文档下载 文档下载导航
设为首页 | 加入收藏
搜索 请输入内容:  
 导航当前位置: 文档下载 > 所有分类 > 自然科学 > Evaluation of a Multiplex Real-Time Reverse Transcriptase PCR
侵权投诉

Evaluation of a Multiplex Real-Time Reverse Transcriptase PCR

592HINDIYEHETAL.J.CLIN.MICROBIOL.

TABLE2.Evaluationofsensitivities,speci cities,PPVs,andNPVsofdifferentassaysfordetectionofin uenzavirusesincomparisonto

resultsobtainedbythe“goldstandard”TC

In uenzavirus

MultiplexTaqMan

Sensitivity(%)

Speci city(%)

PPV(%)

NPV(%)

Sensitivity(%)

MultiplexRT-PCRSpeci city(%)

PPV(%)

NPV(%)

Sensitivity(%)

SV-IFASpeci city(%)

PPV(%)

NPV(%)

TotalAB98.410095.785.591.198.787.984.794.398.11009910010010087.793.198.389.787.893.210010010065.984.433.398.398.810097.797.21007392.886.7

166/98[aB/Bejing/184/93-likevirus],B/HongKong/330/01,B/Shandong/7/97,B/Brisbane/32/02,andB/Shanghai/361/02).Variousin uenzavirussubtypesthatcirculatedinIsraelbe-tween2000and2004weredetectedbytheTaqManassay.Theseincluded veH3N2subtypes,sevenin uenzaBsub-types,oneH1N1subtype,andoneH1N2subtype.

Comparisonofthemultiplexreal-timeRT-PCR(TaqManassay)toTCwithMDCKcellsasadiagnosticassay.Threehundredseventypatientsampleswerecollectedduringthe2001–2002in uenzaseason.Overall,214patientsampleswerepositiveforin uenzavirusesbythemultiplexTaqManassay,while191patientsampleswerepositivebyTC.ThreepatientsampleswerenegativebytheTaqManassaybutpositivebyTC.Thetotalsensitivity,speci city,positivepredictivevalue(PPV),andnegativepredictivevalue(NPV)were98.4,85.5,87.9,and98.1%,respectively(Table2).

UponanalysisoftheperformanceofthemultiplexTaqManassayforthedetectionofin uenzavirusesAandB,144sam-pleswerepositiveforin uenzavirusAand70sampleswerepositiveforin uenzavirusB.Onehundredtwenty-twosam-pleswerepositiveforin uenzavirusAand66positivewereforin uenzavirusBbyTC.Threesampleswerenegativeforin uenzavirusBbytheTaqManassaybutpositivebyTC.Thesensitivity,speci city,PPV,andNPVoftheTaqManassayforthedetectionofin uenzavirusAwere100,91.1,84.7,and100%,respectively,whilethoseoftheTaqManassayforthedetectionofin uenzavirusBwere95.7,98.7,94.3,and99%,respectively(Table2).

ResolutionofdiscrepantresultsobtainedbyTaqManassay.Seventeenofthe22samplesthatwerepositiveforin uenzavirusAbytheTaqManassaybutnegativebyculturewerealsopositivebyregularRT-PCRwiththesameprimersetsusedintheTaqManassay.Uponretestingofthe22RNAsampleswithadifferentsetofprimersderivedfromtheM-proteingene(20),all22sampleswerepositive.Moreover,theoriginal22samplespositiveforin uenzavirusAbutnegativebyTCwerereextractedandtestedagainbytheTaqManassayandRT-PCRwiththetwosetsofprimerswhosesequenceswerede-rivedfromthesequenceoftheM-proteingene.Seventeensampleswerepositiveforin uenzavirusAbythestandardRT-PCR,andtheother vewerepositivewiththesecondsetoftheM-proteingene-speci cprimers,thuscon rmingtheresultsofthe rstrunandsupportingthesensitivitystudiesthattheTaqManassayismoresensitivethanculture.

