文档下载 文档下载导航
设为首页 | 加入收藏
搜索 请输入内容:  
 导航当前位置: 文档下载 > 所有分类 > 人文社科 > 教育学/心理学 > weigle2004
侵权投诉

weigle2004

读写结合

32S.C.Weigle/AssessingWriting9(2004)27–55

onthebasisofpersonalexperience.(doc.guandang.net~wwwrtp/essadev.htm,

retrievedOctober15,2003).

Asthisdescriptionindicates,thepromptsarechosenwithaviewtowardspro-

vidingstudentsavarietyoftopicstochoosefrom.However,thepromptsarenot

pilottestedbeforebeingusedoperationally,nordoestheRegentsTestingProgram

publishdataonwhichpromptsarechosenmostfrequentlyorhowstudentsperform

onindividualprompts.

TheRegentsEssayTestisratedonafour-pointholisticscale,withanyscore2

oraboveconsideredapassingscore.Eachtestisratedbythreeraters;thereported

scoreistheratingonwhichatleasttwooutofthethreeratersagree,orthemiddle

ratingifnotworatersagree.Thetestsfromallinstitutionsarescoredtogetherat

severalscoringsiteseachsemestertoensurethatsimilarcriteriaareusedacross

theuniversitysystem.

Asmentionedabove,whilethesamestatewidetestisrequiredfornativespeak-

ersthroughouttheuniversitysystem,eachcampushassomeleewayintesting

non-nativespeakers.UntilFall2001,thealternativetestforNNSatGeorgiaState

Universitywasadministeredbythecampustestingcenterandscoredbyrepresen-

tativesfromAL/ESLandEnglish.TheAlternateRegentsTestwassimilartothe

regularRegentsEssayTestwiththefollowingmodi cations:

Studentswereallowed90minutesratherthan60minutestocompletetheiressays.Dictionarieswereallowedduringthelast30minutesofthetest.Asmallnumberofpromptswereused,whichhadbeenscreenedfortheirappropriatenessforESLstudents.RatersincludedfacultyfromEnglishandESLratherthanEnglishonly.Onlythescorepoints1(fail)and2(pass)wereusedinrating.EssaysfortrainingraterscamefromapoolofessayswrittenbyNNS,rather

thanthepublishedtrainingsamplesfornativespeakers.

Despitethesemodi cations,numerousproblemsremainedwiththetest.Inad-

ditiontothegeneralconcernsabouttheappropriatenessofthetestformatforNNSs

asdiscussedabove,thefacultyfromtheEnglishandAL/ESLdepartmentswho

scoredthetestoveraperiodofyearsfeltthatmanyofthepromptswereproblem-

aticforvariousreasons.Asanexample,onepromptreads“Doyoulikeshopping?

Whyorwhynot?”Ratersfeltthatthispromptwasnotonlynon-academicinna-

turebutalsotendedtoelicitpooressays,asstudentstryingto tthe ve-paragraph

essayformatstruggledtocomeupwiththreedifferentreasonsforwhytheyliked

ordidnotlikeshopping.

Inaddition,ratersandteachersofESLsectionsofthetestpreparationcourse

wereconcernedaboutthescoringprocedures,asthetestwasscoredstrictlyona

pass/failbasis.Studentswouldhavenowayofknowingwhethertheirfailurein

thetestwasduetolinguisticorrhetoricalproblems,andthusthetestresultswere

uninformativefordiagnosticpurposes.

上一页第6页

你可能喜欢

热门文档

相关文档

站点地图 | 文档上传 | 侵权投诉 | 手机版
本站所有资源均来自互联网,本站只负责收集和整理,均不承担任何法律责任,如有侵权等其它行为请联系我们.
文档下载 Copyright 2013 doc.guandang.net All Rights Reserved.  -  email