Abstract. We provide a conceptual analysis of several kinds of deadlines, represented in Temporal Modal Defeasible Logic. The paper presents a typology of deadlines, based on the following parameters: deontic operator, maintenance or achievement, presence
CharacterisingDeadlines
inTemporalModalDefeasibleLogic
GuidoGovernatori1,JorisHulstijn2,R´egisRiveret3,AntoninoRotolo3
SchoolofITEE,TheUniversityofQueensland,Australia
guido@itee.uq.edu.au2VrijeUniversiteit,Amsterdam,TheNetherlands
jhulstijn@feweb.vu.nl3CIRSFID,UniversityofBologna,Italy
antonino.rotolo@unibo.it,regis.riveret@unibo.it1
Abstract.Weprovideaconceptualanalysisofseveralkindsofdeadlines,rep-resentedinTemporalModalDefeasibleLogic.Thepaperpresentsatypologyofdeadlines,basedonthefollowingparameters:deonticoperator,maintenanceorachievement,presenceorabsenceofsanctions,andpersistenceafterthedeadline.Thedeadlinetypesareillustratedbyasetofexamples.
1Introduction
Manynormativerulesinapplicationsofarti cialintelligenceareconcernedwithdead-lines.Billsmustbepaidbeforetheendofthemonth;booksneedtobereturnedbeforeaduedate;productsmustbedeliveredwithintenworkingdays.Ingeneralwecansaythatadeadlinecombinesaspeci cationofatimepointorconditionδ,withtheobligationtoachievesomestateofaffairs beforeconditionδarrives.
Becausedeadlinescombinetimeandobligations,theyarenaturallystudiedbyacombinationoftemporallogicwithdeonticlogic.Variouspapersuseacombinationofbranchingtimetemporallogic(CTL)withStandardDeonticLogic[5,4,3].Insuchlogics,themeaningofadeadlineclause,i.e.,that shouldoccurbeforeδ,canbeex-pressedasanobligationwhichinvolvesthe‘until’-operator:OBL( Uδ).Thismeansthatsituationsinwhichδbecomestruewhile hasnotbeenachieved,areconsideredtobeaviolationaccordingtosomenormativesystem.
However,suchacharacterisationofdeadlinesdoesnotindicatewhatwillhappenafterthedeadline.Isitrequiredtostillcomplete evenafterthedeadline,asforlatepayments?Orisitimpossibleorunnecessarytocomplete afterthedeadline,asforthelatedeliveryofaweddingcake?Isanexplicitsanctionenforcedafterthedeadline,oristhesanctionsimplythatachievingone’sgoalhasbecomeimpossible?
Sincedeadlinescanhavedifferentfunctions,itislikelythatseveralnotionsofdead-linecanbedistinguished.Inthispaperwethereforewanttoprovideaconceptualanal-ysisofvariouskindsofdeadlines,andtoprovideaformalcharacterisation.Suchacharacterisationshouldmakeiteasiertohaveintelligentsystemsreasonaboutsystemsofdeadlineclauses,to ndoutforexamplewhethertheyaremutuallyconsistent,orhowacourseofactioncanbeplannedthatmeetsalldeadlineclauses;comparethemotivationgivenby[5].
Modal Logic and Temporal... 暂无评价 2页 免费 An overview of temporal ... 暂无评价 35页 免费 Characterising Deadlines... 暂无评价 10页 免费 ...
temporal×modal logic (S... 10页 免费 Characterising Deadlines... 暂无评价 10页 免费 Multi-dimensional modal ... 暂无评价 24页 免费 MAT Logic A ...
1页 免费 temporal×modal logic (S... 10页 免费 Stratified negation in t... 暂无评价 13页 免费 Characterising Deadlines... 暂无评价 10页 免费...
1页 免费 temporal×modal logic (S... 10页 免费 Stratified negation in t... 暂无评价 13页 免费 Characterising Deadlines... 暂无评价 10页 免费...
1页 免费 temporal×modal logic (S... 10页 免费 Stratified negation in t... 暂无评价 13页 免费 Characterising Deadlines... 暂无评价 10页 免费...
热门文档