DETERMINING THE COMPOSITION AND BENEFIT OF THE PRE-HOSPITAL MEDICAL RESPONSE TEAM IN THE CONFLICT SETTING
SYSTEMSANALYSIS
DETERMININGTHECOMPOSITIONANDBENEFITOFTHEPRE-HOSPITALMEDICALRESPONSETEAMINTHECONFLICTSETTING
PRDavis1,ACRickards2,JEOllerton3
ConsultantEmergencyMedicine,16CloseSupportMedicalRegiment,2SpecialistRegistrarEmergencyMedicineGlasgow,3
ConsultantEmergencyMedicine,QueensMedicalCentre,Nottingham
1
Abstract
Aim:Todeterminetheoptimalcompositionofthepre-hospitalmedicalresponseteam(MERT)andthevalueofpre-hospitalcriticalcareinterventionsinamilitarysetting,andspecificallytodetermineboththebenefitofincludingadoctorinthepre-hospitalresponseteamandtherelevanceofthetimeanddistancetodefinitivecare.
Method:Acomprehensivereviewoftheliteratureincorporatingarangeofelectronicsearchenginesandhandsearchesofkeyjournals.
Results:Therewasnolevel1evidenceonwhichtobaseconclusions.The15mostrelevantarticleswereanalysedindetail.Therewasonerandomizedcontrolledtrial(level2evidence)thatsupportstheinclusionofadoctoronMERT.Severalcohortstudieswereidentifiedthatanalysedthebenefitsofspecificcriticalcareinterventionsinthepre-hospitalsetting.Conclusions:AdoctorwithcriticalcareskillsdeployedontheMERTisassociatedwithimprovedsurvivalinvictimsofmajortrauma.Specificcriticalcareinterventionsincludingemergencyendotrachealintubationandventilation,andintercostaldrainageareassociatedwithimprovedsurvivalandfunctionalrecoveryincertainpatients.Thesebenefitsappeartobemoreeasilydemonstratedfortheruralandremotesettingthanfortheurbansetting.Pre-hospitalcriticalcareisanareaunderclosescrutiny.ThereisalackofrobustclinicalevidenceonwhichtobaseMERTcrewcompositionandcurrentmanagementprotocols.Thereisdiscrepancybetweentheevidenceforbestpre-hospitalmanagementinurbanversusruralandremotesettings[1,2,3].Duringoperationsthetacticalsituationwillinfluencebestpracticebecauseoptimalpatientcaremustbebalancedagainsttherisktoallpersonnelinvolvedintheretrievalofacriticallyillorinjuredpatient.Thedistanceandtimefromdefinitivecare,theavailabilityofskilledmedicalpersonnelandthetimeavailableon-sceneforcomplexmedicalinterventionsarefactorsthatmaybeinfluencedduringoperations.
Thisliteraturereviewaimstoexplorecurrentevidencewithregardstothreeclinicalquestions.
1.Inthepre-hospitalmanagementofmilitarytraumapatientsistheclinicaloutcomeaffectedbytheattendanceofanemergencymedicaltechnician(EMT),paramedicornursingofficer?
2.Inthepre-hospitalmanagementoftrauma,doesthepresenceofadoctorinfluenceclinicaloutcome?
3.Inthemanagementoftime-criticalinjuriesinpre-hospitaltraumapatients,doesevidenceexisttosupportcriticalcareinterventionsinthefollowingsituations:
a)Theurbanversustheruralenvironment?
b)Whereevacuationtodefinitivecaremaybedelayed?c)Incasesofpenetratingversusblunttrauma?CorrespondingAuthor:LtColPeterDavisMRCGPFACEMDipIMCDipMtnMedRAMC
ConsultantEmergencyMedicine,16CloseSupportMedicalRegiment,SouthernGeneralHospital,GlasgowG514TF
E:petedavis@doctors.org.ukJRArmyMedCorps153(4):269-273
IntroductionMethodology:SearchStrategy
AdetailedsearchofMEDLINE,Cinahl,EmbaseandPubMedwasperformedinFebruary2007.InternetsearchesofGoogleScholar,GoogleandMDConsult(Elsevier)werecompletedinFebruary2007.Keywordsused:militarymedicine;pre-hospital;personnel;outcome;nurse;emergencymedicaltechnician;paramedic.Relevantarticleswereselectedbythetitlesandabstractswithasubsequenthandsearchofkeypublications.
Results
Twenty-threearticleswereidentifiedandstudiedindetail;15weremostrelevanttotheclinicalquestions.Thelevelofevidencerangedfromalevel2randomisedclinicaltrialtolevel4materialthatincludedletters,commentaries,eventanalyses,andliteraturereviews.Unpublishedworkanalysingtheevidenceforpre-hospitalcriticalcareinterventionandthecompositionofpre-hospitalaeromedicalteamsisincludedfromapaperwrittenby16CloseSupportMedicalRegiment(16CSMedRegt)whiledeployedinAfghanistan[4].
AsummaryofthearticleshighlightedintheliteraturesearchandmostrelevanttotheclinicalquestionsisincludedinTable1.
SummaryoftheEvidence
1.Theinclusionofadoctorwithcriticalcareskillsisassociatedwithimprovedsurvivalinvictimsofmajortrauma.
2.Emergencyanaesthesiaandcontrolledventilationpre-hospitalisassociatedwithimprovedsurvivalinvictimsofseveretraumaticbraininjury(TBI).
3.Emergencyanaesthesia,controlledventilationandintercostalsdrainagepre-hospitalisassociatedwithimprovedsurvivalinvictimsofseverethoracicinjury.
269
Comparison of the United Kingdom and the United ...hospital hospital leadership composition of the ...response to Hurricane Katrina between the state ...
Tufts-New England Medical Center - - Office of ...In determining the number of subjects to be ...yes, what is the length of the hospital stay?...
The Effect of Pharmacy Benefit Design on Patient-...Brigham and Women’s Hospital, Boston, MA, USA...patients aged 53 to 82 (73% response rate). ...
and an EVO grant from Turku University Hospital....the gastrointestinal tract in response to massive ...PCR-DGGE The composition of Lactobacillus spp. ...
and an EVO grant from Turku University Hospital....the gastrointestinal tract in response to massive ...PCR-DGGE The composition of Lactobacillus spp. ...
热门文档