法律案例
107 S.Ct. 2793
Supreme Court of the United States
SOUTH DAKOTA, Petitioner,
v.
Elizabeth H. DOLE, Secretary, United States Department of Transportation.
No. 86-260. | Argued April 28, 1987. | Decided June 23, 1987.
State of South Dakota brought action challenging constitutionality of federal statute conditioning states receipt of portion of federal highway funds on adoption of minimum drinking age of 21. The United States District Court for the District of South Dakota, Andrew W. Bogue, J., dismissed complaint, and state appealed. The Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit, 791 F.2d 628, affirmed, and state petitioned for writ of certiorari. The Supreme Court, Chief Justice Rehnquist, held that statute conditioning receipt of highway funds on adoption of minimum drinking age is valid use of Congress spending power.
Affirmed.
Justices Brennan and O Connor, filed dissenting opinions.
REHNQUIST, C.J., delivered the opinion of the Court, in which WHITE, MARSHALL, BLACKMUN, POWELL, **2795 STEVENS, and SCALIA, JJ., joined. BRENNAN, J., post, p. ----, and O CONNOR, J., post, p. ----, filed dissenting opinions.
Opinion
*205 Chief Justice REHNQUIST delivered the opinion of the Court.
Petitioner South Dakota permits persons 19 years of age or older to purchase beer containing up to 3.2% alcohol. S.D.Codified Laws § 35-6-27 (1986). In 1984 Congress enacted 23 U.S.C. § 158 (1982 ed., Supp. III), which directs the Secretary of Transportation to withhold a percentage of federal highway funds otherwise allocable from States “in which the purchase or public possession ... of any alcoholic beverage by a person who is less than twenty-one years of age is lawful.” The State sued in United States District Court seeking a declaratory judgment that § 158 violates the constitutional limitations on congressional exercise of the spending power and violates the Twenty-first Amendment to the United States Constitution. The District Court rejected the State s claims, and the Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit affirmed. 791 F.2d 628 (1986).
In this Court, the parties direct most of their efforts to defining the proper scope of the Twenty-first Amendment. Relying on our statement in California Retail Liquor Dealers Assn. v. Midcal Aluminum, Inc., 445 U.S. 97, 110, 100 S.Ct. 937, 946, 63 L.Ed.2d 233 (1980), that the “Twenty-first Amendment grants the States virtually complete control over whether to permit importation or sale of liquor and how to structure the liquor distribution system,” South Dakota asserts that the setting of minimum drinking ages is clearly within the “core powers” reserved to the States under § 2 of the Amendment.1 Brief for Petitioner 43-44. Section 158, petitioner claims, usurps *206 that core power. The Secretary in response asserts that the Twenty-first Amendment is simply not implicated by § 158; the plain language of § 2 confirms the States broad power to impose restrictions on the sale and distribution of alcoholic beverages but does not confer on them any power to permit sales that Congress seeks to prohibit. Brief for Respondent 25-26. That Amendment, under this reasoning, would not prevent Congress from affirmatively enacting a national minimum drinking age more restrictive than that provided by the various state laws; and it would follow a fortiori that the indirect inducement involved here is compatible with the Twenty-first Amendment.
又如 1987 年的 “南 ( 案中 ,最高法院再度扩展贸易权 ,在某种产品的任 达科它州诉道尔” South Dakota v. Dole ) 案允许国 何部分都未涉入州际贸易时 ...
SC South Carolina[?k?r??la?n?]南卡罗来纳州, Columbia 哥伦比亚 SD South Dakota 南达科他州, Pierre 皮尔, Sioux Falls 苏族瀑布 TN Tennessee 田纳西州, ...
(罗德岛) South Carolina(南卡罗来纳 州) South Dakota(南达科他州) Tennessee(田纳西州) Texas(德克萨斯州) Utah(犹他州) Vermont(佛蒙特) Virginia(弗吉尼亚州)...
jersey [nju: NJ 'd??:zi] N New York [nju: j?:k] Y 北达科他 州 North Dakota [n?:θ d?'k?ut?] N D O K PA ana South Carolina einj?...
South Dakota 南达科他州 The Location of South Dakota Flag南达科他州州旗 Emblem南达科他州州徽 Corn Palace in South Dakota View picture South Dakota ? ...
NY Wright State University Chicago State University South Dakota State University East Carolina University University of North Texas SUNY Institute of Technology...
【天道原创】美国大学地图-美国南部各州-南卡罗来纳州South Dakota SC_院校资料_高等教育_教育专区。资料介绍美国大学地图,美国南部南卡罗来纳州South Dakota SC。South...
Dakota South Dakota Massachusetts Rhode Island Minnesota ## Cut into 2 ...{MASS}: Absenteeism from School in Rural New South Wales The quine data ...
South carolina SC 哥伦比亚 Columbia 南达科他州 South dakota SD 皮尔 Pierre 田纳西州 Tennessee TN 纳什维尔 Nashville 德克萨斯州 Texas TX 奥斯汀 Austin 犹他州...
In states like South Dakota, a person can get a 37 only three months later. In my state, Massachusetts, we can get a learner’s 39 getting a ...
热门文档