“Give to the emperor the things that are the emperor’s, and to God the things that are God’s.”
To whom shall we give what? To whom shall we give how much? Those questions are on our hearts and minds these days, as we are asked to pray about our
pledges to God for the work of God’s church. How much of what we have will we give, and to whom will we give it? These were deeply vexing questions too for the people who wrote the Gospels, and the people for whom the Gospels were written. Their questions were particularly framed by the requirements of imperial taxation imposed by an
occupying authority – the Roman Empire. But, for them too the questions had deeper implications related to what they believed about God and how they believed they should live their lives. As we pray about our pledges we also realize that our responses reveal much about what we believe and how we should live our lives.
The story in today’s Gospel is yet another in which Jesus is potentially trapped no matter which way he answers. And, as is the style in other stories like this in the Gospel, Jesus takes neither side, but responds in a third and different way. The Pharisees, who put the question to Jesus about whether it was lawful to pay taxes to the emperor, stood decidedly on one side of this issue in the first century. The Pharisees were opposed to paying taxes to the emperor, though usually they had no choice but to do so under duress. They considered the obligations of Jewish law to be higher than the requirements of
imperial law. Another group of Jews in first century Palestine, however, took a different approach. The Herodians were loyal to King Herod, the half-Jewish ruler of Palestine appointed by the emperor. Herod and his underlings, of course, were in collusion with the emperor; they saw cooperation with Roman authority as preferable to resistance, even if it meant compromising religious law or values. Herodians and Pharisees both were opposed to Jesus, and neither paid much attention to the desperate lives of most of their Palestinian sisters and brothers, who lived in terrible poverty under constant oppression. The question in this Gospel passage comes up in the context of the dispute between the Pharisees and the Herodians over their question: “Is it lawful to pay taxes to the emperor, or not?”
The Gospel writers, however, tell this story for a bigger reason than simply to report about the dispute between the Pharisees and the Herodians concerning taxation. Remember that the Gospels are not history books, even though their accounts are set in historical contexts and many of their subjects were actual historical figures. The crux of the question, for the sake of what the Gospel writers were getting at, and the message they wanted their congregations to understand, had to do with the word “lawful:” “Is it lawful to pay taxes to the emperor, or not?” The fundamental issue, the Gospel writers are saying, is not whether it is lawful to pay the emperor, but that all the bounty of this world in fact is God’s. What Jesus’ response really points to is the difference between the emperor’s law and God’s new order of the kingdom. What the Gospel writers point to by Jesus’ reply to the Pharisees, “Give to the emperor the things that are the emperor’s, and to God the things that are God’s,” is Jesus’ fundamental restatement of Jewish law that is at the heart of the Gospel, and that speaks to the whole foundational question of the relation of Jesus’ ministry to all that came before in ancient Judaism – all that was
18. What will the boy give a talk about? 1 ...You should your things. A. put on B. put ...Just at that time, the emperor became very weak...
18. What will the boy give a talk about? A....You should your things. A. put on B. put ...Just at that time, the emperor became very weak...
the emperor's new clothes_英语学习_外语学习_教育专区。2014新目标英语八...The emperor had to ___ give them silk and gold, but they ___ kept everyt...
When ladybugs are in danger, they will give ...Just at that time,the emperor became very weak....【2013 广西南宁】A There are many things we ...
their homes and traveled to the Emperor's city....The Chamberlain felt that it was his duty to ..."Oh, I love new things, Show the two weavers...
to the Emperor's city and applied to meet the...(在镜子前试衣服) Oh, I love new things, Show...观众:It’s said that only the truly clever and...
18. What will the boy give a talk about? A....You should your things. A. put on B. put ...Just at that time, the emperor became very weak...
(Give therefore to the emperor the things that are the emperor’s,and to God the things that are God’s.) 2、大陆法系一般不存在判例法,成文法是它...
When ladybugs are in danger, they will give ...Just at that time , the emperor became very ...第五篇【2013 广西南宁】 There are many things ...
元旦英语话剧The Emperor's New Clothes_英语学习_外语学习_教育专区。优佳...to be an Emperor? That would be the worst thing that could happen--Oh!...
热门文档