文档下载 文档下载导航
设为首页 | 加入收藏
搜索 请输入内容:  
 导航当前位置: 文档下载 > 所有分类 > 人文社科 > 教育学/心理学 > weigle2004
侵权投诉

weigle2004

读写结合

42S.C.Weigle/AssessingWriting9(2004)27–55

purposes,sincethedecisionispass/fail,athirdraterisonlyusedwhenraters’scores

differacrossthedecisionpoint(13pointsforRhetoric,10forLanguage).Thetable

showstheagreementratesontheessaysusingboththesecriteria.Fromthetable

itcanbeseenthatoveralltheagreementratesontheGSTEPessayarequitehigh:

over95%fornearlyeveryadministrationafterthe rstsemester.

ThereareseveralpossiblereasonsforthehigheragreementratesontheGSTEP

Regents.ThesheernumberofdifferentpromptsintheAlternateRegentsTest

comparedtotheGSTEPRegentsTestisprobablyafactor:theessaysusedinrater

trainingfortheAlternateRegentsrepresentonlyafractionofthetotalnumberof

prompts,andratersdonothavetheopportunitytobuildconsensusonthequalities

ofpassingessaysoneachandeveryprompt.FortheGSTEPRegentsTest,thereare

trainingessaysforeachofthethreeformsofthetest,andratersarenormedusing

thespeci cformthattheywillberating.Thefactthattheessaycontentisbased

onthereadingsratherthanonstudents’personalexperiencealsomakestheessays

moredirectlycomparabletoeachother,whichmayleadtogreaterreliability.

Furthermore,theratingscalefortheAlternateRegentsconsistsofonlytwo

scorepointsandasaholisticscoredoesnotallowraterstoconsiderdifferent

aspectsofwritingseparately.Anessaythatisstrongrhetoricallybutsomewhat

weaklinguisticallymightthusreceiveapassingscorefromaraterwhoismore

orientedtowardsrhetoricalfactorsandafailingscorefromaraterwhofocuses

moreonsentence-levelconcerns.ThescalesfortheRegentsGSTEPhaveawider

rangeofpossiblescoresandarecompositesoftwoscores(contentandorganization

fortheRhetoricscale,andaccuracyandrange/complexityfortheLanguagescale),

whichtendstoincreasethereliabilityofratings(Bachman&Palmer,1996).

9.2.Failingstudents

Asnotedearlier,ByrdandNelson(1995)foundthatmostofthestudentswho

repeatedlyfailedtheAlternateRegentswritingtestwerestudentswhoshowed

apatternoffailureintheiruniversitycourses,notgenerallysuccessfulstudents

apartfromtheirinabilitytopassthetest.Inthatstudy,therecordsofstudents

whohadnotpassedthetestafterfouryearswereexamined.Inthecurrentstudy,

onlytwoyearsofdataonthetestareavailablesoitisnotpossibletoreplicate

ByrdandNelson’sstudyexactly.However,datafromthosestudentswhofailed

theGSTEPRegentsthreeormoretimesfrom2001–2003canbeexaminedfor

theirsimilaritiestoByrdandNelson’sdata.Duringthetwoyearscoveredbythe

study,ninestudentsoutof476tookthetestthreeormoretimes.Ofthese,four

stillhadnotpassedthetestaftertheirthirdattempt.Therecordsofthesestudents

wereexaminedtoseewhetherthey tthepro lesofJohns’(1991)studentorthe

studentswhofailedtheRegentsTestasdescribedinByrdandNelson(1995).The

resultsaresummarizedinTable5.Thefollowingdatawerecompiledforthese

students:(a)nativelanguage;(b)major;(c)GSTEPRegentsscores.Asthetable

shows,allfourstudentsfailedonbothrhetoricandlanguageatleastonce,andall

butonefailedonbothsectionstwoorthreetimes.

上一页第16页

你可能喜欢

热门文档

相关文档

站点地图 | 文档上传 | 侵权投诉 | 手机版
本站所有资源均来自互联网,本站只负责收集和整理,均不承担任何法律责任,如有侵权等其它行为请联系我们.
文档下载 Copyright 2013 doc.guandang.net All Rights Reserved.  -  email