YorkReview of Books, Robert Darnton, the head of Harvard University's library, argued that because such books are a common resource – the possession of us all – only public, not-for-profit
bodiesshould be given the power to control them.
The second related criticism is that Google's scanning of books is actually illegal. This allegation has led to Google becoming mired in (陷入) a legal battle whose scope and complexity makes the Jarndyce and Jarndyce case in Charles Dickens' Bleak House look straightforward.
At its centre, however, is one simple issue: that of copyright. The inconvenient fact about
most books, to which Google has arguably paid insufficient attention, is that they are protected by copyright. Copyright laws differ from country to country, but in general protection extends for the duration of an author's life and for a substantial period afterwards, thus allowing the author's heirs to benefit. (In Britain and America, this post-death period is 70 years.) This means, of course, that almost all of the books published in the 20th century are still under copyright – and the last century saw more books published than in all previous centuries combined. Of the roughly 40 million books in US libraries, for example, an estimated 32 million are in copyright. Of these, some 27 million are out of print.
Outside the US, Google has made sure only to scan books that are out of copyright and thus in the "public domain" (works such as the Bodleian's first edition of Middlemarch, which anyone canread for free on Google Books Search).
But, within the US, the company has scanned both in-copyright and out-of-copyright works. Inits defence, Google points out that it displays only small segments of books that are in copyright– arguing that such displays are "fair use". But critics allege that by making electronic copies of these books without first seeking the permission of copyright holders, Google has committed piracy.
"The key principle of copyright law has always been that works can be copied only
once authors have expressly given their permission," says Piers Blofeld, of the Sheil Land literary
agency in London. "Google has reversed this – it has simply copied all these works without bothering toask."
In 2005, the Authors Guild of America, together with a group of US publishers, launched aclass action suit (集团诉讼) against Google that, after more than two years of negotiation, endedwith an announcement last October that Google and the claimants had reached an out-of-courtsettlement. The full details are complicated - the text alone runs to 385 pages– and trying tosummarise it is no easy task. "Part of the problem is that it is basically incomprehensible," saysBlofeld, one of the settlement's most vocal British critics.
Broadly, the deal provides a mechanism for Google to compensate authors and
publishers whose rights it has breached (including giving them a share of any future revenue it generates fromtheir works). In exchange for this, the rights holders agree not to sue Google in future.
This settlement hands Google the power - but only with the agreement of individual rights holders – to exploit its database of out-of-print books. It can include them in subscription deals sold to libraries or sell them individually under a consumer licence. It is these commercial provisions that are proving the settlement's most controversial aspect.
Critics point out that, by giving Google the right to commercially exploit its database,
thesettlement paves the way for a subtle shift in the company's role from provider of information to seller. "Google's business model has always been to provide information for free, and sell advertising
2011 年 12 月大学英语六级真题 Part I Writing (30 minutes) Directions: For this part, you are allowed 30 minutes to write a short essay entitled The...
2013年12月大学英语六级真题及答案真题+听力原文+答案详解_韩语学习_外语学习_教育专区。2013年12月大学英语六级真题及答案真题+听力原文+答案详解ctions...
2013年12月大学英语六级真题及答案真题+听力原文+答案详解_英语考试_外语学习_教育专区 暂无评价
2010年12月大学英语六级考试真题+听力原文+答案详解_英语考试_外语学习_教育专区...听力听写易错单词 2009年6月英语六级考试真... 2011年12月大学六级真题...1...
2014年6月大学英语六级真题及答案真题+听力原文+答案详解_韩语学习_外语学习_教育专区。2014年6月大学英语六级真题及答案真题+听力原文+答案详解o...
2011年6月大学英语六级真题卷+听力原文+答案详解_英语考试_外语学习_教育专区 暂无评价
2009年12月大学英语六级考试真题+听力原文+答案详解_英语考试_外语学习_教育专区 暂无评价
2009年12月大学英语六级考试真题+听力原文+答案详解 隐藏>> 2009 年 12 月大学英语六级考试真题及答案 Part Ⅰ Writing (30 minutes) Directions: For this part...
2011年12月英语六级真题听力原文以及答案_英语考试_外语学习_教育专区。2011年12月大学英语六级真题听力原文以及答案2011 年 12 月大学英语六级真题及答案 Part I Wr...
热门文档