文档下载 文档下载导航
设为首页 | 加入收藏
搜索 请输入内容:  
 导航当前位置: 文档下载 > 所有分类 > 农林牧渔 > 农学 > A case study of socio-economic returns from farm forestry and agriculture in
侵权投诉

A case study of socio-economic returns from farm forestry and agriculture in

394H.T.L.Stewartetal./ForestPolicyandEconomics13(2011)390–395

Forthesecondcropofpulplogsfromthebluegumtimberbelts,assumingthattheproductioncycleorrotationwouldbethesameasthe rstrotation(i.e.14yearsfrom2007to2021),butthattheproductionsystemwouldbemanagementofcoppiceregrowthfromthestumpsinsteadofplantingnewseedlings,thenetpresentvalueoroperatingpro twasestimatedtobe$2541/hain2007dollarsatarealdiscountrateof5%.Thebene t–costratiooftheprojectwas2.7.

Thefarmerestimatedthatthefuturereturnsfromthelivestockenterprise(mainlyproductionofsheepmeat)during2007–2021wouldbeanannualoperatingpro tof$180/ha.Usingthisassumption,theoperatingpro toffarmingduring2007–2021wasestimatedtohaveanetpresentvalueof$1782/hain2007dollarsatarealdiscountrateof5%.

Forfarmforestry,theannualequivalentreturnwas$125/hain1993dollarsinthe rstproductionperiod(1993–2007)and$256/hain2007dollarsinthesecondproductionperiod(2007–2021);forfarming,therespectiveannualequivalentreturnswere$78/haand$180/ha(Table2).

Inboththe rstrotationofbluegum(usingactualcash ows)andthesecondrotationofbluegum(usingestimatedcash ows),thenetpresentvalueforfarmforestrywasgreaterthanthatoflivestockgrazingoverthesameperiodoftime(Table2).3.2.Perceptionsoffarmforestry

In1999,11%ofthepropertywasrevegetatedwithatargetof14%by2005,whichhasbeenachieved.Becauseofthesuccessoffarmforestry,thefarmerhadsincerevisedthetargetandaimedtorevegetate20%oftheproperty,thentobereviewedifachieved(“…farmforestryhasgreatlyexceededourexpectations.AsIseethepropertydevelop,Iammorepassionatethaneveraboutit”).Thestrategywouldconcentratethefarmforestryplantingintimberbelts(15–30mwide)alongland-classboundariesandinnarrowerbeltsofcommercialtreeswithunderstoreyforbiodiversityenhancementalongriparianzones—thatis,strategicallyplacedonproductiveagriculturalland.Althoughunabletoprovidequantitativeevidence,thefarmerbelievedthatagriculturalproductionofthewholefarmhadbeenmaintaineddespiteconversionofarablelandtofarmforestrybecauseofprotectionoflandandlivestockbytherevegeta-tion(“…Iamcomfortableoverallthatwehavenotcompromisedagriculturalproductivity”).

Thefarmerwassatis edwiththetreefarmingagreement,particularlythewillingnessofthecompanytomoveawayfromatraditionalplantationcon guration(i.e.blockplanting)andestablishthetreesintimberbeltsalongpropertyandland-classboundaries.

Thefarmerexplainedthatthebene tsoffarmforestryincludedincreasedpropertyvalue,providinggreaterequityandborrowingcapacityforthefarmingenterprise,andareductionintheriskoffarming.Thefarmersaidthatanalysisoffarmforestrybene tstypicallyonlyaccountedforthedirecteconomicbene ts,butfromthefarmer'sperspective,therewereimportantenvironmentalbene tsandsocialbene ts.Fromthefarmer'sexperienceinthepastdecade,thesebene tsweresubstantialandunexpected.Forexample,the

Table2

Comparisonofreturnsfromfarmforestry(bluegumforpulplogs)andfarming(livestockgrazing)fortwoproductionperiods.Enterprise

ActualreturnsEstimatedreturnsfor1993–2007for2007–2021(1993dollars)(2007dollars)Farmforestry

Netpresentvalue($/ha)

$1236$2541Annualequivalentreturn($/ha/year)$125$256Farming

Netpresentvalue($/ha)

$768$1782Annualequivalentreturn($/ha/year)

$78

$180

amenityvalueoffarmforestryhadimprovedthefamilydynamics—bothimmediateandextended;theemergingeco-tourismbusinessonthefarmhadcreatedanimportantsocialnetworkforthefarmingfamily;andtheaestheticsandambienceofthepropertycontinuedtoimprove(“…thefarmisnowafarmorepleasantworkenvironment”).Thelatterwasexpressedbyimprovedlandscapesandmorebiodiversity(measuredbyregularcountsofbirdspecies)asthefarmforestryplantingsbecamemorediverseandmature.

