Modified thermal cycling conditions were explored in an effort to improve the reproducibility and resolving power of repetitive-element PCR (rep-PCR) fingerprinting. Assay performance was rigorously evaluated under standard and modified cycling conditions,
CLINICALANDDIAGNOSTICLABORATORYIMMUNOLOGY,Mar.2000,p.258–2641071-412X/00/$04.00 0
Vol.7,No.2
ImprovedRepetitive-ElementPCRFingerprintingofSalmonellaenterica
withtheUseofExtremelyElevatedAnnealingTemperatures
JAMESR.JOHNSON*
AND
CONNIECLABOTS
VAMedicalCenterandDepartmentofMedicine,UniversityofMinnesota,Minneapolis,Minnesota
Received12July1999/Returnedformodi cation5November1999/Accepted24November1999
Modi edthermalcyclingconditionswereexploredinanefforttoimprovethereproducibilityandresolvingpowerofrepetitive-elementPCR(rep-PCR) ngerprinting.Assayperformancewasrigorouslyevaluatedunderstandardandmodi edcyclingconditions,usingasatestset12strainsputativelyrepresenting12serovarsofSalmonellaenterica.Forallthree ngerprinttypes(ERIC2,BOXA1R,andcomposite ngerprints),theuseofextremelyelevatedannealingtemperaturesplusaninitial“touchdown”cyclingroutineyieldedsigni cantimprovementsinday-to-dayreproducibilityanddiscriminatingpowerdespitethesomewhatsparserappear-anceofthe ngerprints.Modi edcyclingconditionsmarkedlyreducedthevariabilityof ngerprintsbetweencyclers,allowing ngerprintsfromdifferentcyclerstobeanalyzedtogetherwithoutthedegradationofassayperformancethatoccurredwithbetween-cycleranalysesunderstandardcyclingconditions.Withmodi edcycling,composite ngerprintsexhibitedthelowestreproducibilitybutthehighestnetdiscriminatingpowerofthethree ngerprinttypes.rep-PCR ngerprintsledtothediscoveryofaserotypingerrorinvolvingoneofthe12teststrains.Thesedatademonstratethatmodi edcyclingregimensthatincorporateelevatedannealingtemperatures(withorwithoutaninitialtouchdownroutine)maymarkedlyimprovetheperformanceofrep-PCR ngerprintingasabacterialtypingtool.
Bacterialstraintypingatthesubspeci clevelisanessentialtoolforcontemporarypublichealthandhospitalinfectioncontrolefforts(8,18,27,33),aswellasforbasicresearchin-volvingthemolecularepidemiologyandevolutionarybiologyofpathogenicbacteria(2,6,10,21–24).Traditionalsubspeci ctypingmethodsincludeserotyping,phagetyping,biotyping,plasmidpro ling,multilocusenzymeelectrophoresis,conven-tionalrestrictionendonucleaseanalysis,ribotyping,andpulsed- eldgelelectrophoresis(PFGE).Theirstrengthsnotwith-standing,allofthesemethodshaveoneormoresigni cantdrawbacks,includingbeingsloworcumbersome;requiringhighlyspecializedequipment,skills,and/orreagents;relyingonvariableorunstabletraits;andyieldinguninterpretableresultsforsomestrains(8,18,23,33).
PCR-based ngerprintingisasimple,rapid,andbroadlyapplicabletypingmethodthatispotentiallyavailabletoanylaboratorywithPCRcapability.Fingerprintsaregeneratedusingeitherarbitraryprimers(randomampli edpolymorphicDNA[35],arbitrarilyprimedPCR[34],orDNAampli cation ngerprinting[5])orrepetitive-element-basedprimers(rep-PCR)(32).PCR ngerprintinghasbeenreportedtobeusefulinavarietyofinfectioncontrolandmolecularepidemiologicalapplicationsinvolvingdiversebacterialtypes(11–13,25,27,29,31,36).However,concernshavebeenraisedregardingtheir-reproducibilityofPCR-generated ngerprints(1,20,27;E.M.Jutras,P.Rochelle,R.deLeon,M.Stewart,andR.Wolfe,Abstr.98thGen.Meet.Am.Soc.Microbiol.,abstr.Q-109,p.439,1998).ClaimsofreproducibilityfromproponentsofPCR ngerprintinggenerallyhavenotbeensupportedwithspeci cdata.Onthecontrary,reportsofmanipulationswhichosten-siblyimprovethereproducibilityofPCR ngerprinting(7,9,
13,32;G.Lisby,D.L.Baggesen,andU.Skibsted,Abstr.98thGen.Meet.Am.Soc.Microbiol.,abstr.L-6,p.354,1998)sug-gestthatirreproducibilityisagreaterproblemwiththismeth-odthanisgenerallyacknowledged.
Althoughourpreliminaryexperiencewithrep-PCRtypingofE.coli(14–16)andSalmonellaenterica(J.R.Johnson,un-publisheddata)con rmedthemethod’sspeedandsimplicity,wealsofoundthatwiththepublishedcyclingconditions(32)theassay’sreproducibilityandstraindiscriminationonaday-to-daybasiswereinadequate,evenwiththeuseofkit-puri edgenomicDNAinsteadofboiledlysatesandcommercialPCRbeadsinsteadofhand-compoundedmastermixes(M.Saluta,W.-T.E.Ting,M.Koonge,andC.Tseng,Abstr.98thGen.Meet.Am.Soc.Microbiol.,abstr.H-124,p.297,1998).
ThecomparativelyhighGCcontentoftheERICandBOXA1Rprimersusedinrep-PCR(32)suggestedtousthatattherecommendedannealingtemperature(52°C)theseprimersmightbindtoandinitiateDNAsynthesisfrompartiallymis-matchedrecognitionsites.Suchmismatchedannealingwouldbeexpectedtobeunstableandhighlytemperaturedependentandhencesensitivetosmalltemperatureshiftsasmightoccurfromruntorunorfromdaytodayonagiventhermalcyclerorbetweencyclers.Wehypothesizedthattheuseofhigherannealingtemperatureswouldyieldmorespeci c(andhencemoretemperature-stable)priming,resultingingreaterday-to-dayandcycler-to-cyclerreproducibilityof ngerprints.(Thisissimilartotheprincipleunderlying“touchdown”[TD]cycling,inwhichtoincreasethespeci cityofprimerbindinginearlycycles,annealingtemperaturesareinitiallysethigherthantheultimateannealingtemperatureandthenaredecreasedinastepwisefashionwitheachcycleuntiltheultimateannealingtemperatureisreached[7,9].)Inthepresentstudywesoughttorigorouslyandquantitativelyevaluatetheimpactofex-tremelyelevatedannealingtemperaturesonthereproducibil-ityanddiscriminatingpowerofrep-PCR ngerprints,usingasthetestsubstratestrainsrepresentingdifferentserovarsofS.enterica.
258
Downloaded from cvi.asm.org at Penn State Univ on April 11, 2008
*Correspondingauthor.Mailingaddress:InfectiousDiseases(111F),VAMedicalCenter,OneVeteransDr.,Minneapolis,MN55417.Phone:(612)725-2000,ext.4185.Fax:(612)725-2273.E-mail:johns007@.tc.umn.edu.
Repetitive element-based polymerase chain reaction (rep-PCR) generates DNA ... and has been used for fingerprinting soil bacteria and plant-pathogenic ...
热门文档