milling
170S.R.Bysouthetal./InternationalJournalofPharmaceutics411 (2011) 169–171
Table1
Effectofmillingparametersoncocrystalformationusingahigh-throughputplanetarymill.Component1
Component2
Solvent(10 L)
Carbamazepine20.0±0.2mg(1equivalent)Caffeine30±0.3mg(2equivalents)Caffeine25±0.2mg(1equivalent)Caffeine30±0.3mg(2equivalents)
Saccharin15.5±0.2mg(1equivalent)Oxalicacid7±0.1mg(1equivalent)MaleicAcid14.9±0.1mg(1equivalent)MaleicAcid9.0±0.1mg(1equivalent)
NoneMeOHTolueneNoneMeOHTolueneNoneMeOHTolueneNoneMeOHToluene
Results
Millingtime0.5hUCCC1CC1
UC+CC2CC2
UC+CC2UC+CC1CC3
UC+CC2UC+CC2UC
UC+CC2
Millingtime2hUCCC1CC1
UC+CC2CC2
UC+CC2
UC+CC1+CC2CC3
UC+CC2
UC+CC1+CC2UC+CC3CC2
Millingtime4hUC+CC1CC1CC1
UC+CC2CC2
UC+CC2
UC+CC1+CC2CC3
UC+CC1+CC2UC+CC1+CC2UC+CC3CC2
UC:unreactedcomponents;CC1:cocrystalhavingstoichiometry1:1;CC2:cocrystalhavingstoichiometry2:1;CC3:cocrystalofundeterminedcomposition.
sampleadaptersthathaverecentlybecomeavailable,aroutineusageofsolid-statemethodsinpharmaceuticalcocrystalscreen-ingprotocolsischallengingduetotheirincompatibilitywithotherautomatedscreeningproceduresandthetimerequiredforsam-plepreparationanddecontaminationofthemillingvesselbetweenexperiments.
Inthiscommunication,wepresentasuccessfulcocrystalliza-tionscreen,executedonanovelplanetarymillingsystem,whichisamenabletogrindingupto48samplessimultaneously.Toourknowledge,smallscaleproductionofcocrystalsusingmechanizedaidshasreliedontheshakingofareactionvesselparalleltothevesselaxis,asexempli edbytheRetschsystem.Incontrast,inplan-etarymillingthehorizontalshakingactionoccursatrightangletotheaxisofthemillingvessel,whichisheldvertically.Automaxion(Varenguebec,France)hasadvancedtheplanetarymillingconceptfurther(Bysouth,2006,2008)bymodifyingthestandardmillingjarswithvialadaptersthatallowdistributionofmultiplevialsaroundthejarperiphery.Thisdesignmaintainscomparableforcesexertedonthemillingmediaandsamplesasthosefoundintradi-tionalplanetarymilling.Becausethevialadaptersarelargemassesofaluminium,theyserveasheatsinksthatminimizesampleheat-ing.Thecapacityofthemillisinverselyproportionaltothesizeofthevial,suchthatastandard4-positionlaboratorymilliscapableofaccommodating16200-mLvials,3220-mLvials,etc.Fortheexper-imentsdescribedinthisstudy,vialadapterstohold2-mLglassvials(Agilent,Partnumber5182-0864)wereproduced,thusacapacityof48vialswasachieved.
Theeffectivenessoftheplanetarymillingsysteminproducingcocrystalswastestedusingfourknownpharmaceuticalcocrys-tals:carbamazepine/saccharin(1:1),caffeine/oxalicacid(2:1),caffeine/maleicacid(1:1),andcaffeine/maleicacid(2:1).Thesemodelcocrystalcaseswerechosenduetotheirwell-reportedreproducibility,polymorphicandstoichiometricdiversity,andavailabilityofcharacterizationdata,whichservedasthebasisforvalidatingtheoutcomesofthestudy.Thecocrystalcomponentswereweighedinto2-mLglassvialscontainingtwo4-mmstainlesssteelbeads.Wheredesignated,10- LofsolventwasaddedandthesamplesweresubjectedtoneatgrindingorSDGfor0.5,2or4hataspeedequivalenttoashakingfrequencyof10Hz,usingaplanetarymill(Fritsch,IdarOberstein,Germany).
