Twenty-eight intermediate and twenty-two advanced L2 learners (the experimental groups) and twenty native speakers of English (the control group) participated in a study that investigated second language learners ’ interpretation of reflexives in the VP-e
Hongguang Ying 161
b. Johni defended himselfi and Billj did [defend himi] too. (i.e., John)
In (2a) the reflexive himself in the elided VP co-refers with Bill. This interpretation, known as the sloppy reading, is set by the requirement of Principle A of Binding Theory. In (2b), the pronoun him in the elided VP co-refers with John—the subject of the higher clause. This interpretation, known as the strict reading, is set by Principle B of Binding Theory.
2. Previous Analyses: Semantic versus Syntactic
It is relatively uncontroversial that reflexives have a sloppy reading, on the assumption that they function obligatorily as bound variables. But there has been disagreement in the linguistic literature on the status of a strict reading. Work by Dalrymple, Shieber, and Pereira (Dalrymple, Shieber & Pereira 1991, Shieber, Pereira & Dalrumple 1996) represents the semantic approach. Dalrymple, Shieber & Pereira (1991) proposed that the availability of a strict reading of a reflexive depends on the semantic property of individual verbs. They distinguished between verbs such as lock and defend, stating that no matter what the structure is, the verb defend allows a strict reading, but not the verb lock.
(3) Bill defended himself against the accusation, and John did,
too.
(4) John locked himself in the bathroom when bad news arrived,
but Bill would never do so.
She explained that defend gets both sloppy and strict readings because it does not intrinsically impose a requirement of coreference
G. Ying Relevance mapping: a study of second language learners’ processing...Interpretation of reflexive anaphora in second language VP-ellipsis: Relevance...
G. Ying Relevance mapping: a study of second language learners’ processing...Interpretation of reflexive anaphora in second language VP-ellipsis: Relevance...
热门文档