Foursamplespositiveforin uenzavirusBbytheTaqManassaybutnegativebyTCwereallpositiveuponretestingbytheTaqManassayandbyRT-PCRwithadifferentsetofprimerswhosesequenceswerebasedonthesequenceoftheNSgene(20).Inaddition,allfoursampleswerepositiveuponreextrac-tionoftheRNAfromtheoriginalsamplesandtestingofthosesamplesbytheTaqManassayandthestandardRT-PCR,inadditiontoassayswiththeprimersetsbasedontheNSgene.Evaluationofthreesamplesthatwerenegativeforin uenzavirusBbytheTaqManassaybutpositivebyTCreveledthatthemultiplexTaqManassayfailedtodetectthevirusinthesethreesamples.Oncetheassaywaschangedfromamultiplexformattoasingleplexformat,theTaqManassaywaspositiveforallthreesamples.Thisindicatesthattherewasnogeneticalterationintheprimerorprobeannealingregions.Allthreesampleswerepositivebythestandardone-stepRT-PCR,con- rmingthatthesesampleswerepositiveforin uenzavirusB.Comparisonofstandardone-stepmultiplexRT-PCRtoTCwithMDCKcells.Thestandardone-stepRT-PCRwasevalu-atedbyusingthesameRNAextractedfromthe370patientsamplesusedtoevaluatetheTaqManassay.Ofthe370patientsamplesevaluated,213sampleswerepositivebyRT-PCR,while191sampleswerepositivebyTC.Twenty-twosampleswerepositivebythestandardRT-PCRandnegativebyTC.Thetotalsensitivity,speci city,PPV,andNPVwere100,87.7,89.7,and100%,respectively(Table2).Uponevaluationoftheperformanceofthemultiplexone-stepRT-PCRassaysforthedetectionanddifferentiationofin uenzavirusesAandB,139patientsampleswerepositiveforin uenzavirusA,whileonly122werepositivebyTC.Thesensitivity,speci city,PPV,andNPVofthemultiplexone-stepRT-PCRforthedetectionofin uenzavirusAwere100,93.1,87.8,and100%,respectively(Table2).

Theone-stepRT-PCRwasassensitiveforthedetectionofin uenzavirusBasitwasforthedetectionofin uenzavirusA.Seventy-fourpatientsampleswerepositiveforin uenzavirusBbythemultiplexRT-PCR,whileonly69patientsam-pleswerepositivebyTC.FivepatientsampleswerepositivebythemultiplexRT-PCRbutnegativebyTC.Thesensitivity,speci city,PPV,andNPVofthemultiplexone-stepRT-PCRforthedetectionofin uenzavirusBwere100,98.3,93.2,and100%,respectively(Table2).ResolutionofthediscrepantresultswasidenticaltothatfortheTaqManassayanalysis,thuscon rmingthattheRT-PCRresultsweretruepositive.

ComparisonofSV-IFAtoTCwithMDCKcells.TheoverallperformanceofSV-IFAforthedetectionofin uenzavirusesAandBwasinferiortothoseofallothermethods.The370patientsamplesevaluatedinthisstudyweretestedforin u-enzavirusesbySV-IFA.Ofthe188patientsamplescon rmedtobepositiveforin uenzavirusesbyTC,126sampleswerepositivebySV-IFA,while65sampleswerenegative.ThreesampleswerepositivebySV-IFAandnegativebyTC.Thetotalsensitivity,speci city,PPV,andNPVofSV-IFAforthe

上一页第4页

你可能喜欢

热门文档

相关文档

站点地图 | 文档上传 | 侵权投诉 | 手机版
本站所有资源均来自互联网,本站只负责收集和整理,均不承担任何法律责任,如有侵权等其它行为请联系我们.
文档下载 Copyright 2013 doc.guandang.net All Rights Reserved.  -  email