三种方法测定葡萄园耗水的对比研究
HYDROLOGICALPROCESSES
Hydrol.Process.22,4554–4564(2008)
Publishedonline3June2008inWileyInterScience(doc.guandang.net)DOI:10.1002/hyp.7059
Acomparisonofthreemethodsfordeterminingvineyardevapotranspirationintheariddesertregionsofnorthwest
China
SienLi,1ShaozhongKang,1*LuZhang,2FushengLi,3ZhilinZhu4andBaozhongZhang1
4
CenterforAgriculturalWaterResearchinChina,ChinaAgriculturalUniversity,Beijing,100083,China
2CSIROLandandWater,GPOBox1666,Canberra,ACT2601,Australia3AgriculturalCollege,GuangxiUniversity,Nanning,Guangxi,530005,China
InstituteofGeographicSciencesandNaturalResourceResearch,ChineseAcademyofSciences,Beijing,100101,China
1
Abstract:
Accuratemeasurementandestimationofcropevapotranspiration(ET)playsanimportantroleinunderstanding eldsoilwatercycleandmanagingwater-savingirrigationinthearidregions.ThisstudycomparesthreemethodsforestimatingET: eldWaterBalance(WB),EddyCovariance(EC)andBowenRatio-EnergyBalance(BREB).TheexperimentwasconductedinavineyardintheariddesertregionsofnorthwestChina.ResultsindicatethatthethreemethodsprovidedsimilarestimateoftotalET.ComparedtototalETmeasuredbyWB(ETWB)duringthewholegrowingstage,totalETestimatedbyEC(ETEC)was1Ð57%lower,andtotalETestimatedbyBREB(ETBREB)was5Ð19%higher.VariationsofETECandETBREBaresimilarathourlyordailytimescale,butthevaluesareslightlydifferent.Atsunriseorsunset,ETBREBincreasesordecreasesmorerapidlythanETEC.ThedifferencebetweenETBREBandETECislinearlyrelatedtotheresidualoftheenergybalanceforECandthetwomethodsyieldedcloseestimateswhentheresidualwassmall.ThisstudyshowedthatthethreemethodsprovidedaccurateestimatesofETatdailyandseasonaltimescalesandthemethodscanbeusedtoestimateETfromvineyardsinaridenvironments.Copyright 2008JohnWiley&Sons,Ltd.
KEYWORDS
aridregion;Bowenratio-energybalance;eddycovariance;evapotranspiration; eldwaterbalance;northwestChina;vineyard
Received1November2007;Accepted24March2008
INTRODUCTION
AshortageofwaterresourcesintheHexicorridorofnorthwestChinanotonlyresultsinenvironmentaldeteri-oration,butalsorestrictstheregionalsocialandeconomicdevelopment(Zhangetal.,2007).Longsunshinedura-tionandalargetemperaturedifferencebetweendayandnightintheHexicorridorregionissuitableforcashcropssuchasgrapevine.In2003,theplantingareaofthebrewagegrapevinewasabout6700hectares(hm2)occu-pyingabout12Ð5%ofnationalplantingareaofbrewagegrapevine(Liuetal.,2006),butwatershortageisthemostimportantlimitationofgrapevineindustrydevel-opmentinthisregion.Therearefewstudiesonwaterconsumptionofgrapevinecropintheregion,however.Therearevariousmethodsofestimating eldET,forexample,hydrologicalapproaches(suchas eldwaterbalanceandweighinglysimeter),micrometeorologicalmethods(e.g.eddycovariance,Bowenratio-energybal-anceandaerodynamicmethod)andplantphysiologyapproaches(e.g.chamberssystemandsap owmethod).Regardingthe rstapproach,the eldwaterbalance(WB)equationisabasicmethodofestimatingETby
*Correspondenceto:ShaozhongKang,CenterforAgriculturalWaterResearchinChina,ChinaAgriculturalUniversity,Beijing,100083,China.E-mail:kangshaozhong@tom.comdeterminingallothercomponentsofthewaterbalanceequation.ThismethodcangenerallybeusedtocalibrateotherETestimationmethodsbutitalsohasitsdisad-vantages.Forexample,canopyinterceptionisnotoftenconsideredintheequationandthedrainageorupwardwater uxisnoteasilydeterminedwithanyaccuracyintheactualapplicationoftheequation.However,forsituationswithwell-de nedsurfaceandlowerboundaryconditions,itisstillareliablemethodtocalculatelong-termcropET(Chen,1988;Zuo,1991;RanaandKaterji,2000).
Withrespecttomicrometeorologicalmethods,twoofthemostfrequentlyusedmethodsareEddyCovariance(EC)andBowenRatio-EnergyBalance(BREB).ECisgenerallyconsideredasastandardmethodtomeasurethesurface ux(Baldocchietal.,2001),whichcanbeusedforcomparingwiththeothermethodsormodels.Inspiteoffewtheoreticalhypotheses,itisadirectmeasuringmethodandcanmeasurewatervapour,heatandCO2 uxesatthesametime.Theresultsrepresentabroadrange,anditstimeintervalbetweentwomeasurementsisquiteshort.However,themethodislimitedbyterrainandmeteorologicalconditions(Lee,1998;Baldocchietal.,2000;Massmanetal.,2000;MassmanandLee,2002).Irregularterraincangenerateanadvectiveeffect,whichwillleadto uxloss.Inaddition,theweakeningofnight-timeturbulentintensitywillalsoleadtolowermeasured
Generally, the vineyard has three important features: (1) it usually has ...Direct and indirect methods to simulate the actual evapotranspiration of an ...
are the most important factors determining wine ?...Remorini D and Massai R 2003 Comparison of water...actual evapotranspiration in a rowcropped vineyard. ...
are the most important factors determining wine ?...Remorini D and Massai R 2003 Comparison of water...actual evapotranspiration in a rowcropped vineyard. ...
热门文档