestobecomemorealignedwiththeirclients.Thiscouldleadratingagenciestoonlycommunicateinformationthatbenefitstheirclients,resultinginlessinformativeratingsunderissuer-paythaninvestor-pay.However,asdiscussedbyCantorandPacker(1994)andCovitzandHarrison(2003),thepossibilityforreducedcommunicationistemperedbypotentialreputationalconsequences.

Alternatively,theadoptionofissuer-paycouldleadtomoreinformativeratingsbecausethemajorratingagencieswouldgaingreateraccesstoprivateinformationandbetterresources.First,issuersfaceapotentiallygreaterincentivetodisclosetheirprivateinformationtoratingagenciesfollowingissuer-payadoption.Issuers,naturallymotivatedtolowertheircostofdebtbyfullydisclosingtheirprivateinformationtopotentialinvestors,typicallylimittheirdisclosurebecauseofcosts(e.g.,proprietary,litigation).Theycould,however,safelyprovidedetailedprivateinformationtoratingagenciesintheirroleasinformationintermediariesbecausedisclosedinformationisonlypartiallyconveyedthroughcreditratings(GriffinandSanvicente,1982;KligerandSarig,2000;Tang,2009;Walker,2010)andissuerscanbetterlegallyprotectconfidentialinformationdisclosedtoaratingagencyreceivingcompensationforitsservicesbasedontradesecretlaw(Saulino,2002).5Underissuer-pay,thefiduciaryresponsibilityofratingagenciestowardtheissuertonotrevealtheissuer'sprivateinformationispotentiallygreaterbecauseoftheexplicitcontractualrelationshipbetweentheissuerandtheratingagencyanditsaccompanyingeconomicconsiderationtomaintainconfidentiality(Bast,1999;Whaley,1998).6Inthissense,issuer-payshouldpromotethesharingofvalue-relevantinformationwithratingagencies.

VariousstudieshavenotedtheimportanceofreputationtobondratingagenciesincludingCantorandPacker(1994),SmithandWalter(2002),CovitzandHarrison(2003),andSecuritiesandExchangeCommission(2003).

3

Severalacademicstudieshaveconjecturedthatratingagenciesmaybenefitfromthesharingofprivateinformationfrombondissuers(GriffinandSanvicente,1982;KligerandSarig,2000).Furthermore,theratingagenciesthemselvesandindustryobservershaveassertedthatthemovetotheissuer-paymodelledtogreateraccesstoinformation(McDaniel,2009;Walker,2010).Itesttheseconjecturesdirectly.

4

Bondratingagenciesarenottheonlyinformationintermediariesthatfaceapotentialindependenceproblem.Auditfirmsreceivefeesinexchangeforanopinionastowhetheracompany'sfinancialstatementsconformwithgenerallyacceptedaccountingprinciples(GAAPs).Inaddition,equityanalystswhosefirmsprovideinvestmentbankingservicesalsofacetheso-calledindependenceproblemwhenofferingstockrecommendationsandearningforecastsaboutinvestmentbankingclients.Finally,theBetterBusinessBureau'sreliabilityratings,theAmericanAutomobileAssociation'sdiamondratingsforhospitalityproviders,andUnderwritersLaboratory'scertificationsofproductqualityandsafetyallrelyonfeespaidbythecompanyseekingtherating.

5

Severalempiricalstudiessuggestthatbondratingsdocontainprivateinformation(ButlerandCornaggia,2012;Gan,2004;Jorionetal.,2005)However,asnotedbyGriffinandSanvicente(1982),itisdifficulttoconcludeunambiguouslythatinformationproducedbytheratingagenciespersedrivesequitymarketreactionstoratingchangesratherthaninformationcorrelatedwiththeratingprocess.Tang(2009),however,findsthatfollowingMoody'srefinementofitsratingscale,firmsthatreceivedhigher(lower)refinedratingsexperienceadecrease(increase)intheirbondyieldspreads.

6

Infact,issuer-paybutnotinvestor-payratingagenciesfrequentlysignconfidentialityagreementswiththeirissuerclientstocoverallsharedmaterialnonpublicinformation(LangohrandLangohr,2008).

2

上一页第2页

你可能喜欢

热门文档

相关文档

  • The impact of the corporate balanced scorecard on c...

    journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/mar The impact of the corporate balanced scorecard on corporate control—A research note Kalle Kraus, Johnny Lind...

  • 货币银行学练习题exercises(Part 1&2)

    coupon bonds except A) Corporate bonds B) U.S...the impact of this change was a ___ interest ...C) They both involve a claim on the issuer's...

  • 【(8)-Fixed Income Investments】(11CFA二级强化)

    the cash flows on the bond will not change (i...the credit quality of an issuer of a corporate ...impact future cash flows Zero-coupon bonds: ...

  • management 企业管理类英文版PPT课件 (34)

    yields, prices, popular types of corporate bonds....the impact of required return and time to ...Table 6.1 Debt-Specific Issuer- and Issue-...

  • 财管课件Financial Management-topic04-2013

    types, and international issues of corporate bonds...the impact of required return and time to ...The theory holds that for a given issuer, long...

  • Valuing bonds

    of return investors earn if they buy the bond ...Changes in interest rates have larger impact on ...16 Types of Bonds: By Issuer Corporate Bonds ...

  • Recovery Rates on Defaulted Corporate Bonds

    Recovery Rates on Defaulted Corporate Bonds_经管营销_专业资料。Recovery Rates... The impact of issuer-p... 暂无评价 21页 1下载券 Pricing Corporate Bond...

  • 词语解释 终结版

    portfolio of securities such as stocks and bonds....issuer, and the cost of acquiring that ...Corporate restructuring hedge fund 公司重组型对冲...

  • Unit 10

    have little impact on the value of the ...The yield on corporate bonds is higher than that... usually so that the issuer can issue new bonds...

  • 贵金属投资技术分析英文版 (3)

    impact on stakeholders regulation expertise expenses ...Corporate bonds – similar to government bonds but...the issuer and may change during the course of ...

站点地图 | 文档上传 | 侵权投诉 | 手机版
本站所有资源均来自互联网,本站只负责收集和整理,均不承担任何法律责任,如有侵权等其它行为请联系我们.
文档下载 Copyright 2013 doc.guandang.net All Rights Reserved.  -  email