8
Table2
ServaesandTamayo:TheImpactofCorporateSocialResponsibilityonFirmValue
ManagementScience,ArticlesinAdvance,pp.1–17,©2013INFORMS
PanelRegressionsofTobin’sqasaFunctionofCSRInvolvement,andtheCSR–AdvertisingInteraction
CSRmeasure
(i)Conservative
(ii)
Includeindustryconcerns4 15 0 226 003 750 396 65
(0.00) (0.00) (0.00) (0.00) (0.00) (0.02)
(iii)
Includeindustryandproduct4 02 0 216 593 810 314 25
(0.00) (0.00) (0.00) (0.00) (0.00) (0.08)
(iv)Conservative6 38 0 50 1 25 0 64 0 077 70
(0.00) (0.00) (0.46)(0.34)(0.23)(0.00)
(v)
Includeindustryconcerns6 38 0 50 1 15 0 62 0 087 42
(0.00) (0.00) (0.49)(0.24)(0.24)(0.01)
(vi)
Includeindustryandproduct6 37 0 50 0 82 0 63 0 014 94
(0.00) (0.00) (0.59)(0.17)(0.78)(0.00)
Copyright:INFORMSholdscopyrighttothisArticlesinAdvanceversion,whichismadeavailabletosubscribers.The lemaynotbepostedonanyotherwebsite,includingtheauthor’ssite.Pleasesendanyquestionsregardingthispolicytopermissions@informs.org.
InterceptLogassets
AdvertisingintensityR&DintensityCSR
CSR AdvertisingintensityYeardummiesFirm xedeffectsAdjustedR2N
4 17 0 235 833 760 416 19(0.00) (0.00) (0.00) (0.00) (0.00) (0.05)
YesNo0.1910,712YesNo0.1910,712YesNo0.1910,712YesYes0.7410,712YesYes0.7410,712YesYes0.7310,712
Notes.ThemodelisestimatedusingOLS.Thestandarderrorshavebeenadjustedforheteroscedasticityandforthelackofindependenceofobservationsforthesame rm(clusteredstandarderrors).TheconservativemeasureofCSRincludesthefollowing veKLDcategories:community,diversity,employees,environment,andhumanrights.Thep-valuesarereportedinparentheses.
,,and indicatesigni canceofthecoef cientatthe1%,5%,and10%levels,respectively.
WeemploythreemeasuresofCSR:theconservativemeasure,whichincludes veKLDcategories(com-munity,diversity,employees,environment,humanrights);anexpandedmeasure,whichalsoincludesindustryconcerns;andthebroadestmeasure,whichincludesindustryconcernsandtheproductcate-gory.Foreachmeasure,wereporttwospeci cations:the rstspeci cationisestimatedwithout rm xedeffects,asinmostofthepriorliteratureonCSR;thesecondspeci cationisestimatedwiththeinclusionof rm xedeffects,whichcontrolfortime-invariantunobservable rmcharacteristicsthatmaydrivebothvaluationandCSRinvolvement.Theomissionofsuchcontrolsmayresultinspurious ndingsandmayexplainwhyregressionmodelswithdifferentsetsofexplanatoryvariableshaveyieldedcontradictoryresultsinpriorwork.
