IEEETRANSACTIONSONMAGNETICS,VOL.46,NO.1,JANUARY2010127
AQuantitativeComparativeAnalysisofaNovelFlux-Modulated
Permanent-MagnetMotorforLow-SpeedDrive
W.N.FuandS.L.Ho
TheHongKongPolytechnicUniversity,HungHom,Kowloon,HongKong
Anovellow-speed ux-modulated(FM)permanent-magnet(PM)motorthatbreaksthetraditionaldesignrule,whichstipulatesthatthenumberofstatorpolepairsandthenumberofrotorpolepairsmustbethesame,isproposed.TheFMmotorhasaspecialphysicalstructurewithironsegmentsintheairgaptomodulatethemagnetic eld.Inthedesign,thefreespacebetweenadjacentstationaryironsegmentsalsoactsasventilatingductstohelpimprovingtheheatdissipationandventilationofthemotor.Itscoggingtorqueisverysmall.Inthispaper,aruleforcomparingthepowerdensityofelectricmotorsisproposed.TheperformanceoftheFMmotoriscomparedwiththoseofamagnetic-gearedPMmotor,atraditionalPMmotor,andafractional-slotPMmotorbyusingmagnetic eld nite-elementanalysis.
IndexTerms—Electricmotor, nite-elementanalysis, uxmodulation,low-speeddrive,magnetic eld,powerdensity,ventilation.
I.INTRODUCTION
Nmanyindustrialapplications,low-speeddrivesarere-quired.Foranelectricmotor,itsoutputtorqueisapproxi-matelyproportionaltoitsvolume.Astheoutputpowerofmotorisproportionaltotheproductofitsoutputtorqueandspeed,themotorwillbeverymassiveifitisdesignedtodrivealow-speedmechanicalloaddirectly.Amechanicalgearisusuallyneededtoreducetheoutputspeedofthemotorbeforeitisconnectedtothemechanicalload.However,themechanicalgearreducestheenergytransmissionef ciency.Recently,magneticgearsareproposedtoreplacethemechanicalones[1]–[5].Comparedtotheirmechanicalcounterparts,magneticgearshaveverycom-petitivetorquetransmissioncapabilityandef ciency.Themag-neticgearcanalsobedirectlycombinedwithaconventionalpermanentmagnet(PM)motorwiththeouter-rotorstructurehousedinsidealowspeedrotatingframe[6]–[8].Thesystemtorquedensitycanbesigni cantlyimproved.Thedisadvantageisthatsuchasystemhastworotatingpartsanditsmechanicalstructureiscomplicated.
Anovelmagnetic-gearedmotorwithsimplestructurewaspresentedrecently[9].Essentiallyitintegratesamagneticgearwithaconventionalouter-rotorPMmotor.Ithasonlyonero-tarypart.TheouterrotorisequippedwithsinteredNdFeBmag-nets.Thestatorhasathree-phaseconcentratedwindingwhichproducesarotatingmagnetic eldwiththreepolepairs.Theouterrotorhas22polepairsanditsstationaryironsegmentsaremadeofsiliconsteellaminationswhichcanbeexploitedformodulatingtheairgap eldspaceharmonics,andtherotorcanrotateatlowspeedef ciently.Theoperatingprincipleoftheproposedmagnetic eldmodulationissimilartothatofthemagneticgear.However,thehigh-speedrotary eldiscreatedwithanarmatureratherthanwiththemagnets.Asfarastheau-thorsareaware,thereisnoquantitativecomparisonbetweentheproposedmotorandtraditionalmotors.
ManuscriptreceivedJune09,2009;revisedJuly30,2009.CurrentversionpublishedDecember23,2009.Correspondingauthor:W.N.Fu(e-mail:eewnfu@polyu.edu.hk).
Colorversionsofoneormoreofthe guresinthispaperareavailableonlineatdoc.guandang.net.
DigitalObjectIdenti er10.1109/TMAG.2009.2030677
I
Inthispaper,thenovelmotorisreferredasthe ux-modulated(FM)motor.Aruletocomparethepowerdensityofvariouselectricmotorsispresented.TheperformanceoftheFMmotoriscomparedwiththoseofamagnetic-gearedmotor,atraditionalPMmotor,andafractional-slotmotor.Theiradvantagesanddisadvantagesarediscussed.
II.BASICCOMPARISONRULESOFMOTORSBEINGSTUDIEDThepurposeofthispaperistocomparetheoutputpowerperunitvolumeoffourdifferenttypesofmotors.Allthemotorsbeingstudiedhavethreephasesandareoperatedassynchronousmotors.Forthesakeofsimpleperformancecomparison,theex-citationcurrentsinthemotorwindingsareassumedtobesinu-soidalatafrequencyof220Hz.Theratedspeedis600rpm.Rulestocomparethepowerdensitiesofdifferentmotorsareasfollows.
1)Allmotorshavethesameoutsideradiusandaxiallength;thesametypeandamountofPMmaterials;thesamegradeofironandcoppermaterials.
2)Thetemperaturerisesatfull-loadarethesameforallfourmotors.
Becausethetemperature-risecomputationisbeyondthescopeofthispaper;thus,thepowerlosseswillbeusedasanindirectmeasureofthetemperatureriseofthefourmotorsasa rstorderofapproximation.Moreover,asthecorelossisonlyasmallpercentageofthetotallossesinthesemotors,onecantakethecopperlossasanindicationofthetemperatureriseinallfourmotors.Inotherwords,itisassumedthatthesamecopperlosswillhaveapproximatelythesametemperaturerise.Intheanalysis,thephaseresistanceofthewindingintheeffectiveregion(excludingtheendwinding)


















































is
(1)
0018-9464/$26.00©2009IEEE
流式细胞分析Comparative-Flow-Cytometric-Analysis-...The results presented give a quantitative indication...Therefore, in this study we introduced a novel ...
A Flux-modulated Low-speed Motor with an Improved Structure and its_天文...L. Ho, “A quantitative comparative analysis of a novel flux-modulated ...
437Quantitative Statistical Analysis of cis-...modulated mainly by transcriptional control to the ...A second novel motif, AGTNGGTCC, was found in ...
This paper proposes a quantitative software quality... for the attributes to make comparative judgment....This division follows quality analysis framework ...
A novel method of quantitative risk assessment based on grid difference of...Quantitative comparative analysis on explosion and poisoning accidents of arti?...
Quantitative real-time RT-PCR (qRT-PCR) analysis showed that CiHMGB2a and ...Rao et al. / Developmental and Comparative Immunology 41 (2013) 164–177 ...
A Comparative Study on Proteomics between LNCap and DU145 Cells by Quantitative Detection and SE_专业资料。维普资讯 http://www.cqvip.com Jahn nvSiehoMe ...
Quantitative real-time RT-PCR (qRT-PCR) analysis showed that CiHMGB2a and ...Rao et al. / Developmental and Comparative Immunology 41 (2013) 164–177 ...
热门文档