About Guanxi
ATTITUDESTOCHINESEMIGRANTWORKERS
477
China’smigrantsalsofacechallengesinrelationtoattitudesofindigenousurban-dwellers.Evidencesuggeststhaturbanresi-dentsaresuspiciousofthe oatingpopulationandthattheyholdruralmigrantsresponsiblefortheirrecedingprivilegedstatus(Roberts,2002b).ChaiandChai(1997)notedthatthereisoftenoutrighthostilitytowardsmigrantsandthatthisperceptionseemstohavetranslatedintothedevelopmentofbroadnegativeattitudestowardsmigrants.Indeed,Solinger(1999)notedthat,inasurveycon-ductedinthemid1990s,74percentofShanghaineseblamedmigrantworkersforatleastthreeofthefollowingfoururbanproblems:crime,transportproblems,unem-ploymentandenvironmentaldegradation.Suchevidencewell-illustratesthetrans-formationofurbanChinaintoanhierarchicalsociety,withwell-de nedandsociallydiffer-entiated‘us’versus‘them’groups.WithinTurner’sself-categorisationtheory(Turneretal.,1987),suchdiscreteandhierarchicallyarrangedsocialgroupsaretermed‘in-groups’and‘out-groups’;2anin-groupbeingamoresuperior,orsociallypowerfulgroup,andanout-groupbeingasociallyinferior,orlesspowerful,group.3InurbanChina,thehierarchicalarrangementofurbanindigenousandmigrantgroupsprovidesagoodexamplerespectivelyofin-andout-groupsthatweargueareborneinpartoftheresidentialregis-tration(hukou)system’sclearsocialpowerdifferentialfavouringurbanitesoverruralmigrants.4
Oneofsocialpsychology’smorereliablephenomenaisthepropensityofgroupmemberstofavourtheirownoverother-groupmembers.Thisisreferredtoasin-groupfavouritism(Schaller,1992).InastudyconductedbyMalloyetal.(2004)amongChinesein-groupandout-groupsamples,therewasgreaterconsensusintraitjudgmentswithinthein-andout-groupsthantherewasbetweenthein-andout-groups,indicatingthatthephenomenonofin-groupfavouritism,whileoriginallyelucidatedinaWesternenvironment,extendstoChineseculture.Indeed,itisperhapsnotentirelysurprisingtoobserveastrongin-group–out-groupdivideinChinasinceithaslongbeenobservedthat,inrelationtotheWest,theChinesehaveastrongtendencytocategorisepeople(Parsons,1949).Indeed,TsuiandFarh(1997,p.60)statedthat“attentiontoothersinChinaishighlyselectiveandismostcharacteristicofrelationshipswithin-groupmembers”.
Apartfromtheirstructuraloriginswithinthehukousystem,anotherexplanationfortheemergenceofhighlydiscretein-andout-groupsinurbanChinamaybe,asRoberts(1997,p.268)observed,thefactthat“nativeplaceidentity(tongxiang)isacriticalcom-ponentofpersonalidentityinChina”.RobertsarguedthattheconceptofethnicityinChinahaslongbeende nedintermsofbirthplace—adifferentiatingtendencyreinforcedbythefactthatChineseMarxismencouragedurbanitestoseethemselvesasthe‘leadingclass’,thatis,asaveritable‘aris-tocracyoflabour’from1949.
Inpartduetoin-groupfavouritism,volun-taryintergroupsocialcontactbetweenin-groupsandout-groupstendstobelimited.Prejudicetowardssame-group,andagainstother-group,membersservesonlytodeepenin-group–out-groupdividesbecause,asPlous(2003,p.3)observed,“wherepreju-diceslurk,stereotypesareseldomfarbehind”.StereotypesarefrequentlynegativeandthisobservationseemspiercinglyvalidinthecontextofurbanChinawhere,asChengandSelden(1994)pointedout,thetermmangliu,whichisusedtodescribethe oatingpopulation,isaplayonthewordliumang,whichmeansvagrantorhooligan.Onefactorthathasbeenusedtoexplainhownegativestereotypescanbechangedisintergroupcontact.Allport’s(1954)contacthypothesis,elucidatedinhisseminalworkTheNatureofPrejudice,suggeststhat‘plea-santandco-operativecontact’—termsinfactcoinedsomedecadeslaterbyHewstoneandBrown(1986)referringtocontactsuchasthatenjoyedbyfriends,orfriendswhoarealsocolleaguesworkingtowardsmutualgoals—withmembersofanegativelystereo-typedout-groupcanamelioratenegativeatti-tudestowardsthosespeci cout-groupmemberswithwhomthepersonhascontact.
Effects of Intergroup ... 17页 免费 THE DEVELOPMENT...CHINESEGEOGRAPHlCALSCIENCEVolume14,Number2,pp.170一...investigationintolocalresidents’attitudesoftouris...
Effects of Intergroup ... 17页 免费 THE DEVELOPMENT...CHINESEGEOGRAPHlCALSCIENCEVolume14,Number2,pp.170一...investigationintolocalresidents’attitudesoftouris...
热门文档