Abstract — This paper describes a performance comparison of two PLLs for clock generation using a ring oscillator based VCO and an LC oscillator based VCO. We fabricate two 1.6GHz PLLs in a 0.18 m digital CMOS process and compare their performances based
APerformanceComparisonofPLLsforClockGeneration
UsingRingOscillatorVCOandLCOscillatorinaDigitalCMOSProcess
TakahitoMIYAZAKIMasanoriHASHIMOTOHidetoshiONODERADept.CommunicationsandComputerEngineering,KyotoUniversity,Presto,JST
Abstract—Thispaperdescribesaperformancecomparisonof
twoPLLsforclockgenerationusingaringoscillatorbasedVCOandanLCoscillatorbasedVCO.Wefabricatetwo1.6GHzPLLsina0.18mdigitalCMOSprocessandcomparetheirperfor-mancesbasedonthemeasurementresults.Wealsopredictsma-jorperformancesofPLLsinthefuturesuchasjitter,powercon-sumptionandchiparea,basedonaqualitativeevaluationinananalyticway.
Fig.1.PLLArchitecture

I.INTRODUCTION
Phase-LockedLoops(PLLs)arewidelyusedforclockgen-erationinhigh-speeddigitalsystems.Voltage-ControlledOs-cillator(VCO)isakeycomponentofPLLsandwehavetwochoices:avoltage-controlledringoscillator(ringVCO)andavoltage-controlledLCoscillator(LCVCO).AringVCOhasbeenconsideredtobeabetterchoice,becauseofitslowpowerconsumption,smallchipareaandwidetunablefre-quencyrange.Recentincreaseinclockspeedandthelatestmulti-GHzseriallinkcircuits,however,requiresrigidjitterperformance.Itisgettinghardertosatisfythedesignrequire-mentsusingasimpleringVCO.Incontrast,anLCVCOissu-periortoaringVCOintermsofnoisecharacteristicssuchasphasenoiseandjitter[1].
Inthisworkwefabricatetwo1.6GHzPLLsusingaba-sicringVCOandabasicLCVCO,andcomparetheirperfor-mancesbasedonthemeasurementresults.Thispaperalsodis-cussestheperformancepredictionofclockgenerationPLLsinananalyticway.
II.PLLARCHITECTURE
ThePLLarchitectureunderourstudyisshowninFig.1.Itiscomposedof vemajorblocks:aphase-frequencydetec-tor(PFD),achargepump,asecondorderloop lter,avoltage-controlledoscillator(VCO)andadivider.Allthecomponentsincludingtheloop lterandtheoutputbufferareintegrated.ThedesignedringVCOandLCVCOareshowninFig.2andFig.3respectively.TheringVCOis ve-stagedifferentialinverters.TheLCVCOisanNMOScross-coupleddifferentialoscillatorcomposedoftwosquare-shapedspiralinductorandadifferentialdiodevaractor.
III.EXPERIMENTALRESULTS
WefabricatedandmeasuredtwoclockgenerationPLLsina0.18mdigitalCMOSprocess.Supplyvoltageissetto1.8V.Theoperationalfrequencyis1.6GHzandtheoscillationam-plitudeiscontrolledtobe400mV.PLLreferencefrequencyof25MHzisgivenbyacrystaloscillator.Wecomparetheirper-formances;area,powerconsumption,tunablefrequencyrange,spectrum,jitterandphasenoise.
Figure4showstheoutputspectrumsoftwo1.6GHzPLLs.WecanseethatLCPLLspectrumismuchsharper.Diepho-

Fig.2.DifferentialRing

Oscillator
Fig.3.DifferentialLCOscillator
tographsoftwoPLLswiththesamescaleratioarealsoshowninFig.4.TableIliststhemeasuredperformancesoftwofabri-catedPLLs.IncomparisonwiththeLCPLL,theringPLLhasatenfoldtunablefrequencyrange,a1/4corechipareaanda1/2powerconsumption.Inthenoisecharacteristics,however,theLCPLLindicatesbetterperformances.Jitterisreducedby2/3,andphasenoiseat1MHzoffsetdecreasesby50dB/HzcomparedwiththeringPLL.
IV.PERFORMANCECOMPARISONINTHEFUTURE
ITRSroadmap[2]forecaststhattheoperatingfrequencywillbeover5GHzin2008andnear15GHzin2014.Inthissection,wepredictmajorperformancesofbothPLLssuchasjitter,powerconsumptionandchipareawithaqualitativedis-cussionbyananalyticalapproach.
Weusetheminimumchannellengthofthedeviceandthesameratioateverytechnologynode.ThenumberofinverterstageinringVCOisunchanged.Theratioofos-)iskeptcillationvoltageamplitudeandsupplyvoltage(
unchanged.Weassumethevalueofspiralinductoriscon-stantineverytechnologynode,whichweconsidertobecon-servative.OurpredictionusesandinTableIIthatareindicatedbyITRSroadmap[2].
Wepredictthejittercharacteristic((jitter)/(oscillationpe-riod))ofbothVCOs.First,weexamineof
TABLEI
THEMEASUREDPERFORMANCESOFTWOPLLS(OUT
FREQUENCY=1.6GHZ).
RingPLLLCPLL
Technology0.18mdigitalCMOS,5LM,1.8VFrequencyRange400MHz-1.8GHz1.49GHz-1.64GHzPowerConsumption10.4mW22.1mWPkPk/RMSjitter91ps/15.9ps29ps/3.6psPhaseNoise@1MHz65dBc/Hz113dBc/HzCoreChipArea0.07mm0.26mm
clock generation architecture are even more ... so performance will scale with device speed, ...Figure 10.5.2: Ring oscillator schematic. Figure...
are proposed to improve the jitter performance of PLLs, such as choosing a narrow bandwidth or using a low-gain voltage-controlled oscillator (VCO) [5...
performance of PLL combined with complicated logic ...one third of gain in the first ring oscillator.... frequency is proposed for clock generation. ...
Clock distribution and local oscillator of a digital low-level radio-frequency board for SSRF_专业资料。NcaSicn ehius1(0071 ulrcneadcnqe 21)-0e eT2 ...
A 1.5% jitter PLL clock generation system for...(LF), a voltage controlled oscillator (VCO), ...aligner, ancl by using a differential loop filter...
m CMOS process and achieves a jitter generation ... Oscillator, Phase Locked Loop, Phase Detector, ...performance, using noise simulations combined with ...
Their uses include clock generation, signal ... one of the chief metrics of PLL performance, ...behaviours in PLLs, using a ring oscillator VCO....
a simple comparison, Table 1 shows the ...generation technique (<50 Spectral performance ...steep stable reference clock oscillator is critical...
A 16-oscillator 1.3-GHz distributed clock network in 0.35- m CMOS is ...power and has substantial impact on the overall performance of the system. ...
The Generation of Independent Rayleigh Faders Yunxin...PERFORMANCE EVALUATION To evaluate the performance ...7 L Figure 5 shows the comparison results which...
热门文档