Sensitivity of different generations and developmental stages In studies on reproductive toxicity
ToxicologyLetters226(2014)245–255
ContentslistsavailableatScienceDirect
ToxicologyLetters

journalhomepage:doc.guandang.net


t
Sensitivityofdifferentgenerationsanddevelopmentalstagesinstudiesonreproductivetoxicity
F.Schulz ,M.Batke,I.Mangelsdorf,C.Pohlenz-Michel,N.Simetska,G.Lewin
FraunhoferITEM,Nikolai-Fuchs-Str.1,30625Hannover,Germany
highlights
IntroductionofthenewFeDTexdatabaseforprenataldevelopmentandreproductivetoxicitystudies.Analysisofthemostresponsivegenerationanddevelopmentalstage.
Determinationofthemostaffectedcriticaltargetsinreproductionstudies.Identi cationofF1orF2exclusiveeffects.
article
info
abstract
Articlehistory:
Received19July2013
Receivedinrevisedform27January2014Accepted29January2014
Availableonline10February2014
Keywords:
FeDTexdatabase
ReproductivetoxicologyLOELNOEL
Riskassessment
Multi-generationreproductivetoxicitystudy
NumerousstudiesonreproductivetoxicityareexpectedtobenecessaryundertheEUprogramonReg-istration,Evaluation,AuthorisationandRestrictionofChemicals(REACH).Therefore,itisimportanttoanalyseexistingtestingstrategiesincludingalsotherecentlyimplementedextendedone-generationreproductiontoxicitystudy(EOGRTS,OECDguideline443).Forthispurposetheresponsivenessofthedifferentgenerationsanddevelopmentalstagesinstudiesonreproductivetoxicityisanalysedandcriticaltargetsofreproductivetoxicityareidenti edbyusingtheFraunhoferFeDTexdatabase.
TheF1generationisidenti edasmostresponsivegenerationinmorethan50%ofone-generationandmulti-generationreproductionstudies.WithintheF1generationtheadultstageismostlyaffectedcomparedtotheprenatalorpostnatalstage.ThetargetanalysisinF1hasrevealedalterationsinbodyweightashighlysensitiveforalldevelopmentalstages.Otherimportanttargetsaretheliver,kidney,testes,prostate,spermparametersaswellasdevelopmentallandmarks.The ndingsintheF2generationhaveshownahigherresponsivenessthanF1onlyin3%ofthestudies.Althoughin29studiesneweffectsareobservedinF2offspringcomparedtoF1irrespectiveofdoselevels,overallnosevereneweffectshaveemergedthatwouldchangeclassi cationandlabellingandjustifyanF1mating.
ThepresenteddatasupporttheimportanceofF1forriskassessmentanddemonstratethatthestudydesignoftheEOGRTSisasuitablealternativetotwo-generationstudies.However,comparedtoaconven-tionalone-generationstudytheEOGRTSmayidentifyadditionaleffectsbutwillchangeriskassessmentwithrespecttoNOELsonlyinrarecases.
©2014ElsevierIrelandLtd.Allrightsreserved.
1.Introduction
Currently,theEURegistration,Evaluation,AuthorisationandRestrictionofChemicals(REACH)programclaimsforthe(re)evaluationofthetoxicityofupto100,000chemicalsuntil2018(RovidaandHartung,2009),includingdevelopmentalandrepro-ductivetoxicityforindustrialchemicalsimportedormanufacturedat≥10tonsperyearaccordingtomandatoryendpointsmentionedinannexesVIII–XoftheEuropeanREACHRegulation(EC,2006).Therequiredoffspringstudiesareestimatedtoberesponsiblefor
Correspondingauthor.Tel.:+495115350318;fax:+495115350335..E-mailaddress: orian.schulz@item.fraunhofer.de(F.Schulz).
approximately90%ofanimaluseand70%oftoxicitytestingcostsunderREACH(RovidaandHartung,2009).Giventheshorttimeframe,thisambitiousgoalseemsonlyfeasibleifexistingdataareutilisedattheirbest,currenttestingstrategiesareoptimisedandnewalternativeinvitroandinsilicomethodsaredeveloped.Thisalsocontributestothe3R-principle(Reduction,Re nementandReplacementofanimaltesting)originallypublishedmorethan50yearsago(RussellandBurch,1959),primarilyforethicalreasonsbutalsoduetocostsavingsandtoallowamorerapidtoxicityeval-uation.Toxicitydatabasesareintegratedasusefultoolsintothisprocess.Themaintaskconsistsherebyinorganisingstudydatainananalysableformatwithoutlosinginformation.Afterwards,thedatapoolcanbeusedtoanalysecompoundrelatedtoxicologicalpropertiesandtore netoxicitytestingasfollows:
0378-4274/$–seefrontmatter©2014ElsevierIrelandLtd.Allrightsreserved.doc.guandang.net
of different strains of Tetranychus urticae and_...cacy against all developmental stages.5,6 A ...(allowing numerous generations in a growing season...
of different learning experience and provide ...in studies on intercultural communication competence ...sensitivity consists of six developmental stages, ...
In the context of Table 1. Sensitivity test on...different developmental stages was confirmed (Figure...studies [48,60] as well as custom-designed ...
Morphological Characteristics of Floral Organ at Different Microspore Developmental Stage in Bal_专业资料。Ot21,l ,.(ei .1c.00Vou4No6Srl3)meaNo Junlff ...
Studies on developmental mechanisms in Atlantic ...All developmental stages were reared using sea ...This may simply reflect the different composition ...
sensitivity of sperm, eggs and embryos to copper...developmental stages, few studies have examined ...in mean values are indicated with different ...
studies that have been conducted on this developmental process, there are ... together with the involvement of sensitivity of the tissues to particular ...
Developmental sequences or developmental stages in SLA_英语学习_外语学习_教育专区。defence 3今日推荐 180份文档 2014证券从业资格考试...
of different developmental stages in cells and the...in both in vivo and in vitro studies on the ...sensitivity and glucose tolerance are 31 SUN well...
in many different tissues such as leaves, petals...by endogenous levels and sensitivity of hormones. ...and developmental factors control the flower ...
热门文档