394H.T.L.Stewartetal./ForestPolicyandEconomics13(2011)390–395
Forthesecondcropofpulplogsfromthebluegumtimberbelts,assumingthattheproductioncycleorrotationwouldbethesameasthe rstrotation(i.e.14yearsfrom2007to2021),butthattheproductionsystemwouldbemanagementofcoppiceregrowthfromthestumpsinsteadofplantingnewseedlings,thenetpresentvalueoroperatingpro twasestimatedtobe$2541/hain2007dollarsatarealdiscountrateof5%.Thebene t–costratiooftheprojectwas2.7.
Thefarmerestimatedthatthefuturereturnsfromthelivestockenterprise(mainlyproductionofsheepmeat)during2007–2021wouldbeanannualoperatingpro tof$180/ha.Usingthisassumption,theoperatingpro toffarmingduring2007–2021wasestimatedtohaveanetpresentvalueof$1782/hain2007dollarsatarealdiscountrateof5%.
Forfarmforestry,theannualequivalentreturnwas$125/hain1993dollarsinthe rstproductionperiod(1993–2007)and$256/hain2007dollarsinthesecondproductionperiod(2007–2021);forfarming,therespectiveannualequivalentreturnswere$78/haand$180/ha(Table2).
Inboththe rstrotationofbluegum(usingactualcash ows)andthesecondrotationofbluegum(usingestimatedcash ows),thenetpresentvalueforfarmforestrywasgreaterthanthatoflivestockgrazingoverthesameperiodoftime(Table2).3.2.Perceptionsoffarmforestry
In1999,11%ofthepropertywasrevegetatedwithatargetof14%by2005,whichhasbeenachieved.Becauseofthesuccessoffarmforestry,thefarmerhadsincerevisedthetargetandaimedtorevegetate20%oftheproperty,thentobereviewedifachieved(“…farmforestryhasgreatlyexceededourexpectations.AsIseethepropertydevelop,Iammorepassionatethaneveraboutit”).Thestrategywouldconcentratethefarmforestryplantingintimberbelts(15–30mwide)alongland-classboundariesandinnarrowerbeltsofcommercialtreeswithunderstoreyforbiodiversityenhancementalongriparianzones—thatis,strategicallyplacedonproductiveagriculturalland.Althoughunabletoprovidequantitativeevidence,thefarmerbelievedthatagriculturalproductionofthewholefarmhadbeenmaintaineddespiteconversionofarablelandtofarmforestrybecauseofprotectionoflandandlivestockbytherevegeta-tion(“…Iamcomfortableoverallthatwehavenotcompromisedagriculturalproductivity”).
Thefarmerwassatis edwiththetreefarmingagreement,particularlythewillingnessofthecompanytomoveawayfromatraditionalplantationcon guration(i.e.blockplanting)andestablishthetreesintimberbeltsalongpropertyandland-classboundaries.
Thefarmerexplainedthatthebene tsoffarmforestryincludedincreasedpropertyvalue,providinggreaterequityandborrowingcapacityforthefarmingenterprise,andareductionintheriskoffarming.Thefarmersaidthatanalysisoffarmforestrybene tstypicallyonlyaccountedforthedirecteconomicbene ts,butfromthefarmer'sperspective,therewereimportantenvironmentalbene tsandsocialbene ts.Fromthefarmer'sexperienceinthepastdecade,thesebene tsweresubstantialandunexpected.Forexample,the
Table2
Comparisonofreturnsfromfarmforestry(bluegumforpulplogs)andfarming(livestockgrazing)fortwoproductionperiods.Enterprise
ActualreturnsEstimatedreturnsfor1993–2007for2007–2021(1993dollars)(2007dollars)Farmforestry
Netpresentvalue($/ha)
$1236$2541Annualequivalentreturn($/ha/year)$125$256Farming
Netpresentvalue($/ha)
$768$1782Annualequivalentreturn($/ha/year)
$78
$180
amenityvalueoffarmforestryhadimprovedthefamilydynamics—bothimmediateandextended;theemergingeco-tourismbusinessonthefarmhadcreatedanimportantsocialnetworkforthefarmingfamily;andtheaestheticsandambienceofthepropertycontinuedtoimprove(“…thefarmisnowafarmorepleasantworkenvironment”).Thelatterwasexpressedbyimprovedlandscapesandmorebiodiversity(measuredbyregularcountsofbirdspecies)asthefarmforestryplantingsbecamemorediverseandmature.
