The trend of the lateral displacement was well predicted. Figure 11 compares the measured data with the predicted data for section 9. It can be seen that the numerical displacements matches quite closely with the general trend of the inclinometer readings. However most of the numerical runs predicted smaller maximum deflection at the top of the inclinometers. Detail wise, along the deflection, current 2-D analysis did not cap-ture the changes in rotation due to the fact that in the current analyses the simplification of discrete soil nails as plates causes ‘shielding’ of soil movement ( Top of nail and bottom of nail). Therefore in a 2-D analysis the exact soil nail-soil interaction behavior is not captured.
The general feature of the comparative study is to investigate the use of FEM in assessing the Factor-of-safety. Stability calculations in Plaxis are conducted using the Phi-C routine and were compared to coventional slope stability methods such as the ‘Method of slices’. The following comparative finite element analysis was conducted:
Group 1: Unreinforced slope with two different slope face angle using FEM and LEM Group 2: Reinforced slope with two different slope face angle using FEM and LEM Group 3: The influence of ultimate pullout force to soil strength ratio on factor-of-safety
The geometry and parameter adopted in the parametric analysis is given in Figure 12 and Table 3. The fail-ure mechanism predicted by both FEM and LEM in indicated in Figures 13a and b. For the 30 degree slope face both methods give very similar factor-of-safety values but for the 75 degree slope face the factor-of-safety value is dissimilar. As indicated in Table 4, the factor-of-safety values calculated using phi-c reduction is al-ways smaller than the method-of-slices. The failure mechanism predicted using FEM and LEM is also differ-ent for a slope face of 75 degrees. Possible reasons for the disparity in the predictions are: 1. Different mobilized resisting forces along the soil nails
2. Progressive failure is not mimic in Limit Equilibrium methods
3. The slip-surface in Limit equilibrium methods are confined to certain assume generic pattern, whereas
in FEM, the formation of the slip surface is due to the natural progression stresses and strains.
The altered geometrical behavior of the soil nails does not mimic accurately the real behavior and therefore the calculated axial force distribution is not well captured. In the current analysis the interface elements adopt a simplistic elastic perfect-plastic law and therefore do not capture the non-linear elastic hardening/softening behavior of real behavior. Better interface models will be used in the future to investigate to better capture the pullout response due to stress-relief. Construction details like drilling and post grouting was not taken into ac-count in the finite element analyses. It is known that the post grouting process produces a higher coefficient of friction and therefore a stiffer and higher pullout response. It is possible to capture this behavior in the current FEM code through the use of separate interface properties.
The implication of FEM vs LEM parametric analysis is that both methods provided similar factor-of-safety values and failure mechanism pattern for the 30 degree slope face. For a steeper slope face of 75 degrees, the factor-of-safety value is dissimilar by as much as 50% in some cases. The finite element method provided the lowest values. For slope face of 75 degree, Limit Equilibrium methods may not give the lowest critical Factor-of-safety. It was also found that with high nail forces, Limit Equilibrium method predicted un-conservative factor-of-safety values when compared with the Finite Element method.




Finite Element Analysis ... 10页 免费 ... Analysis of soil nailed earth slope by discrete...some degree of accuracy, and local safety factors...
Analysis of soil nailed ... 14页 免费 (贾永辉)Finite element a... ...χ in Bishop’s strength equation can be obtained according to experience, ...
Soil fungistasis and i... 暂无评价 7页 2.00 A case study on the me... 暂无评价 9页 免费 Eyeful-Case Study-Lain... 4页 1下载券 A Case...
Finite element analysis grid chart 本文把按照以上...soil nailed wall 为了分析土钉墙支护极限高度的影响...soil and horizontal displacement of toe of slope ...
Soil fungistasis and i... 暂无评价 7页 2.00 A case study on the me... 暂无评价 9页 免费 Eyeful-Case Study-Lain... 4页 1下载券 A Case...
热门文档