rent users have already developed a firm mental model of searching:
Search is such a prominent part of the Web user experi-ence that users have developed a firm mental model for how it’s supposed to work. Users expect search to have three components: ■
A box where they can type words
■ A button labeled “search” that they click to run the search
■ A list of top results that’s linear, prioritized, and appears on a new page—the search engine results
page (SERP)
In our experience, when users see a fat “Search” button,
they’re likely to frantically look for “the box where I type my words.” The mental model is so strong that the label “Search” equals keyword searching, not other types of search.12
to which an OPAC is set affects users’ success in retriev-Studies have also shown that the default search option ing information. Two studies on university OPAC search transactions confirmed that novice users preferred search-ing Singapore, by keyword. At Nanyang conducted to “identify query and search failure patterns a recent search transaction Technological log University, study was with the goal of identifying areas of improvement for the system.” Results indicated that “the most commonly used search option for the NTU OPAC is the keyword search. The use of keyword searches contributed to 68.9 percent of all queries while other options such as title, author, and subject percent of all searches respectively.”accounted for 16.5 percent, 138.2 percent, and 6.4 quarter At California State University–Los
Angeles, a four-revealed (2002–2003) an similar results. search After transaction log analysis also more user-centered, behind-the-scenes search algorithms “advanced keyword search” the feature library that implemented provided and that set keyword search as the default, the keyword search queries rose dramatically.14to Many university library OPACs
have already begun Among adopt “keyword(s) the features 123 ARL employed library by Internet search engines. appendix A). This is a positive sign that libraries are pay-anywhere” as the OPACs default studied, search key 81 have (see ing attention to user search behavior. Thirty-six libraries’ default search keys are still set to “title,” and six libraries, instead choices of providing a default search option, their search terms.
from which users must choose before list entering field potential problems. In order to retrieve good results from The title search used as the default option holds some a title search, users are expected to type in a title in the right article (a, an, the), if any. While librarians are fluent with
order, spelled correctly, and omitting the initial these stantly have trouble remembering them. Providing online seemingly simple rules, students and faculty con-search tips and offering information literacy classes only help default has proved effective, libraries using title search as a little. Since presenting keyword search as the their sider switching their default setting to keyword.
OPAC default search option might want to recon-search ability—true keyword search
The basis of current OPAC search systems is Boolean logic. The ease of using Google-like search engines comes from its to search terms. This is logical because users usually look for enter implicit Boolean “AND” connectors feature, which (AND, eliminates OR, NOT) the between need records that contain all the terms that they enter.
OPACs Sixty-six These libraries handle Boolean logic in keyword search-with percent keyword of set the as ARL the libraries default search studied option. have ing very differently. All five ILS vendors offer “automatic AND” adopted functionality, but not all of these libraries have Boolean it: Library’s OPAC automatically executes “same” for mul-operators in some during cases, a users search. are Emory required University to enter tiple which means that it will find records with the search terms search words if no Boolean operators are entered in OPAC automatically uses the Boolean operator “OR” for the same bibliographic fields. Syracuse University’s all keyword queries. This practice can generate too many irrelevant the Boolean operator “AND” for multiple terms entered results. Libraries that automatically supply in results. In addition, none of the ARL OPACs studied han-the search box consequently produce more relevant dle auto-word-truncation, auto-correction for typos, spell-check, ters. This makes searching unnecessarily inconvenient.
punctuations, or special auto-plurals, charac-erly For many years now, teaching students how to prop-tial these topics use Boolean in information operators literacy has been classes. one of the essen-searching? classes, by A do study students of 2,374 use transaction Boolean operators After taking when versity 836 French universities revealed that logs collected Fifty-six students use Boolean operators infrequently. French uni-Approximately percent Boolean 28 of percent the queries of the used queries only contained a single term. information search expertise on the use of Boolean opera-operator. To further investigate the impact one of tors, the study showed that approximately one-third (32 percent) of the students (considered the “novice” group in when they were explicitly invited to do so, compared to the study) still did not use Boolean operators even 83 in the study), who used at least one Boolean operator for percent of librarians (considered the “expert” group their and syntax are mostly used by expert users. Novice users
queries.15 Therefore, complicated search strategies REvitaLizinG tHE LiBRaRY opaC aRtiCLE titLE | mi anD WEnG | autHoR 7
热门文档