Abstract. Concept Maps are seen as ways to conceptualize domains that can be comprehended within the human attention span, and are often based on terminologies arising in technical, scientific or engineering domains. We report on a set of related projects
Concept Maps: Theory, Methodology, Technology
Proc. of the Second Int. Conference on Concept Mapping
A. J. Cañas, J. D. Novak, Eds.
San José, Costa Rica, 2006
FORMALIZING THE INFORMAL: A CONFLUENCE OF CONCEPT MAPPING AND
THE SEMANTIC WEB
Thomas Eskridge, Pat Hayes, Robert Hoffman, Florida Institute for Human and Machine Cognition (IHMC), USA
Margaret Warren,Carma Productions, USA
Email: teskridge,phayes,rhoffman@ihmc.us, doc.guandang.net
Email: mm@carmapro.com , doc.guandang.net
Abstract. Concept Maps are seen as ways to conceptualize domains that can be comprehended within the human attention span, and
are often based on terminologies arising in technical, scientific or engineering domains. We report on a set of related projects that go
beyond this tradition in two ways: by connecting CmapTools to the new, machine-processable standard notations for formal Web meta-data (RDF and OWL), and by applying the resulting tools to the construction of Web markup for works of art. This domain
provides a semantically-rich case study because descriptions of artwork inherently contain a mix of artifacts, some of which can easily
be formalized (creator, title, creation date, etc.) and some of which express meanings about the work that are more difficult to
formalize. Formalization of knowledge about works of art could benefit web developers by giving greater organization to these types
of resources on the internet. It will also help foster the development of ontologies in other, similarly rich and challenging domains. A
CmapTools extension called CmapTools Ontology Editor (COE) translates RDF and OWL to and from Concept Maps, providing a
bridge between the worlds of human-oriented Concept Mapping and machine-oriented formal inference. Because of the strengths in
CmapTools to provide a specific method for capturing meanings and concepts, we believe that the COE extension can provide the
means for formalizing this conceptually challenging domain that involves an artist's interpretation of the intentions and motivations
behind their artwork.
1 Introduction
The Semantic Web is often viewed as the “next generation” of the current World Wide Web (Berners-Lee, Hendler et al. 2001), which aims to create a simple way to express and store interchangeable data on the internet.
Because the volume of web resources (web pages, images, music, video, etc.) continues to increase exponentially, there is a recognized need for advanced strategies that will enable resources to be interpreted more logically by search engines and other intelligent agents. As such, there are many individuals and organizations beginning to explore the integration of semantic web strategies into their future web development activities.
The most widely accepted technique for employing semantic web technologies involves the use of a formalized language (OWL/RDF1) to ‘markup’ web resources with detailed descriptions of their content that can be more easily ‘ingested’ by computers. The resulting machine-readable markup is often referred to as an ontology. Ontologies must be created using a tightly controlled and elaborate syntax, and are required to satisfy many logical constraints, some of which may not be intuitively clear to human readers. Because of this, determining the content and structure of an ontology for a given domain requires an expert-level understanding of that content and its purpose.
CmapTools (Cañas, Hill et al. 2004) has been used to capture knowledge of human experts for use in training (Hoffman, Coffey et al. 2006), institutional memory preservation (Coffey, Eskridge et al. 2004), and in-the-field use (Coffey, Cañas et al. 2003). The method for eliciting this knowledge usually involves a moderator who questions and guides the expert and a mapper who documents the interview in one or more concept maps (Hoffman, Shadbolt et al. 1995; McNeese, Zaff et al. 1995). The result of this process, called a knowledge model, has proven to be easily navigated and understood by human users. However, because of their semantic expressivity, Concept Map-based knowledge models cannot easily be interpreted and made actionable by computers.
The work reported here is part of an effort to build a bridge between these two worlds (human comprehension and computational analysis), by casting OWL/RDF semantic web ontologies in the form of Cmap knowledge models, thereby making available to users the human-oriented clarity and conceptual organization provided by Cmaps, while retaining the ability to produce exact, formal ontologies for semantic-web markup.
1 See doc.guandang.net and doc.guandang.net
Formalizing Botanical Taxonomies Uta Priss School of Computing, Napier University, u.priss@napier.ac.uk Abstract. Because botanical taxonomies are prototypical...
These notes discuss formalizing contexts as first class objects. The basic relations are ist(c; p) meaning that the proposition p is true in the ...
Formalizing the Concepts Simple Random Sampling_建筑/土木_工程科技_专业资料。Formalizing the Concepts Simple Random SamplingFormalizing the Concepts: Simple ...
Formalizing UML for Rigorous Software Development Formalizing a modeling technique broaches issues including development of software specification, design, analysis...
A method for formalizing, analyzing, and verifying secure user interfaces Abstract. We present a methodology for the formalization of humancomputer interaction...
Formalizing and Analyzing Sender Invariance Paul Hankes Drielsma, Sebastian M¨dersheim, Luca Vigan`, David Basin o o Information Security Group, Dep. of...
nedness (sttwu) and then formalizing in sttwu examples of unde?nedness arising in calculus. The examples are taken from M. Spivak’s well-known text...
Formalizing narratives using nested circumscription The representation of narratives of actions and observations is a current issue in Knowledge Representation, ...
Formalizing Space Shuttle Software Requirements Four Case Studies This paper describes two case studies in which requirements for new flight-software subsystems...
Formalizing INductive Proofs of Network Algorithms Abstract. Theorem proving and model checking are combined to fully formalize a correctness proof of a ...
热门文档