Thefarmingenterprisewasbeingconductedinaregionundergoingsocio-economicchange,re ectedbyalargeincreaseinruralpropertypricesinthelast10yearsasbuyersfromurbanareaspurchasedfarms.Thefarmersaidthatmarketvalueofthefarm(atleast$10000/hain2007terms,basedonanindependentvaluation)wassubstantiallymorethantheagriculturalvalueoftheland,basedonthefarmer'sanalysisusingregionaleconomicdatafromanagriculturalconsultinggrouptogetherwiththefarmer'sownexperienceoffarminginthelocality.Thisperspectivewasborneoutbyusingthefarmer'sestimateoffutureoperatingpro tfromlivestockproductiontocalculatethevalueoflandforfarming—atanassumedoperatingpro tof$180/ha,thevalueofthelandforfarmingwas$3600/haatarealdiscountrateof5%,usingthecapitalassetpricetheory(Clarketal.,1993).Nevertheless,thefarmerwascommittedtousingthelandprimarilyforagribusinessandsaidthatfarmforestrywouldbeanintegralcomponentofland-useontheproperty.
4.Discussion
Thetimberbeltcon guration,whichseparatedthebluegumplantationfromthepastures,wasthemostpracticalwayofintegratingtimberproductionandlivestockproductiononthefarm.Underthisarrangement,differentinteractionsacrosstheboundarybetweenthetreesandpasture(‘edge-effect’)aretheoreticallypossible(Reid,2009).Themostcommonlyobservededge-effectinAustraliangrazingsystemsisasigni cantreductioninpasturegrowthalongthetreeboundary(Reid,2009),whichwasthecaseinthisprojectandwasaccountedforbyestimatingtheopportunitycostofreducedpastureproductionasacosttothefarmforestryenterprise.Thiseffectwasestimatedtobegreaterinthesecondrotationofbluegumbecauseofthecarry-overeffectsofthe rstrotationcrop.However,itispossiblethattimberbeltsreducedwindspeedandhencetheevapotranspirationofpastureatsomedistancefromthetimberbelt,resultinginincreasedpastureproduction(Abeletal.,1997)andthatshelterimprovedanimalproduction(Reid,2009).Ifsuchbene tsoccurred,theobserveddifferenceinthe nancialbene toffarmforestryandlivestockgrazingwouldhavewidened.
Thelongitudinalstudydemonstratedthepotentialforfarmforestryinachanginglandscape.Thefarmerwithmorethan15yearsexperiencewithfarmforestryhaddedicated15%oftheagriculturallandtostrategicallyplacedcommercialforestry.The nancialreturnsfrombluegumgrownforpulplogproductioninaforestrypartnershipexceededthosefromfarming.Whilethisexamplewasnotbroadlyrepresentativeoffarmforestryinsouth-eastAustraliabecauseofthediversityofthelatter,itdemonstratedthatfarmforestrycanbeeconomicallyviable.However,stumpagepricesandhencereturnsfromfarmforestryaredependentonharvestingcostsandtransportdistancetotheprocessingcentre.Inthecasestudy,harvestingcostswereoffsettosomeextentbyintegratingtheoperationwithharvestingofanindustrial-scaleplantationinthelocality,andthefarmforestwaslocatedclose(65km)totheprocessingcentrerelativetomostbluegumplantationsintheregion.
Thefarmerwhohadsuccessfullyintegratedfarmforestryasaland-usewascommittedtofarmforestrybeingpartofthediversi edfarmingbusiness.Alsodemonstratedwasthatwithwell-designedfarmforestry,productionandamenitycanco-existandsocialnetworkscan
Socio-economic driving forces of arable land conversion-A case study of ... agriculture, forestry, animal husbandry, industry, transportation and ...
Life cycle assessment a case study of a dwelling home in Scotland_电子/...socio-economic development and also a major user of energy and natural ...
On the basis of socio-economic assumptions, sectoral energy-demand projections...[1] Bathing[2] Agriculture Transportation Notes ECLTH = Energy service for ...
of Minnesota at Minneapolis to study forestry. ...agriculture came under severe criticism from ...His work faced environmental and socio-economic ...
Socio-Economic Security ... 暂无评价 90页 免费... a case study from north India Dinesh Mohana, ...Agriculture injuries survey The study was done in...
Re-engineering of the forest stand database: case study of Bilahe Forestry Bureau, Inner Mongol_专业资料。维普资讯 http://www.cqvip.com Junlfoet eerh(...
Sustainable Ecosystem Management versus Economic Exploitation: A Case Study of Lake Naivasha Ba_专业资料。Jl2 ,ou ,.Srl.)u 0 Vly10me4No7(ei 3 ...
in rapidly urbanizing China Case study of Shanghai...a dramatic changeover from central planning to ...and GIS methods Socio-economic driving forces ...
Urban growth pattern modeling_ a case study of Wuhan city, PR China_...The rapid physical and socio-economic 0169-2046/02/$20.00 ? 2002 ...
programme with the socio-economic criteria, i.e....Ministry of Forestry Ministry of Home Affairs 民政...Agriculture The Agency for Soil and Water ...
热门文档