Collagen Membranes: A Review
Volume 72 Number 2
ndings implied that the collagen membrane decreases the mitotic activity of basal cells resulting in piling up of dividing cells adjacent to the membrane, thus inhibiting apical migration of the epithelium. Although these reports showed an adequate barrier function of the collagen materials, it is noteworthy that most studies were conducted in a rat model in a short period of time. Further studies in this area are still needed. It should be noted that a prolonged resorption rate of the collagen membrane does not always result in greater periodontal/bone regeneration. Using rat calvarial defects, Brunel et al.32 evaluated the effect of degrees of cross-linking on guided bone regeneration. Their results con rmed previous reports that the higher degree of cross-linking, the longer the resorption rate, and more defect lls were noted on membrane-treated sites. However, no statistically signi cant differences in bone lls were observed among sites treated with collagen membranes with different cross-linking degrees. Interestingly, highly cross-linked, slow-resorbing collagen membranes appeared to have negative effects on nal clinical outcomes as reported by Crigger et al.35 in a dog model. The authors found the greatest attachment gain when using weak cross-linked, rapid-resorbing collagen membranes, followed by ePTFE membranes and high cross-linked collagen membranes. Membrane exposure, one of the primary contributing factors for GTR/GBR failure, was commonly found in ePTFE membranes and highly cross-linked collagen membranes.
At 6 months, the highly cross-linked membrane group demonstrated extensive recession and loss of attachment. In contrast, the weak cross-linked collagen showed 84% new connective tissue attachment while ePTFE membranes had only 53%. Regarding cross-linking techniques, the glutaraldehyde technique, the most widely used chemical crosslinking technique, was reported to leave cytotoxic residue during the process.36 To overcome the drawback of this technique, the diphenylphosphorylazide (DPPA) technique was developed. Collagen barriers manufactured through this process showed comparable results when compared to other collagen membranes.33 In addition to cross-linking, heparan sulfate and fibronectin have also been added in an attempt to enhance the inhibitory effect on epithelial migration. In a dog model, Pitaru et al.37 compared the length of the root surfaces repopulated by connective tissue between sites treated with collagen membrane alone, and those treated with a bronectin and heparan sulfate-enriched collagen membrane. Approximately 30% more root surfaces were repopulated with connective tissue in the bronectin and heparan sulfate-treated group compared to the collagen alone group. Overall, studies have shown that collagen materials have an ability to inhibit apical migration of epithe218
lium regardless of the fast degradation rate. It should be noted that once the epithelium becomes mature, membrane integrity is no longer essential for tissue regeneration. Hence, the crucial period for the membrane to remain intact is during the early wound healing period when the epithelium actively migrates along the root surface.38 After that, the presence of a barrier may cause a delay in connective tissue maturation during the late phase of wound healing. Animal Studies Several animal studies have been conducted to evaluate the safety and ef cacy of collagen barriers (Table 2). Most earlier studies focused on collagen biocompatibility and its resorption rate,12,13,16,29,30,34 and the majority of them used surgically created defects. In addition, most studies ended within 4 to 12 weeks, with few studies lasting for 6 months. These factors should be considered when applying results obtained from these in vivo reports. Nevertheless, the conclusions drawn from these animal studies can be used as a reference for the material. They are: 1) collagen membranes are weak immunogen and biocompatible; 2) collagen membranes possess the chemotactic ability to attract gingival and/or PDL broblasts, thus promoting proliferation and extracellular matrix maturation, and facilitating wound healing;13,16 3) collagen membranes have been shown to be an effective barrier in preventing apical migration of epithelium;29,30,34 4) the higher degree of cross-linking, the slower the resorption rate;29-33,35 and 5) collagen membranes provide better clinical results when compared to open ap debridement alone.23,35,37,39,40 Guided Tissue Regeneration Intrabony defects.
Since the late 1980s, collagen membranes have been tested for their ability to promote regeneration in periodontal intrabony defects (Table 3).31,41-46 Most studies have shown signi cantly greater probing depth (PD) reduction, clinical attachment gain, and bone fill in collagen-treated groups than open debridement controls.31,42-45 The mean PD reduction from these studies ranged from 3.1 to 5.5 mm in collagen-treated groups, while only 2.2 to 2.8 mm reductions were noted in controls. However, Tanner et al.41 showed no difference in clinical attachment gain when comparing collagen membranes to ap debridement alone. It should be noted that this study was done in only 4 patients with hopeless teeth, and results were obtained only at 3 months. Other studies had more participants (9 to 52) with longer follow-up (6 months). Factors contributing to these variable results include different cross-linking techniques, initial probing depths, width of defects, measuring techniques, and different analytical methods.47 For example, Chung et al.42 used mean PD and attachment level from each tooth for data analysis instead

Table 2. Characteristics of Transwell Membranes Characteristics Polyester (PET) Polycarbonate PTFE/ Collagen-coated Pore Sizes Selecting the correct pore size ...
& Babu, M. Collagen based dressings -- a review. Burns 26, 54-62 (...Characterization of UV-irradiated dense/porous collagen membranes: morphology, ...
membranes at the varios opening of the digestive,...Reticular layer: is rich in collagen and elastic...2015国考面试通关宝典116份文档 2014一级建造师考试...
Collagen may be abundant ? Form a protective ...Tight junction – Connect the plasma membranes of...2015国家公务员考试备战攻略 2015国考行测模拟试题及...
fibers, natural and synthetic leather, collagen, and organic membranes. Geopolymer...2002, Melbourne, Australia, -11- minutes, can explode into a fireball....
the invasive stage of carcinomas, because of their ability to degrade type IV collagen, a major constituent of basement membranes (Stetler-Stevenson, 1990)...
Enzyme Between Macroscopic Membranes MicroEncapsulated ...-carrageenin, polyacrylamide, collagen; Solid ...文档贡献者 jiemotc 贡献于2015-03-01 专题推荐 ...
takes place within membranes of mesenchynal tissue....QUESTIONS FOR REVIEW 1 What components dose ...E.collagen fibrils are presen 7.Isogenous group ...
forms membranes Lines body cavities Lines lungs and capillaries Protects Fig....Used to attach the Epithelium Lamina propria fibers Collagen ? Fills the ...
Respectively, a and b show the SEM of DHT and DHT-EDC modified collagen-chitosan membranes 图 7是戊二醛改性膜的孔率测定结果,膜材料的孔 率在90%左右...
热门文档