英语教学法 methodology of English teaching
Observations - why bother?
Submitted by Andy Baxter on 7 December, 2010 - 17:04
"Nice board work." This was a killer phrase back in the days before the invention of the interactive whiteboard. It normally sat, all alone, in the left hand column of a page divided by a vertical line, under the label "Good".
The right hand column was labelled "To Think About". And, even though you were just starting to learn how to teach, you couldn't help noticing that the number of entries that your Teacher Trainer had made in the "To Think About" section had overflowed into the bottom of the "Good" half, and sometimes even on to the back of the page.
It meant your lesson had been rubbish. Or rather, it meant that your lesson had been judged as rubbish. Because this phrase was, essentially, a code. To a novice teacher, it meant that you had written on the board in straight lines and not made any really bad spelling mistakes. But to the more experienced observer, the code was clear: the lesson was a stinker. This may be an extreme example, but it does show how the notes from lesson observations do not necessarily mean what they say. Indeed, they will say one thing to one person (or set of people) and something quite different to another.
Why is this? And why does it matter?
Well, partly it is an example of groupthink. Trainers train trainers and those trainers become trainer trainers and so on: unless your organisation has seen a significant influx of new staff there will be a line of
continuity. And unfortunately all those trainers will have the same belief: that they are describing the lesson they are observing.
They are not. They are, rather, demonstrating what they have been
conditioned to see. To see this phenomenon in a different area of activity, let us look at the examples of football referees. Supporters criticise referees during games because the refs are discriminating against their club. And yet both sets of supporters feel this discrimination. Obviously, they can't both be right. In fact, I would suggest that they are both wrong. The referee is observing the game carefully. But he or she can only see half the action (even with the help of assistant referees). And, even then, they too have been subjected to groupthink. After every international match, football experts on TV complain that the referee comes from a country with different tolerances of physicality or dissent.
1 SUMMARY OBSERVATIONS 暂无评价 7页 免费 General Observations 暂无评价 2页 1财富值 — observations and futu... 暂无评价 3页 免费 Astrochemistry and ...
Little_R Observations Format 格式说明_专业资料。Little_R Observations Format 格式说明,这是做同化的朋友必备的Observations Format To make the best use of ...
observations of galaxy clusters W. D OMAINKO1 , W. B ENBOW1 , J. A. H INTON2 , O. M ARTINEAU -H UYNH3 , M. DE NAUROIS3 , D. N EDBAL4...
It is the bifactor that makes the new robust estimator for correlated observations di?er from that of the IGGIII scheme or that of the LS method. 3 ...
Observations on China’s People-to-People Diplomacy_英语学习_外语学习_教育专区。? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? . 2 2013 O P -P C D ? ? ? ? ...
Primary identifications and palynological observations_专业资料 暂无评价
Our detections are based upon spectral line mapping observations of the R(3) and R(4) rotational lines of HD, at rest wavelengths of 28.502 and 23...
OBSERVATIONS OF JETS IN H II REGIONS (HH 444)_专业资料。Presentamos espectros de rendija larga de alta resolucion espectral de HH 444 y simulaciones ...
Influence Analysis of the Missing Observations Model_天文/地理_自然科学_专业资料。Mathematical Computation June 2013,Volume 2,Issue 2, ...
Profiler observations provide estimate of end of transition (onset of daytime convective ABL) ? Data from two sites – Tower observations from Cabauw ...
热门文档