Thefarmingenterprisewasbeingconductedinaregionundergoingsocio-economicchange,re ectedbyalargeincreaseinruralpropertypricesinthelast10yearsasbuyersfromurbanareaspurchasedfarms.Thefarmersaidthatmarketvalueofthefarm(atleast$10000/hain2007terms,basedonanindependentvaluation)wassubstantiallymorethantheagriculturalvalueoftheland,basedonthefarmer'sanalysisusingregionaleconomicdatafromanagriculturalconsultinggrouptogetherwiththefarmer'sownexperienceoffarminginthelocality.Thisperspectivewasborneoutbyusingthefarmer'sestimateoffutureoperatingpro tfromlivestockproductiontocalculatethevalueoflandforfarming—atanassumedoperatingpro tof$180/ha,thevalueofthelandforfarmingwas$3600/haatarealdiscountrateof5%,usingthecapitalassetpricetheory(Clarketal.,1993).Nevertheless,thefarmerwascommittedtousingthelandprimarilyforagribusinessandsaidthatfarmforestrywouldbeanintegralcomponentofland-useontheproperty.

4.Discussion

Thetimberbeltcon guration,whichseparatedthebluegumplantationfromthepastures,wasthemostpracticalwayofintegratingtimberproductionandlivestockproductiononthefarm.Underthisarrangement,differentinteractionsacrosstheboundarybetweenthetreesandpasture(‘edge-effect’)aretheoreticallypossible(Reid,2009).Themostcommonlyobservededge-effectinAustraliangrazingsystemsisasigni cantreductioninpasturegrowthalongthetreeboundary(Reid,2009),whichwasthecaseinthisprojectandwasaccountedforbyestimatingtheopportunitycostofreducedpastureproductionasacosttothefarmforestryenterprise.Thiseffectwasestimatedtobegreaterinthesecondrotationofbluegumbecauseofthecarry-overeffectsofthe rstrotationcrop.However,itispossiblethattimberbeltsreducedwindspeedandhencetheevapotranspirationofpastureatsomedistancefromthetimberbelt,resultinginincreasedpastureproduction(Abeletal.,1997)andthatshelterimprovedanimalproduction(Reid,2009).Ifsuchbene tsoccurred,theobserveddifferenceinthe nancialbene toffarmforestryandlivestockgrazingwouldhavewidened.

Thelongitudinalstudydemonstratedthepotentialforfarmforestryinachanginglandscape.Thefarmerwithmorethan15yearsexperiencewithfarmforestryhaddedicated15%oftheagriculturallandtostrategicallyplacedcommercialforestry.The nancialreturnsfrombluegumgrownforpulplogproductioninaforestrypartnershipexceededthosefromfarming.Whilethisexamplewasnotbroadlyrepresentativeoffarmforestryinsouth-eastAustraliabecauseofthediversityofthelatter,itdemonstratedthatfarmforestrycanbeeconomicallyviable.However,stumpagepricesandhencereturnsfromfarmforestryaredependentonharvestingcostsandtransportdistancetotheprocessingcentre.Inthecasestudy,harvestingcostswereoffsettosomeextentbyintegratingtheoperationwithharvestingofanindustrial-scaleplantationinthelocality,andthefarmforestwaslocatedclose(65km)totheprocessingcentrerelativetomostbluegumplantationsintheregion.

Thefarmerwhohadsuccessfullyintegratedfarmforestryasaland-usewascommittedtofarmforestrybeingpartofthediversi edfarmingbusiness.Alsodemonstratedwasthatwithwell-designedfarmforestry,productionandamenitycanco-existandsocialnetworkscan

上一页第5页

你可能喜欢

热门文档

相关文档

站点地图 | 文档上传 | 侵权投诉 | 手机版
本站所有资源均来自互联网,本站只负责收集和整理,均不承担任何法律责任,如有侵权等其它行为请联系我们.
文档下载 Copyright 2013 doc.guandang.net All Rights Reserved.  -  email