Distributed object architectures and Java are important for building modern, scalable, web-enabled applications. This paper is focused on qualitative and quantitative analysis of two distributed object models for use with Java: CORBA and RMI. We compare bo
Qualitative and QuantitativeAnalysis of CORBA and RMI
Matjaz B. Juric, Ivan Rozman
Institute of Informatics, Faculty of Electrical Engineering,Computer and Information Science, University of Maribor
Smetanova 17, SI-2000 Maribor, Slovenia, Europe
Telephone: +386 62 2207422, 2207410, fax: +386 62 211178
E-mail: , Abstract
Distributed object architectures and Java are important for building modern, scalable, web-enabled applications. This paperis focused on qualitative and quantitative analysis of two distributed object models for use with Java: CORBA and RMI. Wecompare both models in terms of features, maturity, legacy system support and ease of development. Focus is given toperformances. We present performance results based on real world scenarios that include single client and multi-clientconfigurations and different data types and sizes. We evaluate multithreading strategies and analyse code in order to identifythe most time consuming methods. We compare the results and give hints and conclusions. We have found that because of itscomplexity CORBA is slightly slower than RMI in simple scenarios. On the other hand CORBA handles multiple simultaneousclients and larger data amounts better and suffers from far lower performance degradation under heavy client load. Thearticle presents a solid basis for making a decision about the underlying distributed object model.Keywords: Java, CORBA, RMI, performance analysis
1. Introduction
Exponential network growth, global connectivity and new application domains have reached the limits of traditional objectoriented programming environments. The most critical aspects not supported by them are connectivity and interoperability.These two aspects are crucial for building a new generation of distributed information systems. Distributed systems requirecommunication between computing entities.
The most promising language for building distributed portable applications is Java. Java offers basic low-level communicationmechanisms with its support for sockets. For the new generation of information systems high level development approachesare needed. The alternative is a concept, known from procedural languages as remote procedure call (RPC). Pairing of RPCconcepts and object paradigm results in a distributed object model. For Java there are two suitable distributed object models,Common Object Request Broker Architecture (CORBA) and Remote Method Invocation (RMI). Both CORBA and RMI hidethe communications details of remote method invocations thus their basic functionality is similar.
For a software developer, several aspects are important [1] in order to make the right choice concerning which distributedobject model to use. These include features, performances and scalability, maturity, support for legacy systems and ease ofdevelopment. Traditionally one of the most important criteria are performances and scalability. As far as we know there are noin-depth analyses of distributed object models and Java language. In this paper a detailed analysis of CORBA/Java and JavaRMI can be found. Focus is given to performance evaluation. Several testing scenarios are defined so that the results between
关键词 :CORBA ; RMI ; 分布式对象模型 ; 响应时间 Key words :CORBA ; RMI ;dist ributed object model ;response time 中图分类号 : TP312 文献标识码 :...
RMI与CORBA在Java中的应用RMI与CORBA在Java中的应用隐藏>> RMI 与 CORBA 在 Java 中的应用来源:开放系统世界 2002-10-2 11:47:00 本篇用实例来说明采用 ...
methods, which allow designers to perform qualitative and quantitative analysis...“Performance of CORBA-Based Client-Server Architectures”, IEEE Transactions ...
Java 2 Remote Method Invocation Performance Analysis, Comparison and ...Keywords: Java, RMI, IIOP, CORBA, performance 1. Introduction Java has ...
reasonable qualitative and quantitative performance analysis of interoperability ...RMI CORBA HTTP SOAP 的数据较小时,CORBA/IIOP 和 JAVA RMI 占用的带宽要小 ...
detailed analysis of CORBA and RMI can be found...We have done a qualitative analysis by comparing ...have also done an in depth quantitative analysis....
SunRPC Network File System (NFS) Network Information System (NIS) CORBA Java RMI Microsoft COM } Object Request Brokers 2 The SANS Institute and FBI ...
Traditional distributed object computing (DOC) middleware such as CORBA, DCOM, and Java RMI support request/response semantics for distributed applications. ...
Java Remote Method Invocation (RMI) Introduction ? ? Java远程方法调用是一种...CORBA ? ? Developed by OMG Access to non-Java objects (as well as Java...
Method call latency is a major problem in approaches based on object-oriented middleware such as CORBA, DCOM, and RMI, especially for fine-grained ...
热门文档