OurresultsarereportedinTable2.Tworesultsstandout.First,inthemodelsestimatedwithout rm xedeffects(models(i)–(iii)),we ndapositiverela-tionbetweentheCSRmeasureand rmvalue.This ndingholdsforallmeasuresofCSRandappearstosuggestthatCSRitselfisvaluecreating.However,inmodelsestimatedwith rm xedeffects(mod-els(iv)–(vi)),evidenceofadirectrelationbetweenCSRandvaluedisappears,suggestingthatthis nd-ingisspuriousandthatcontrollingforunobservable rmcharacteristicsisimportantinthesespeci ca-tions.Infact,thecoef cientonCSRisnegativeinallspeci cations,althoughnotstatisticallysigni cant.Second,theinteractionbetweenadvertisingintensityandtheCSRmeasureissigni cantlypositive.Thus, rmsbene tfromCSRiftheyadvertise.Comparingthecoef cientsontheCSRmeasureandtheinter-actionindicatesthatthejointeffectbecomesposi-tivefor rmswithadvertisingtosalesabove0.91%(basedonmodel(iv)),acriterionmetby28%ofthe
sample rms.11TheeffectofadvertisingintensityontheCSR–valuerelationisalsoeconomicallysignif-icant.Forexample,basedonmodel(iv),for rmswithzeroadvertising(themedianofthedistribution),increasingtheCSRmeasurebyonestandarddevia-tion(0.38)leadstoadecreaseinTobin’sqof0.03.For rmswithadvertisingexpenditurestosalesof3.07%(onestandarddeviationabovethemedian),thesameincreaseintheCSRmeasureleadstoanincreaseinTobins’sqof0.06.Theoveralleffectimpliesadiffer-enceinTobins’sqof0.09,whichissubstantialgiventhemeanTobins’sqratioof2.10.12
Oneconcernwithmodelsthatinclude rm xedeffectsisthattheymaylackpowertodetectarela-tion.Ifmostofthevariabilityintheexplanatoryvari-ablesiscross-sectional,andthereislittletime-seriesvariation,theinclusionof rm xedeffectsessentiallyremovesalltheinterestingvariationthatneedstobeexplained.Thus,ifcompanyCSRactivitiesvarylit-tleovertime,itmaynotbesurprisingthata rm xedeffectsmodelshowsnorelationbetweenCSRinvolvementandvalue.Toaddressthisconcern,we rstcomputehowmuchtime-seriesvariationthereisinCSRinvolvementfortheaverage rm.Thatis,foreach rm,wecomputethestandarddeviationoftheirCSRinvolvementovertime,andwethenaveragethismeasureacross rms.Theaverageofthesestandarddeviationsis0.15andthemedianis0.14.Thissug-geststhatthereissubstantialtime-seriesvariability
11
Thecoef cientontheCSRscoreis 0 07,andthecoef cientontheinteractionbetweentheCSRscoreandadvertisingintensityis7.70.Thebreak-evenvalueofadvertisingintensityisthereforecomputedas0 07/7 70=0 91%.
12
Becauseweemploya rm xedeffectsmodel,therelativemag-nitudeforeach rmdependsonthe rm-speci cmeanTobin’sq,whichrangesfrom0.81to8.79.
of corporate social responsibility (CSR) on ... this negative impact, harms firm market value. ... Expanding the Role of Relationship Marketing,” ...
商务英语小组讨论:Corporate social responsibility_...impact on the environment of the emerging ... can the corporate truly value safety and ...
The role of purchasing in the value chain firm infrastructure Support ...Corporate Social Responsibility and business integrity Conclusions In short, ...
Corporate social responsibility_金融/投资_经管营销...impact on the environment andstakeholders including ... or an attempt to pre-empt the role of ...
外文原文【Corporate Social Responsibility And ...It shows the relation and the impact of the ...role as a partial mediator in the CSR-firm ...
As people are more and more concern for corporate social responsibility of business, the CSR behavior of family business will impact the family business' ...
Darren Filson Claremont Graduate University The Impact of E-Commerce Strategies on Firm Value: Lessons from Amazon.com and Its Early Competitors* I. ...
Impact of Corporate Social Responsibility on Bank Performance in Nigeria_专业资料。JunlfUSChn ul miirtnIS14.5 ora —iaPbiAdnsai,SN 869 oc...
Corporate social responsibility and cause-related ...‘The impact of prior firm financial performance ...Consumers are demanding more value for their money...
firm’s long-run value-creating potential (... by focusing on the role of capital markets, ...The impact of corporate social responsibility on ...
热门文档