管理学论文
Knight,Durham,andLocke(2001)foundthatdif cultperformancegoalsincreasedtheriskinessofthestrategiesparticipantschosetouseinacomputergameandimprovedperformance.Obviously,higherriskstrategiessometimesleadtoworseperformanceoutcomesthanlowerriskones,andtheconditionsunderwhichbetterorworseoutcomesoccurneedtobestudiedfurther.Personality
Tworelatedissuesareinvolvedhere.First,dogoals,alongwithself-ef cacy,mediatepersonalityeffects?Itmustbenotedherethatthereissomedoubtaboutthemeaningofpersonalitytestscores(Bandura,1986,1997).Ifatraitmeasurerefersonlytopastbehavior,thentrait–performancecorrelationsinvolvepredictingcurrentbehav-iorfrompastbehavior.Traits,inthiscase,wouldpredictbutnotexplainbehavior.If,however,traitsareviewed,explicitlyorimplicitly,asre ecting,insomeform,under-lyingmotives,thentheywouldconstituteanexplanation.
Regardlessofone’sopiniononthisissue,anumberofstudieshavefoundthatgoals,alongwithself-ef cacy,mediatetheeffectofpersonalitymeasuresonworkperfor-mance(seeLocke,2001,forasummary).Forexample,Matsui,Okada,andKakuyama(1982)foundthattherela-tionshipbetweenachievementmotivation(measuredwithaquestionnaire)andperformancedisappearedwhenthedif- cultylevelofself-setgoalswascontrolled.Barrick,Mount,andStrauss(1993)foundthattheeffectsofcon-scientiousnessonsalesperformancewerepartiallymedi-atedbygoalsandgoalcommitment.VandeWalle,Cron,andSlocum(2001)foundthatgoalsandself-ef cacyme-diatedtheeffectofaperson’sgoalorientationonstudentperformance.
Thesecondissueinvolvediswhethergoalsarebetterpredictorsofactionthantraits.Ifgoalsmediatepersonalityeffects,thentheformershouldpredictbetterthanthelatter.AdlerandWeiss(1988),intheirreviewofthegoal-settingliterature,arguedthataperformancegoalisastrongvari-ablethatmaskspersonalitydifferences.YuklandLatham(1978)foundthatgoalspredictedperformanceandsatis-factionbetterthanameasureofneedforachievement.Dweckandhercolleagues(Dweck,1986;Dweck&Leg-gett,1988;Elliott&Dweck,1988)foundthattwoperson-alitytraitscharacterizedchildrenintheclassroom.Thosewithadesiretoacquireknowledgeandskills—thatis,thosewithalearninggoalorientation(LGO)—performedbetteronschool-relatedsubjectsthanwhosefocuswasprimarilyonattainingaperformanceoutcomesuchasagradeorscore—thatis,thosewithaperformancegoalorientation(PGO).Inindustrial/organizationalpsychology,PGOhasbeenmeasuredasadesirenotforchallenginggoalsbutratherforcertainoreasysuccessthatresultsinpraise(Button,Mathieu,&Zajac,1996)—afocusthatgoaltheorypredictswouldbeassociatedwithlowperformance.Thus,itwouldbeanLGOratherthanaPGOthatwouldbemorelikelytoleadpeopletoundertakechallenges,thusleadingtohighperformance,aswasfoundbyVandeWalleetal.(2001).Asnoted,thelatterstudyfoundLGOeffectstobefullymediatedbygoals.
SeijtsandB.W.Latham(2001)conductedastudytodeterminewhetheralearninggoaltooisastrongvariable.TheyfoundthatindividualswhohaveahighPGObutaregivenaspeci c,dif cultlearninggoalperformaswellasthosewithalearninggoalwhohaveanLGO.Inshort,assignedgoalsneutralizegoalorientationeffects.
FurtherevidencethatthesettingofahighgoalcreatesastrongsituationwasobtainedbyHarackiewiczandElliott(1998).Usingapinballmachine,theyfoundthat,regard-lessofwhetherapersonscoredhighorlowonneedforachievement(asmeasuredbyaself-reportquestionnaire),aspeci chigh-performancegoalthatwasaccompaniedbyarationaleorpurposethatemphasizedaPGOresultedinahigherlevelofintrinsicmotivation(e.g.,continuedperfor-manceduringfreetime)thanaperformancegoalthatemphasizedanLGO.Intheabsenceofastatementofpurpose,aspeci chigh-performancegoalthatemphasizedanLGOresultedinthehighestlevelofintrinsicinterestinthetask.
GoalsandSubconsciousMotivation
BecausewehadstudiedconsciousgoalsandMcClellandetal.(1953)hadassertedthatachievementmotivationwassubconscious,McClellandcollaboratedwithLockeandotherstoseeiftherewasarelationshipbetweenthesetwoconcepts.Theresults,involvingentrepreneursintheprint-ingbusiness,showedthatneedforachievement,measuredbytheThematicApperceptionTest(TAT;aprojectivetest),hadnoconcurrentorlongitudinalrelationshipwitha rm’sperformanceandnorelationshiptoentrepreneur-setgoals.However,goaleffectswerehighlysigni cantinbothcases(Tracy,Locke,&Renard,1999).
HowardandBray(1988)collectedTATdataina25-yearstudyofmanagersatAT&T.CollaboratingwithMcClelland,theyconstructedapatternscoreforleaders’motivesfromtheTAT.Thisscorecombinedneedforpower,powerinhibition,andneedforaf liation(weightednegatively).HowardalsopossessedunscoredTATproto-colsthatshesubsequentlyaddedtothedataset.Inaddition,shemadescoringadjustments,afterconsultingwithMc-Clellandaboutrecentre nementsintheprocedure,forcalculatingleadermotivepattern.Inthereanalysis,theleadermotivepatternwasnotsigni cantlyrelatedtoman-agers’numberofpromotions.However,managers’ambi-tionwasasigni cantmotivationalpredictorofnumberofpromotionsoverthe25-yearperiod.Howard(personalcommunication)notedthatthecoreitemintheambitionfactorwasasingleinterviewquestion:“Howmanylevelsupdoyouwanttogo?”Thiswasthemanagers’consciousgoalfornumberofpromotions.Managers’motivepatternsandtheirpromotiongoalswereunrelated.
TwotentativeconclusionsmaybedrawnfromHowardandBray’s(1988)results.First,evenoveralongperiod,Ryan’s(1970) rst-levelexplanationofmotivation,namely,consciousgoalsetting,maybemorereliablyanddirectlytiedtoactionthanaresecond-levelexplanations(e.g.,motives).Second,theconsciousandsubconsciousaspectsofachievementmotivationareunrelated.
P. Latham (2002), “Building a Practically Useful Theory of Goal Setting and Task Motivation: A 35-Year Odyssey,” American Psychologist, 57, 705-717...
goal setting theory is linked to job design, motivation and performance 5....– Job enrichment – is the practice of building motivating factors into ...
goal setting theory is linked to job design, motivation and performance 5....– Job enrichment – is the practice of building motivating factors into ...
热门文档