The V-22 does not
provide any truly
revolutionary
operational mili-
tary capability.IntroductionThe V-22 Osprey is a tilt-rotor aircraft thattakes off and lands vertically like a helicopter
but flies like an airplane when its wing-
mounted rotors are tilted to become pro-
pellers. The V-22’s vertical takeoff and landing
(VTOL) capability allows it to operate without
traditional runways (it can operate from the
decks of amphibious ships). Its winged-air-
craft configuration gives it the speed and
range of a traditional turboprop airplane and
permits aerial refueling and self-deployment
(flying directly from its base to a theater of
operations rather than being partially disas-
sembled and transported via sealift or airlift)
anywhere in the world.
Supporters of the V-22 argue that it has the
operational flexibility of a helicopter but is
twice as fast, can carry more troops, and has
double the range. The V-22’s multimission
capabilities include troop and cargo transport,
amphibious assault, transport for special
operations, and search and rescue operations.
According to an issue brief by the Lexington
Institute, “It’s hard to imagine an aircraft bet-
ter suited to a period of uncertainty about the
future because no matter what kinds of
threats arise in the next century, the Osprey is
nearly certain to be useful everyday.”1
Critics contend that the Osprey is prohib-
itively expensive and unsafe (the V-22 pro-
gram has experienced four crashes, two of
which killed 23 Marines). The V-22 entered
full-scale development in 1986, and its esti-
mated per unit cost has more than tripled
from $24 million to $85 million since the
program started. Now—more than 15 years
later and having survived an attempt to ter-
minate it by then–secretary of defense
Richard Cheney in the first Bush administra-
tion—the program is still essentially in a test
phase with 40 preproduction V-22s built.
Although news reports have speculated
that the V-22 Osprey might be on the
Pentagon’s chopping block,2the director of
program analysis and evaluation, Stephen A.
Cambone, recently announced that the V-22would be allowed to proceed as a test program.Cambone says: “I think it would be fair to saythat there isn’t a desire to cut a major weaponssystem for the purposes of saving money. Thequestion is whether the weapons system atissue is going to support the kind of joint oper-ational capability that we are attempting toconstruct.”3Cutting the V-22 would savemoney (which could then be used on otherneeded weapon systems) and would not under-mine any important goal or reduce the mili-tary’s capabilities. The V-22 does not provideany truly revolutionary operational militarycapability necessary for defense moderniza-tion. Therefore, to reduce an already bloateddefense budget, the Pentagon should eliminatethe V-22 tilt-rotor program.The Tilt-Rotor Conceptand the V-22The idea of combining the vertical takeoffand landing capabilities of a helicopter withthe winged flight of an airplane dates back tothe mid-1940s. Wynn Laurence LePage (apioneer in rotary wing design) and HavilandH. Platt (a mechanical engineer with a num-ber of rotary wing patents) formed the Platt-LePage Aircraft Company in 1938. They pro-posed and patented the first tilt-rotor aircraftdesign in the United States. But Platt-LePagewas forced to shut down in 1947 because ofits small size, lack of capital, and lack oforders for military aircraft. Robert Lichten,an ex-Platt-LePage engineer, went to BellHelicopter where he developed the XV-3—under contract with the NationalAeronautical and Space Administration andthe Army. The XV-3 was remarkably similarto the Platt-LePage in design.4The XV-3 wasthe first successful demonstration of tilt-rotor feasibility and, from 1953 to 1966,made 250 test flights, including 110 full con-versions from helicopter mode to airplanemode and back.5Beginning in 1972, Bell Helicopter devel-oped the XV-15 tilt-rotor aircraft (againunder contract with NASA and the Army)
2
The LAMV uses one-fourth of the fuel per passenger mile used by the tilt-rotor V-22 Osprey or high performance helicopters. The LAMV's acquisition ...
The LAMV uses one-fourth of the fuel per passenger mile used by the tilt-rotor V-22 Osprey or high performance helicopters. The LAMV's acquisition ...
热门文档