Oncemilled,thesamplesweremanuallytransferredontoananalyticalplateandsubjectedtoautomatedanalysesviaFT-Ramanspectroscopy(NicoletNXR9650equippedwithastainlesssteel96-wellsamplestage).TheuniquescreeninghitswerevalidatedbyPowderX-rayDiffraction(PXRD,PANalyticalX’PertPro).Thecocrystalformationwascon rmedorrefutedbasedoncompar-isonofthePXRDpeakspositionstothosereportedforthefourmodelcocrystals(Porteretal.,2008;Trasketal.,2005).Thesamplecomposition,millingtimesandresultsareshowninTable1.Table1showsthatalluniquemixturesunderwentsomedegreeofcocrystallizationunderatleastonesetofappliedgrindingcon-ditions.Partialcocrystallizationwasobservedwithin30mininthemajorityofexperimentsconducted.Asexpected,SDGwasmoreeffectiveascomparedtoneatgrinding,inthatmillingtimesof0.5–2hweresuf cienttoachievecompletecocrystallizationinallfourcasesstudied,whereasunreactedstartingcomponentsweredetectedinallneatlygroundsamples,evenafter4hofcontinu-ousgrinding.Whilecarbamazepine/saccharinandcaffeine/oxalicacidcocrystalwereobtainedinasinglesolid-stateform(poly-morphicand/orstoichiometric),grindingcaffeineandmaleicacidresultedinatotalofthreesolidforms.Twooftheseformswereidenti edas1:1and2:1cocrystals(CC1andCC2respectively)andthethirdsolidform(CC3)wasnew.Thermalanalysescon rmednoappreciablesolventlossuponheatingCC3,whichsuggestsitisanon-solvatedsolidform.PXRDanalysisofCC3formedafter4husing1:1ingoingmixtureindicatedthatonlytracesofunre-actedcaffeineandmaleicacidwerepresent,whereaslargeexcessofcaffeineandtraceofmaleicacidwerepresentintheproductobtainedusing2:1ingoingmixture.ThesedatasuggestthatCC3islikelyapolymorphicformof1:1caffeine/maleicacidcocrystal.Detailedstudiesareunderwaytounderstandthemechanismandrateofthiscocrystalformationandtheresultswillbereportedinaseparatemanuscript.Themillingexperimentswereperformedwithoutsampleloss,asthegroundmaterialwascontainedwithinthevialsduringtheentirecourseofthemillingoperation.Suchdesigneliminatescleaningstepsbetweenexperimentsthatareotherwiserequiredforthecurrentlyknownmillingvesselsandreducestheriskofsamplecross-contamination.Although,inthisstudythesamplesweremanuallytransferredontoananalyticalplateforsubsequentFT-Ramananalysis,itshouldbenotedthatthemilledsamplescouldalsobeanalyzeddirectlythroughthevialglass,thuspreservinganintactsample.Thebreadthanddiversityofthestudycouldthenbeexpandedfurtherbyapplyingadditionalportionsofsolventtotheintactsampleinordertogeneratesus-pensionsorsolutionsforsubsequentcocrystallizations,withoutanyadditionaldemandonthesolidcomponents.
Inconclusion,theAutomaxionmultisamplemillwassuccessfulatproducingtheexpectedcocrystalsandledtothediscoveryofapreviouslyunreported(Trasketal.,2005)solidforminthepresenceofmethanol.Thedeviceiscapableofcarryingoutupto48exper-imentsatatime,whichdeliversthehighestcapacityavailableforcocrystalscreeningviamechanochemicalmethods.Suchthrough-putenablesmoreexperimentalvariablestobeinvestigatedinlesstimeenablingfasterandmoreextensiveoptimisationofconditionsforcocrystalformation,e.g.,cocrystalformersandstoichiometries,solventstypeandamount,andcocrystallizationtime.Inadditiontotheincreasedthroughput,automatedapproachesprovidegreatercontrolofexperimentalconditions,suchastimingandgrinding
Mechanically assisted synthesis was performed in air atmosphere in a planetary ball mill (Fritch Pulverisette 5). Milling conditions were the following: ...
Microfabrication of single chamber SOFC with co-planar electrodes via multi...polyurethane resin (UT5750, KCC, Korea) by a planetary milling process for...
Microfabrication of single chamber SOFC with co-planar electrodes via multi...polyurethane resin (UT5750, KCC, Korea) by a planetary milling process for...
热门文档