Collagen Membranes: A Review
Volume 72 Number 2
using surgical techniques based on the principles of GTR.65-68 Similar results were reported when GTRbased techniques were compared to traditional root coverage procedures.69-72 However, GTR therapy offers an additional bene t through its potential of achieving new attachment formation along the previously denuded root surface, while it rarely occurred when a subepithelial connective tissue graft was utilized.73 Collagen membranes have recently been used in root coverage procedures (Table 6). While Shieh et al.74 gained 51.6% root coverage after 6 months, Zahedi et al.75 reported mean root coverage of 82.2% after 2 years. Since neither of these studies included a control group, it is inconclusive if the GTR-based procedure is comparable to the conventional procedures. In 1997,Özcan et al.76 compared the use of collagen membranes containing fibrin/fibronectin plus tetracycline root conditioning to coronally positioned aps. They reported no signi cant differences between groups with regard to mean root coverage. However, signi cantly more gain in clinical attachment was found in the collagen membrane group compared to the coronally positioned ap (4.21 mm versus 2.86 mm). Wang et al.77 compared a conventional subepithelial connective tissue graft to a GTR-based procedure using a newly designed double-thickness collagen membrane (prepared from cross-linked bovine tendon and supplied in individual 20× 15× 0.4-0.5 mm pieces) in 16 patients with bilateral Miller’s Class I or II (gingival recession≥3.0 mm) recession defects. Data from this study indicated that the GTR-based procedure resulted in statistically signi cant (P<0.05) improvements in recession depth, CAL, and width of keratinized and attached gingiva compared to baseline. Moreover, the results were comparable to those achieved from subepithelial connective tissue grafts, with mean root coverage of 73% and 84% for the newly designed collagen membrane and conventional connective tissue graft, respectively. Recently, Kimble et al.78 studied the effect of adjunctive bone graft placement during GTR-based root coverage procedures. Twen
ty patients with a Miller Class I or II buccal recession defect≥2.5 mm were randomly treated with either type I collagen membrane alone or type I collagen membrane plus DFDBA. Preliminary results from this study indicated both forms of treatment resulted in statistically signi cant (P<0.05) reduction of recession depths (69% for membrane alone and 79% for membrane plus DFDBA). It was concluded that there is a tendency for an additional bene t of bone graft for percent root coverage; however, no statistically signi cant difference was found between groups. In summary, data from available resources indicate that GTR-based procedures and subepithelial connective tissue grafts are clinically equivalent. In addition, using a barrier may also enhance more clinical 224
attachment gain.76 It should also be noted that with the GTR-based procedure, adequate flap thickness (≥0.5 mm in the defect area) seems to have a great in uence in improving the percent root coverage as reported by Harris70 (26.7% versus 95.9% root coverage in thin and thick tissue, respectively). Therefore, careful case selection is crucial for the success of this procedure. Guided Bone Regeneration (GBR) Implants have slowly emerged as an alternative procedure for replacing missing teeth. Ridge de ciency or inadequate bone height/width often compromises the overall treatment plan. Bone augmentation using GTR principles has become a common means to resolve these concerns. Studies have reported success in using barriers to augment bone prior to or after implant placement.79 When selecting an ideal material for GBR, the following requirements must be considered: wound stabilization, space creation and maintenance, protection of the underlying blood clot, and the ability to exclude unwanted tissues or cells (connective tissue and epithelium). Since collagen membranes ful ll all these criteria, it has become one of the materials used in GBR procedures. However, the fast resorption rate of collagen material remains a concern to most clinicians. So far, no study has de ned the actual time needed for GBR barriers. Iglhaut et al.80 reported that during GTR procedures, bone and/or PDL cell migration reach their peaks in 2 to 7 days after surgery, with a decrease in mitotic activity to almost normal levels by the end of the third week. It could be implied that cells needed for regeneration arrive at the wound sites in around 3 to 4 weeks; therefore, the length of time that the collagen membrane retains its integrity should be sufficient to allow selective cell repopulation. GBR procedures utilizing collagen membranes have been widely reported (Table 7).81-85 In a pilot study, Colangelo et al.81 created through and through defects on the lateral aspect of rabbit mandibles and then treated these defects with either a collagen membrane or no-treatment control. The histologic evaluation at 30 days demonstrated a nearly complete continuous layer of lamellar bone with osteoblastic
activity in the collagen membrane-treated group compared to only brous connective tissue in the control group. Sevor et al.82 created buccal dehiscence defects after placement of a total of 48 implants (24 hydroxyapatite[HA]coated and 24 grit-blasted) in 6 dogs. At 8 weeks, the mean defect fill was 80.29% in the collagen membrane-treated group compared to 38.62% in the control group. Contrary to the GTR procedures, additional bone grafting materials for space creation/maintenance tend to improve GBR outcomes. This was supported by

Table 2. Characteristics of Transwell Membranes Characteristics Polyester (PET) Polycarbonate PTFE/ Collagen-coated Pore Sizes Selecting the correct pore size ...
& Babu, M. Collagen based dressings -- a review. Burns 26, 54-62 (...Characterization of UV-irradiated dense/porous collagen membranes: morphology, ...
membranes at the varios opening of the digestive,...Reticular layer: is rich in collagen and elastic...2015国考面试通关宝典116份文档 2014一级建造师考试...
Collagen may be abundant ? Form a protective ...Tight junction – Connect the plasma membranes of...2015国家公务员考试备战攻略 2015国考行测模拟试题及...
fibers, natural and synthetic leather, collagen, and organic membranes. Geopolymer...2002, Melbourne, Australia, -11- minutes, can explode into a fireball....
the invasive stage of carcinomas, because of their ability to degrade type IV collagen, a major constituent of basement membranes (Stetler-Stevenson, 1990)...
Enzyme Between Macroscopic Membranes MicroEncapsulated ...-carrageenin, polyacrylamide, collagen; Solid ...文档贡献者 jiemotc 贡献于2015-03-01 专题推荐 ...
takes place within membranes of mesenchynal tissue....QUESTIONS FOR REVIEW 1 What components dose ...E.collagen fibrils are presen 7.Isogenous group ...
forms membranes Lines body cavities Lines lungs and capillaries Protects Fig....Used to attach the Epithelium Lamina propria fibers Collagen ? Fills the ...
Respectively, a and b show the SEM of DHT and DHT-EDC modified collagen-chitosan membranes 图 7是戊二醛改性膜的孔率测定结果,膜材料的孔 率在90%左右...
热门文档