The thorny problem of usability has been recognized in the security community for many years, but has, so far, eluded systematic solution. We characterize the problem as a gap between theoretical and effective levels of security, and consider the character
An Approach to Usable Security Based on Event
Monitoring and Visualization
Paul Dourish and David Redmiles
Information and Computer ScienceUniversity of California, IrvineIrvine, CA 92697-3425
USA
{jpd,redmiles}@ics.uci.edu
ABSTRACT
The thorny problem of usability has been recognized in thesecurity community for many years, but has, so far, eludedsystematic solution. We characterize the problem as a gapbetween theoretical and effective levels of security, andconsider the characteristics of the problem. The approach weare taking focuses on visibility – how can we make relevantfeatures of the security context apparent to users, in order toallow them to make informed decisions about their actions andthe potential implications of those actions?
Keywords: Usability, mental models, visualization, eventmonitoring.
1. INTRODUCTION
Networked computer systems are increasingly the site ofpeople’s work and activity. So, for example, millions ofordinary citizens conduct commercial transactions over theInternet, or manage their finances and pay their bills online;companies increasingly use the Internet to connect differentoffices, or form virtual teams to tackle mission-criticalproblems through entirely “virtual” interaction; and we seeincreasing discussion of online voting systems for politicalelections.
However, these new opportunities have costs associated withthem. Commercial, political and financial transactions involvedisclosing sensitive information. The media regularly carrystories about hackers breaking into commercial servers, creditcard fraud and identity theft. Many people are nervous aboutcommitting personal information to electronic informationinfrastructures. Even though modern PCs are fast enough tooffer strong cryptographic guarantees and high levels ofsecurity, these concerns remain.
Participation in activities such as electronic commercerequires that people be able to trust the infrastructures thatwill deliver these services to them. This is not quite the sameas saying that we need more secure infrastructures. We believethat it is important to separate theoretical security (the levelof secure communication and computation that is technically
feasible) from effective security (the level of security that canpractically be achieved in everyday settings). Levels ofeffective security are almost always lower than those oftheoretical security. There are many reasons for this disparity,including poor implementations of key security algorithms(Kelsey et al., 1998), insecure programming techniques(Wagner et al., 2000; Shankar et al., 2001), insecure protocoldesign (Kemmerer et al., 1994; Schneier and Mudge, 1998),and inadequate operating systems support (Ames et al., 1983;Bernaschi et al., 2000). One important cause of the disparity,though, is the extent to which users can comprehend and makeeffective use of security mechanisms.
2. CURRENT PROBLEMS
Although much effort has been devoted to the development ofalgorithms and technologies for secure communication andcomputation, much less time has been spent investigating howto integrate these techniques into real-world use in meaningfulways. In fact, it often seems that security and usability tradeoff against each other – the complexity and overhead oftraditional security mechanisms are barriers to their effectivedeployment. A few simple examples from our own experiencewill illustrate:
A needed research a security group solution. designing A a highly system qualified for mobile academiccodesecurity expert designed and implemented an elegantscheme based on SPKI/SDSI in which the system serverswould determine transaction rights based oncryptographically secure certificates exchanged over anSSL RPC infrastructure. However, in actual use, thisresulted in a performance reduction of 5-10X. As a result,in day-to-day use, everyone simply turned it off,rendering the system less secure than it had been in thefirst place. A terminal access through a firewall host. Researchers research laboratory used S/Key one-time pads to wouldallowperiodically use private passwords and local clientprograms to generate themselves new one-time passwordpads. However, the system was soon discontinued when itbecame clear that people could not tell whether theirconnections were secure enough to make it safe togenerate the new pads. Norton’s incoming Anti-Virus email for viruses software before offers you an option download to checkit toyour computer. The actual mechanism for doing this isnot directly disclosed. When this option is turned on, theuser’s login and password are sent to a Norton server,which downloads the user’s email and reads it, checking
A Risk-Based Approach to Monitoring Elemental Impurities in Leachable Studies_机械/仪表_工程科技_专业资料。PEER-REVIEWED A Risk-Based Approach to Monitoring ...
暂无评价 6页 免费 A Visualization Service ... 暂无评价 20页 免费喜欢此文档...Based on “An Event-Based Network-on-Chip Monitoring Service” by Calin ...
based 3D visualization is a unique opportunity to...public security and medical data that stored in ...By a service-oriented approach, the monitoring ...
We have designed a new monitoring platform and visualization tool adapted for...a complete monitoring system based on an hierarchical object-oriented approach...
An event service framewo... 暂无评价 8页 免费 Agent Based Approach to ....their visualization, and estimation and effecting of deployment architectures for...
An Architecture for Loca... 暂无评价 6页 免费 A Visualization Service .....An Event-based Monitoring Service for Networks on Chip CALIN CIORDAS and TWAN...
c retrieval and visualization of multimedia data. ...Event detection from surveillance and monitoring is...An approach for event detection in live sports, ...
approach for monitoring and visualization of ...architecture, to a textual, rule based selection....event and time oriented instrumentation techniques. ...
An Architecture for Monitoring, Visualization and Control of Gigabit Networks ...We propose using a highly exible, scalable and high performance event- ...
The approach combines qualitative analysis, monitoring and testing as well as quantitative analysis on the basis of a net-based intermediate representation of...
热门文档