Paula M. the Carbone Carbone| Scaffolding Rhetorical Situation page
Aristotle in the Classroom: Scaffolding the Rhetorical Situation reparing students for meaningful participation in democratic society includes entering into conversations surrounding important issues of the day using some form of public deliberation, such as editorials, blogs, or letters to elected officials. Yet, while arguing may be a basic human activity, educators cannot assume that students’ transition from using persuasive arguments in their lived experience to writing an argumentative essay will meet academic expectations without carefully planned instruction and scaffolding. In this article, I explore the use of the rhetorical situation in the classroom, with emphasis on encouraging students to join conversations around issues of the day that are important to their lives and to strengthen their argumentative writing. I begin by defining argumentative writing; then I introduce Aristotle’s triangle to model the means of persuasion and construct an argument using the rhetorical square as a scaffold. The student voices shared here are from various secondary classrooms in which I have modeled this strategy and observed teachers as they implement it. While I prefer to focus on argumentative writing for reasons noted above—namely, to prompt students’ participation in issues of importance to them—a practical reason to address argumentative writing is its centrality in the Common Core State Standards (CCSS). The benefits of focusing on argument are readily apparent in strengthen-
41
P
ing students’ critical thinking and understanding of“rhetorical purpose and organization” (Beach, Thein,& Webb, 2012). Delving into these aspects of argumentative writing supports conceptbased teaching and student-centered models of teaching by scaffolding the ways choices are made within rhetorical situations, and then releasing responsibility to students to make those choices individually as they consider their stances on topics of interest. Argumentative writing in academic settings is expected to incorporate the elements of persuasion (c.f., Toulmin, 2003): claim/stance, supporting evidence, warrants linking the evidence to the claim, and opposing perspectives as While arguing may be a counterarguments or basic human activity, educoncessions. While I believe most students have cators cannot assume that an intuitive understand- students’ transition from ing of the elements of argument (Carbone& using persuasive arguments Orellana, 2010) and the in their lived experience to capability to use these skills—think of young writing an argumentative adolescents convincing essay will meet academic their parents for privileges or merchandise— expectations without careputting these elements fully planned instruction together cohesively and convincingly in writing and scaffolding. requires specific knowledge of the rhetorical context, academic expectations for marshaling evidenc
e, and structuring of an academic essay. Using rhetoric as a starting point from which to develop students’ argumentative writing facilitates the use of complex,
Copyright© 2014 by the National Council of Teachers of English. All rights reserved. Voices from the Middle, Volume 21 Number 3, March 2014

modern scholars see Aristotle as dividing artistic ...Rhetorical vs. dialectical proofs induction = ...kinds of speech--determined by the situation ??...
号:2008124315 Key words: Aristotle speech theory political speech Introduction:...(audience) – Identity – Turn of mind at the rhetorical situation – ...
Aristotle believed that metaphor is "a matter to...It is not only a kind of rhetorical device, ...imagine the ridiculous situation that soapy is in...
? Socrates, Plato, Aristotle. ? Father of ...Glowing Language Rhetorical feature Phonological level...Suppose: Situation 1: You campaign for one key ...
iv)Different rhetorical devices in different ...Situation: In the 7th and 8th centuries, the ...The works translated are those by Aristotle, ...
which implied the situation of American Society ...“in the Rhetoric, Aristotle presents the earliest...rhetorical devices——exaggeration and irony to ...
iv)Different rhetorical devices in different ...Situation: In the 7th and 8th centuries, the ...The works translated are those by Aristotle, ...
热门文档