
JournalofRetailing84(2,2008)

131–135
Editorial
Onwhatmakesasigni cantcontributiontotheretailingliterature
Abstract
Duringthepast2years,wehaveprocessedscoresofsubmissionstotheJournalofRetailing.Thosethathavenotbeenpublished(orscheduledforpublication)sufferfromavarietyofproblems.Ourexperienceindicatesthatthesinglemostvexingdif cultywiththesepapersistheirlevelofcontribution.Inthiseditorial,wede newhatwemeanbyasigni cantcontributiontotheretailingliterature.Wediscussseveralgeneralwaysinwhichamanuscriptcanmakeasigni cantcontributiontotheliterature—addingnewknowledge,deepeningourunderstandingofexistingknowledge,surprisingresults,andaddressingnewproblemsthatinterestscholarsandpractitioners.Wesuggestanapproachfororganizingandarticulatingapaper’scontribution.Weconcludebyofferingacoupleofsourcesofideasformakingsigni cantcontributionstotheretailingliterature.
©2008NewYorkUniversity.PublishedbyElsevierInc.Allrightsreserved.
Keywords:Signi cantliteraturecontribution;Newknowledge;Deskrejection;Successfulauthorship;Retailingliterature
Introduction
Duringthepast2years,scoresofmanuscriptshavebeensubmittedtotheJournalofRetailing(JR).Alargemajorityofthesepaperswereimmediatelysentoutforreview.Ofthosereviewed,roughly85%didnotpassmusterwiththereviewersand/orus.Thosepapersthatwerenotsentoutforreviewweredeskrejected.BasedonthevariousMeettheEditorconferencesessionsthatweattend,thesestatisticsareonparwithotherhighlyregardedjournalsinmarketing.
Whythesuccessrateisnothigherforthesejournals,includ-ingtheJR,isanimportantissue.Armstrong(1982)articulatesthecriteriathateditorsandreviewersusetomakethosedecisions(foranotherperspective,seeOzanne,Fern,andYadav1990).Amongthesecriteriaareobjectivity,replicability,competence,intelligibility,ef ciency,andimportance.
Wedescribethesecriteriabrie y.“Objectivitycanbede nedastheextenttowhichastudyisindependentoftheresearcher’sbias”(Armstrong1982,p.84,emphasisadded).“Replicabilitymeansthatotherresearchersshouldbeabletoreproducethekeyelementsofthestudy”(Armstrong1982,p.88,emphasisadded).Competencedenotesthatresearchshouldbeproperlyexecuted(i.e.,appropriateresearchmethod,correctuseofpriorresearch,analysisfreefromerrors).Intelligibleresearchisread-able.Thatis,submissionsshouldbewellorganizedandclearlywritten;theyshouldalsobefreeofgrammaticalandtypograph-icalerrors.“Ef ciencymeansthatjournalspaceisusedwiselyandthattimeissavedforreadersandauthors”(Armstrong1982,p.96,emphasisadded).Thisimpliesthatarticlesshouldbeasshortaspossibleandasshouldbetheturnaroundtimebetweensubmissionandpublication.Finally,importancereferstothesigni canceofthepaper’scontributiontotheliterature.
WefocusonthislastofArmstrong’scriteria–importanceorcontribution–forfourkeyreasons.Firstandforemost,weattheJRbelievethatthelackofimportanceorcontributionisthekeyreasonwhymarketingjournalrejectionratesaresohigh(LevyandGrewal2007).Second,inadditionto(Armstrong1982),othereditors,reviewers,andresearchershavesharedtheirsuggestionswithauthorsforimprovingtheirpapers’objectiv-ity,replicability,competence,intelligibility,andef ciency(forexample,seeSummers2001;SuttonandStaw1995;Varadarajan1996).WhileSmith(2003)explicitlyaddressedtheissueofresearchcontribution,webelievethatrestatingandexpandinguponhissuggestionsisworthwhile.And,thatleadstoourthirdreasonforfocusingonresearchcontribution.Thecriteriaforwhatconstitutesasigni cantcontributiontotheliteraturearenotwellde ned(Ozanne,Fern,andYadav1990).Thisarticlerepresentsourattemptataddingsomespeci citytotheexpli-cationofsigni cantcontribution.Finally,inourexperienceaseditors,reviewers,andresearchers,specifyingapaper’scontri-butioncanbethemostelusivepartofwritingapaper(cf.Smith2003).Assuch,wehopethatexploringwhatconstitutesasignif-icantcontributiontothemarketingliterature,ingeneral,andtheretailingliterature,inparticular,providesourcontributorsand
0022-4359/$–seefrontmatter©2008NewYorkUniversity.PublishedbyElsevierInc.Allrightsreserved.doi:10.1016/j.jretai.2008.05.002
2财富值 2.on what makes a signif... 暂无...Contribution to the Arabic Literature" held on 24...The following are some of the significant changes...
2财富值 2.on what makes a signif... 暂无...Contribution to the Arabic Literature" held on 24...The following are some of the significant changes...
热门文档